DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Superman Returns Sequel is a GO! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/481950-superman-returns-sequel-go.html)

Solid Snake 05-30-10 05:00 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Let's remember artistically...the 80s was a bad decade. The greatest thing in the world in that decade was action movies. American and HK for sure..it was gold!!!! Also...Ninjas galore. So Sly was doing his best shit in the 80s for the most part. His time in the 90s...well it started to slump here sadly...but he's back and seems to want to blow his load on movies w/ the GREATEST ACTION MOVIE EVER!!!!! So it's all good.

JumpCutz 05-30-10 11:37 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt (Post 10186049)
He was also very good in First Blood, Rocky Balboa, CopLand and (the VERY underrated) Oscar. Don't shortchange the guy because he "sold out" for a lot of "phone them in" performances in the 80s. EVERYONE was doing that in the 80s (yes, even YOU, Tom Hanks).

I appreciate your opinion, we'll just have to agree to disagree. I thought he was just serviceable in First Blood and Rocky Balboa. In Copland he was overshadowed by far superior actors and it was such a self-consciously "understated" performance, I just couldn't buy into it completely.

I have never seen Oscar, I should probably catch up with that, but I thought his comedic turns in 'Rhinestone' and 'Stop Or My Mom will Shoot' were almost embarrassing.

But, hey, he's a likable guy and I'm hoping he delivers in spades with 'The Expendables'. :thumbsup:

stingermck 07-13-10 12:26 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
More 'Superman' Rumors: Zachary Levi Auditions, Jonathan Nolan to Direct?


Looks like it's about that time for the Superman rumors to start infiltrating our Man of Steel-lovin' brains as folks at Warner Bros. apparently move toward the next step of production by seeking out a director and star. While last week's rumor that Chris Columbus was up for the directorial gig was quickly debunked, the fact that we're beginning to hear more and more rumblings probably means the wheels are definitely beginning to turn.

This latest rumor comes from Geek Tyrant, who claim their sources "on the lot" have informed them that Jonathan Nolan (Christopher Nolan's brother) is currently the "unannounced director" of the new Superman movie. The other Nolan has been rumored to be up for the gig ever since his brother came onboard to sort of "godfather" the project with writer David Goyer. I'm not sure if Warners would give such a large project to a first-time director like Jonathan, especially with Christopher off waist-deep in another Batman movie and not readily available to help his brother out. That said, if there was a package deal agreed upon when Nolan and Goyer came on -- and if that deal involved Jonathan directing the movie -- then maybe there is some truth to it. If that wasn't originally part of the deal, though, then I just don't see them trusting this big of a movie to a first-time director. But I guess we'll see.

The other part of the rumor is a lot more intriguing to me as it signals the start of another casting circus. And if it's anything like the recent Spider-Man casting debacle, then we're in for one heckuva overly annoying ride. Find out who they're looking at after the jump ...


I really dig Zachary Levi. If it was up to me, I'd halt everything right here and sign the guy up to play Superman. One thing Levi brings to the table that Routh didn't is instant charisma. You can't help but like the guy. If you've watched the TV show Chuck, then you're familiar with Levi -- you know he can do the clumsy, fish-out-of-water thing -- but at the end of the day he's got a great contemporary Clark Kent look going on, and he's definitely capable of turning on the action if need be. Plus he's not too big of a name, but he's familiar enough to get people excited about the project. I like Levi. I like Levi a lot.

Whether or not this is just another bogus rumor or if there's some truth to it, we don't really know just yet (I'd expect to hear denials from the Levi camp within 24 hours). What do you think about Levi as Superman? Does he work? And what about Jonathan Nolan as director? Shouldn't the guy have to prove himself in front of the camera before landing one of the biggest (and most important) directorial gigs of the decade?
http://www.cinematical.com/2010/07/1...athan-nolan-t/

RocShemp 07-13-10 12:33 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Chuck as Superman? :lol:rotfl

Oh wait you're serious.... :confused:

Michael Corvin 07-13-10 12:38 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Zachary Levi as Clark/Supes? Wow, that's huge. I'm totally down with that. Sign him now, avoid the casting circus that all these movies tend to go through.

MrSmearkase 07-13-10 12:41 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
No to Levi. Go with another unknown.

Although, it is kind of interesting that he is now rumored for the role, as he has shared considerable screentime with both Routh and Matthew Bomer on Chuck, as well as Adam Baldwin, who voiced Supes in Superman Doomsday.

stingermck 07-13-10 12:41 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
At first I thought it was stupid, but then the article made me think. He is a modern day Clark Kent, he can do the action, and he has a good look. It could work...

Numanoid 07-13-10 04:11 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Oh cripes, just get Routh back. -ohbfrank-

Bob_Bobbson 07-13-10 04:16 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Numanoid (Post 10263667)
Oh cripes, just get Routh back. -ohbfrank-

I'm actually waiting for them to approach someone else again...

http://www.solarnavigator.net/films_...man_outfit.jpg


Okay, not really. :lol:

I actually liked Routh a lot as Supes/Kent. Seriously, I wouldn't mind seeing him back, as long as there was a better script this time.

Artman 07-13-10 04:48 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10263123)
Chuck as Superman? :lol:rotfl

Oh wait you're serious....

Lol, I had assumed it must be someone else on the show, not...chuck. I couldn't think of a faster way to make me lose interest in this. If they're trying to make a spoof than sure...it could work.

Blu Man 07-13-10 05:38 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Bob_Bobbson (Post 10263678)
I actually liked Routh a lot as Supes/Kent. Seriously, I wouldn't mind seeing him back, as long as there was a better script this time.

This. Routh is the perfect Superman in my opinion. He was excellent as Superman even in a mediocre movie, so I'm definitely holding out the hope that he will be cast again.

reverie 07-13-10 05:52 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Blu Man (Post 10263780)
This. Routh is the perfect Superman in my opinion. He was excellent as Superman even in a mediocre movie, so I'm definitely holding out the hope that he will be cast again.

I totally agree.. I really liked Routh, and besides, I'm tired of constant recasts in the superhero movies.

Solid Snake 07-13-10 05:57 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
The problem with him being Superman was the script. EVERYTHING ELSE about him was fine. He played a good Kent. Just.....Superman...didn't talk....much. also....I KNOW wtf he does all the time..he saves people. Gimme something where Superman actually has a real fight for his life and hey! Earth can be at stake too! Just get a good script.

TheMovieman 07-13-10 06:05 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
I've been watching White Collar lately and know that Matthew Bomer was up for the role and think he'd be a solid choice if they want to start anew and not go with Routh again (though I hope they do).

Iron_Giant 07-13-10 06:55 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
LOVE ROTH!!!! He is perfect for Clark/Supes.

Bring on S3. Brainiac or Darkseid are the only two that will make the movie awesome. Darkseid gets my vote.

It will make tons of money and sell boat loads of BR.

Do you hear us DC/Warner?

Mike86 07-13-10 07:21 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Maybe I'm wrong but I thought with the rumors of Nolan being on board for this that this movie was going to be a sort of start over/origins story for Superman. If that is the case I think that while Routh was a good fit for the role they should go with someone else so as not to confuse the new film for a sequel to Superman Returns. If on the other hand this is going to be a sequel to that movie I'd have no problem with Routh being brought back.

One thing I'd like to see in this new film is have a different villain besides Lex Luthor. I realize that he's Superman's main villain but it seems like that's the only character ever used as a villain in the Superman movies and its getting really old. I'm not that huge on Superman so I don't know about his entire rogues gallery but there has to be others that could be used.

MrSmearkase 07-13-10 07:55 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 10263969)
One thing I'd like to see in this new film is have a different villain besides Lex Luthor. I realize that he's Superman's main villain but it seems like that's the only character ever used as a villain in the Superman movies and its getting really old. I'm not that huge on Superman so I don't know about his entire rogues gallery but there has to be others that could be used.

I wouldn't have a problem with more Lex, but for Christ's sake, lay off the land schemes!

resinrats 07-13-10 08:45 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Maybe have Lex behind the scenes using the other super powered villian as muscle. Go with the CEO route like in the cartoon. Superman knows he's evil but he can't prove anything so he can't touch him.

Superman07 07-13-10 08:51 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Mike86 (Post 10263969)
Maybe I'm wrong but I thought with the rumors of Nolan being on board for this that this movie was going to be a sort of start over/origins story for Superman. If that is the case I think that while Routh was a good fit for the role they should go with someone else so as not to confuse the new film for a sequel to Superman Returns. If on the other hand this is going to be a sequel to that movie I'd have no problem with Routh being brought back.

One thing I'd like to see in this new film is have a different villain besides Lex Luthor. I realize that he's Superman's main villain but it seems like that's the only character ever used as a villain in the Superman movies and its getting really old. I'm not that huge on Superman so I don't know about his entire rogues gallery but there has to be others that could be used.

How might somebody get confused?

I also don't have a problem with more Lex. I would just have a problem with a poorly written Lex. In fact, Spacey was fine in the role, but it was just written very poorly. Although I'm sure Clancy Brown is free too. ;)

raven56706 07-13-10 08:54 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
sucks... please no to chuck as supes....

Patman 07-13-10 09:08 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by TheMovieman (Post 10263838)
I've been watching White Collar lately and know that Matthew Bomer was up for the role and think he'd be a solid choice if they want to start anew and not go with Routh again (though I hope they do).

Bomer's too short, and his physique is too slight.

Blu Man 07-13-10 09:10 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by raven56706 (Post 10264132)
sucks... please no to chuck as supes....

+1

Just seeing Zach stand next to Routh in Chuck is enough for him to not get the job. He simply doesn't have the physique or attitude that Superman needs. Routh has it all.

Solid Snake 07-13-10 09:13 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Has it all but a damn script that's good!

Blu Man 07-13-10 09:19 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 

Originally Posted by Solid Snake PAC (Post 10264178)
Has it all but a damn script that's good!

Well since Nolan's name is attached to the project the script won't have a problem, the studio just needs to give Routh another chance to shine. Come on WB, come on.

Solid Snake 07-13-10 09:21 PM

Re: Superman Returns Sequel is a GO!
 
Oh I know but that's my only fault to Routh as Supes/Kent. And it's not his fault..just the limitations given to him.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:35 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.