The General Star Wars Discussion Thread
#276
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
I never wanted to see another trilogy after IX. The numbered saga should end at IX and not be something that just keeps going on and pointlessly.
After that, do something new like a Obi-Wan movie, a Boba Fett/Bounty Hunters movie, a KOTOR trilogy, a Hundred Years of Darkness trilogy, a trilogy that takes place decads or centuries after IX. The possibilities are endless.
After that, do something new like a Obi-Wan movie, a Boba Fett/Bounty Hunters movie, a KOTOR trilogy, a Hundred Years of Darkness trilogy, a trilogy that takes place decads or centuries after IX. The possibilities are endless.
#277
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
#278
DVD Talk Hero
#279
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
I wouldn’t say that. I wouldn’t have had that scene play out the way it did at all personally. I’d have wanted a more simplistic fight that could have shown Luke as a badass Jedi Master but done believably.
#280
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
I think what he did showed how badass he was as a Jedi Master, but that's for another thread.
#281
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Seems a little telling to me that he conveniently didn’t mention Johnson or his trilogy. Not saying that means it’s cancelled but that’s one of the supposed projects we were getting.
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/ne...owdown-1145493
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/ne...owdown-1145493
#282
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
No, but given Johnson has already directed a film in the franchise and the GoT team has not, I agree with Mike86 it's telliing Iger would not emphasize Johnson's work given the opportunity.
#283
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
He gave one example, the first to pop into his head. Maybe he just got off the phone with the GoT guys before the interview, or it's the one he's looking forward to the most. It's not evidence of anything.
#284
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Why would he omit his name? That to me says they may be reconsidering his trilogy. Whether that means it’s cancelled or there will be changes to it who’s to say, but I don’t think you’d leave out or just forget the name of a director who just did a film for you less than a year ago on accident while mentioning Abrams and people who haven’t done anything for you yet. Also Johnson’s trilogy was announced before the GoT creators trilogy.
My thought is maybe he intentionally left his name out so as not to be directly asked how he felt about how divisive The Last Jedi was.
My thought is maybe he intentionally left his name out so as not to be directly asked how he felt about how divisive The Last Jedi was.
Last edited by Mike86; 09-21-18 at 10:34 AM.
#285
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Maybe because Iger only felt the need to mention one creative "entity" during the interview as an inclusive example, and for whatever reason chose the GoT team as that example.
And I don't think Iger chose his example based on "what project was announced first" or any formal criteria. This wasn't a formal announcement of what projects were still in development. He mentioned the film that's actively in production, and then one of the pre-productions projects, possibly selected at random based on what entered his head first.
And I don't think Iger chose his example based on "what project was announced first" or any formal criteria. This wasn't a formal announcement of what projects were still in development. He mentioned the film that's actively in production, and then one of the pre-productions projects, possibly selected at random based on what entered his head first.
#286
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
But he didn’t mention just one name. He also mentioned Abrams who has Episode IX upcoming. Johnson had his film out less than a year ago and is supposedly directing a trilogy. Abrams is obvious to mention because that’s the next film but it’s weird to omit Johnson when supposedly he’s on board for three more films and yet mention other guys who haven’t done anything for you.
#287
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Iger explicitly said it was an inclusive list. You can't rule out a film because it wasn't mentioned in an incomplete list that explicitly states it includes other projects not mentioned.
#288
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Like I said I’m not saying that’s an indication of the films being cancelled but I just think it’s a rather glaring omission for one reason or another. I also feel like he may have been purposely trying to avoid a question on the divisiveness of The Last Jedi as that interviewer likely would have asked.
#289
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Like I said I’m not saying that’s an indication of the films being cancelled but I just think it’s a rather glaring omission for one reason or another. I also feel like he may have been purposely trying to avoid a question on the divisiveness of The Last Jedi as that interviewer likely would have asked.
He just admitted to being wrong about making too many Star Wars movies. You really think he was scared about being asked about ONE of them? Please.
#290
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
I’m not grasping at anything. I’m taking what he said at face value and speculating on that. I’m hardly the first to have noticed this online. You really think he just didn’t mention Johnson’s name because he only felt the need to give a couple examples?
#291
DVD Talk Legend
#292
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Exactly. It shouldn't be read into at all.
#293
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Again I’m not saying it’s cancelled. I’m just pointing out that it’s weird to have left his name out. It could be that there are some changes being made to the trilogy. Maybe they want to try one and see how it pans out before giving him three. Maybe Johnson is only producing/developing a trilogy but not directing all three.
If anything it seems like fans of The Last Jedi go on the defensive and act like those of us who didn’t care for it have no valid points. It’s odd to not bring up a person you just worked with and announced future projects with. That’s all I’m saying. Not sure how it’s hard to see that for some of you.
If anything it seems like fans of The Last Jedi go on the defensive and act like those of us who didn’t care for it have no valid points. It’s odd to not bring up a person you just worked with and announced future projects with. That’s all I’m saying. Not sure how it’s hard to see that for some of you.
#294
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
- You don't understand the conversation Iger was having, and the context of his statement.
- You want it to be weird, and are reading way too much into it.
You can hate TLJ all you want. This thread isn't about that film.
#295
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
The thread isn’t about The Last Jedi but is about future Star Wars films of which that film’s director is supposed to be in charge of three. Again I’m taking what was said and speculating on that in the thread where that’s what a good chunk of the conversation is about. That makes me wrong or my opinion invalid?
#296
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Someone like Iger is not going to let his words fall carelessly in my opinion.
Of course no one here has any more insight into his thoughts than anyone else. It's all SPECULATION.
Of course no one here has any more insight into his thoughts than anyone else. It's all SPECULATION.
#297
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
I’m not claiming to be right or wrong. People (not you) have cherry picked my posts and assumed differently because of my feelings towards The Last Jedi. I’m just making an observation.
#299
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
Given how much they wanted people to know Johnson was working on that trilogy at the time I do think it's fair to point out how Iger and others no longer mention it. Wouldn't be the first time Disney had made sure a project got a lot of attention and then ignored it hoping people would forget it was ever a thing.
Last edited by hdnmickey; 09-21-18 at 12:24 PM.
#300
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Future Star Wars projects discussion thread - news, rumors, etc.
It's not more valid, it's equally valid, which is the point. Mike86 was asking a number of "why then X?" questions, as if his speculation was the only possible answer. I responded with a number of equally plausible scenarios. The fact that a number of equally valid scenarios can be spun from the same material points out that there's not enough evidence there to accurately infer, well, anything about the RJ trilogy from what Iger said. The interview isn't evidence that the RJ trilogy is cancelled, being reworked, etc., but it's also not evidence that the RJ trilogy is still in production, on schedule, etc. In terms of relevance to RJ's trilogy, the interview is a giant nothing sandwich.



