"Wall-E" ...(An Adventure Beyond the Ordinar-E) reviews thread.
#227
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by JPRaup
I've heard it's just the
Spoiler:
#228
DVD Talk Legend
Caught this in the theater this week - The family and I enjoyed it.
Didn't read through the whole thread, so perhaps someone else has mentioned it. But I go into every Pixar movie with my ears tuned for John Ratzenberger's voice. Halfway through this one I was extra curious how they were going to squeeze him in with so little spoken dialogue.
Didn't read through the whole thread, so perhaps someone else has mentioned it. But I go into every Pixar movie with my ears tuned for John Ratzenberger's voice. Halfway through this one I was extra curious how they were going to squeeze him in with so little spoken dialogue.
#229
Senior Member
Really liked it on the first viewing, I'll have to see it again to decide where it ultimately ends up on the Pixar hierarchy.
Amazing how much personality they got into Wall-E and Eve, with just body language and sounds (and minimal dialogue). And their romance was also surprisingly sweet and just really worked for me.
I'll definitely see this again at the theater, and I'm anxiously awaiting the Blu-Ray release (hopefully by Christmas?).
Amazing how much personality they got into Wall-E and Eve, with just body language and sounds (and minimal dialogue). And their romance was also surprisingly sweet and just really worked for me.
I'll definitely see this again at the theater, and I'm anxiously awaiting the Blu-Ray release (hopefully by Christmas?).
#230
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 852
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Washington, DC
Originally Posted by california9570
I thought the movie was great. Not only could kids enjoy it, but adults got it on a whole nother level. And both age groups can appreciate the great graphics and creativity.
#231
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Jon2
But what was the sound that went with it? It's been bugging me because it sounds so very familiar, but I can't place it. Someone mentioned it sounds like the Sega start up chime but that's only two notes.
It is the apple start up sound.
#232
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by berserker37
and I'm anxiously awaiting the Blu-Ray release (hopefully by Christmas?).
#233
Saw it this morning with my mom and dad. The opening short was great and I thought wall-e was great. Not as good as pixars previous films but still well done. I hope one day they make an animated film geared towards adults. They've proven that they can make a movie with a good story. Why not take a shot at a more serious animated film?
#234
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by mhg83
I hope one day they make an animated film geared towards adults.
#235
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by BigDaddy
It is the apple start up sound.
#236
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Jon2
As I a long-time Mac user I know they used the Mac startup chime for Wall•E, but I'm not familar with previous Apple computers. Was it an original Apple, Apple II, IIe or ?
I am not sure I have a G4 iBook that makes the same sound.
#237
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by NiCK Crush
so nobody knows why Pixar decided not to debut the Up teaser trailer before Wall-E?
I think that it just wasn't ready, but it will be attached to Bolt which is a Disney Flick..
And then we get
#239
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by BigDaddy
I am not sure I have a G4 iBook that makes the same sound.
I know different Macs have slightly different start up sounds, but that's the first I've heard of a multi-note chime for a Mac.
#240
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Greatest. Pixar. Movie. Ever.
Seriously, wow.
Seriously, wow.
I feel the same way. I'm in love with the little guy. Going back to see it for a third time sometime this week.
#243
Originally Posted by baracine
Just a reminder that, several days before the film opened, by sheer coincidence, I added an Intermission to my long list of "films that are ahead of their time" - and that Intermission is an excerpt from Hello, Dolly! 
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...&postcount=159
I did this because it suddenly dawned on me that Hello, Dolly! (Gene Kelly, 1969) was largely unrecognized as the last and possibly the greatest achievement in movie musicals of the last century, using modern technical advances in the staging and photography of a traditional musical, before the genre almost disappeared.
If I had the energy, I would also add The Incredibles (Brad Bird, 2004), Ratatouille (Brad Bird, Jan Pinkava, 2007) and Wall-E (Andrew Stanton, 2008) to the list for "sheer narrative brilliance and advances in the art of characterization as well as computer animation".

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showpost.ph...&postcount=159
I did this because it suddenly dawned on me that Hello, Dolly! (Gene Kelly, 1969) was largely unrecognized as the last and possibly the greatest achievement in movie musicals of the last century, using modern technical advances in the staging and photography of a traditional musical, before the genre almost disappeared.
If I had the energy, I would also add The Incredibles (Brad Bird, 2004), Ratatouille (Brad Bird, Jan Pinkava, 2007) and Wall-E (Andrew Stanton, 2008) to the list for "sheer narrative brilliance and advances in the art of characterization as well as computer animation".
#246
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 9,447
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boston, MA
A little late to the party here, but just saw it, and it was amazing. Definite 5 star, and by far the best Pixar movie in my opinion. I will be grabbing this on DVD day 1.
#247
Banned
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 966
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't get why people are liking this so much. There wasn't that much really to the story (not compared to other PIXAR films like Bug's Life). No songs, very little dialogue, very few characters, nothing really memorable about it.
From the reviews, you would think it would be as spectacular as the second coming of Christ. Hardly.
From the reviews, you would think it would be as spectacular as the second coming of Christ. Hardly.
#248
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Originally Posted by shifrbv
I don't get why people are liking this so much. There wasn't that much really to the story (not compared to other PIXAR films like Bug's Life). No songs, very little dialogue, very few characters, nothing really memorable about it.
From the reviews, you would think it would be as spectacular as the second coming of Christ. Hardly.
From the reviews, you would think it would be as spectacular as the second coming of Christ. Hardly.
One dimensional characters, a heavy handed message, humor limited to silly slapstick. This pales in comparison to other Pixar films. How one can think it on the same level as Bug's Life or one of the Toy Stories amazes me.
A brief snippet from Brian's review here seems spot on to me. "the spark of the film is in constant threat of being snuffed out by the habitual elongation of the ice-thin story. I wasn't moved by Wall-E's Chaplinesque mishaps and intergalactic dreams, just agitated that Stanton doesn't take the character past infantilization or offer something more than pratfalls for our hero to undertake. Wall-E's shtick tires quickly.
To some, Wall-E is an adorable character with rich emotional professions, and that's all the cinematic nutrition they need from this picture. I craved that sensation while watching "Wall-E," but it never arrived. Instead I was left bored and insulted by a misguided, preachy film riddled with absurd messages and run into the ground by complete storytelling lethargy. But that Wall-E sure is cute, huh?"
#249
Originally Posted by shifrbv
I don't get why people are liking this so much. There wasn't that much really to the story (not compared to other PIXAR films like Bug's Life). No songs, very little dialogue, very few characters, nothing really memorable about it.
From the reviews, you would think it would be as spectacular as the second coming of Christ. Hardly.
From the reviews, you would think it would be as spectacular as the second coming of Christ. Hardly.
#250
DVD Talk Hero
I gave it a B- after seeing the film, and struggled with that rating. I was sort of befuddled by all the praise, but then I just ascribed it to this being the kind of film that evokes a certain reaction depending on how much personal baggage you bring in with you, and then are confronted with images of over-consumption and environmental issues. Some folks enjoy the "love" story between 2 robots, while others weren't too keen at being preached at given Disney's involvement with the film (and profiting from consumption of Wall-E goods). Perhaps it's a litmus test for one's outlook on life in general, but it's the kind of movie with little no middle ground between its supporters and detractors.



