Word on 'Da Vinci Code' ? Not good.
#101
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 5,494
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Cromwell, CT
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
I picked DaVinci Code to be the highest grossing for this season, but looks like it may not have legs to do that, but it will have a huge opening.
I think you're overestimating this one a bit. Who's the market? It definitely doesn't have wide appeal unless your a big Tom Hanks fan..........
#102
Suspended
NEWS FLASH!!! The www.rottentomatoes.com/m/da_vinci_code/ site has just crashed under the weight of all those tomatoes!!!
Cache:http://72.14.207.104/search?q=cache:...a&ct=clnk&cd=1
Cache:http://72.14.207.104/search?q=cache:...a&ct=clnk&cd=1
#103
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by JaxComet
I think you're overestimating this one a bit. Who's the market? It definitely doesn't have wide appeal unless your a big Tom Hanks fan..........
#104
Suspended
Originally Posted by Sierra Disc
You are kidding, right? 40 million copies of the book sold. That's the market. Whether it's a good movie or sucks, it'll definitely have at least $50 million opening weekend. Long term, who knows, but the movie certainly has a wide appeal.
#105
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 5,494
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Cromwell, CT
Originally Posted by Sierra Disc
You are kidding, right? 40 million copies of the book sold. That's the market. Whether it's a good movie or sucks, it'll definitely have at least $50 million opening weekend. Long term, who knows, but the movie certainly has a wide appeal.
Many book readers hate movie adaptations.. They also lose most of the teen to early 20's group as many won't even know the hell this flick is all about. Granted it will have a big opening week due to Hanks but I'd expect it to fall hard and fast. The reviews thus far have been brutal..........
The opening of Over the Hedge (good or bad) will steal some of TDC's take as well.........
Last edited by JaxComet; 05-19-06 at 02:00 PM.
#106
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,376
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: St. Albans, England (UK)
Originally Posted by marty888
Same here. It appears that some of the negativity has more to do with the basic concept, rather than the realization on film. Since the imaginative (some would say outlandish) plotting didn't seem to hinder the book sales .....
However the reviews I've read so far in England have been pretty crap too.I've seen Paul Bettany on posters and in clips - doesnt he look a bit like Palpatine in Revenge of the Sith?
#107
Needs to contact an admin about multiple accounts
Joined: Mar 1999
Posts: 472
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New Jersey
Rate it a 6.5 or B-
It's a treasure hunt picture along the lines of National Treasure with religous overtones.(Though I liked National Treasure and it's fun energy more than Da Vinci Code film) I read the book 2 years ago and the movie is very much faithful to the book except for some details(needlessly changed). I'm not sure but the movie lacked a certain sense of energy or emergency, a certain vitality. It was a workman like movie but not great. It was not a page turner like the novel It was good but.... felt slightly self important.
Maybe because I read the novel and knew the story and outcome the movie lost some of it's effect. Good, not as good a movie or as fun as MI3 or Poseidon. Runs a little long at 2:29, Howard could have chopped 10-15 minutes from the story.
It's a treasure hunt picture along the lines of National Treasure with religous overtones.(Though I liked National Treasure and it's fun energy more than Da Vinci Code film) I read the book 2 years ago and the movie is very much faithful to the book except for some details(needlessly changed). I'm not sure but the movie lacked a certain sense of energy or emergency, a certain vitality. It was a workman like movie but not great. It was not a page turner like the novel It was good but.... felt slightly self important.
Maybe because I read the novel and knew the story and outcome the movie lost some of it's effect. Good, not as good a movie or as fun as MI3 or Poseidon. Runs a little long at 2:29, Howard could have chopped 10-15 minutes from the story.
Last edited by sabre; 05-19-06 at 05:59 PM.
#108
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by sabre
...religish overtones...
I'm going to see this later today, and I can say for certain that my expectations are definitely lowered. At this point, I'm more curious to see what is so bad about it rather than being excited to see what they did right.
#109
I'm not going to see this. This movie isn't getting bad reviews because of being religious/anti-religious, hype, or because it's not as good as the book. It's getting bad reviews because it sucks. Frankly, I'm tired of these big overblown Hollywood productions.
#110
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,550
Received 1,658 Likes
on
1,176 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
I never read the book and I'm wondering why it's getting really bad press. I think it's a better film than that. Yes, the acting is a bit flat, but the plot is overtly serious in nature. Everyone is supposed to be brooding. From the nature and tone of the story, I expected this kind of flat acting. What, would it be more in tone if Will Smith was cast in the lead and does his usual, "OH HELL NO", when he comes across a dead body or something?
I enjoyed it but I didn't find anything bad about it, yet at the same time I didn't find it spectacular. It was good, plot cliches aside.
I enjoyed it but I didn't find anything bad about it, yet at the same time I didn't find it spectacular. It was good, plot cliches aside.
#111
Originally Posted by Sierra Disc
You are kidding, right? 40 million copies of the book sold. That's the market. Whether it's a good movie or sucks, it'll definitely have at least $50 million opening weekend. Long term, who knows, but the movie certainly has a wide appeal.
#112
Originally Posted by JaxComet
Many book readers hate movie adaptations.. They also lose most of the teen to early 20's group as many won't even know the hell this flick is all about. Granted it will have a big opening week due to Hanks but I'd expect it to fall hard and fast. The reviews thus far have been brutal..........
The opening of Over the Hedge (good or bad) will steal some of TDC's take as well.........
The opening of Over the Hedge (good or bad) will steal some of TDC's take as well.........
#114
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,104
Received 1,717 Likes
on
1,409 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Originally Posted by sabre
religish overtones
Originally Posted by FinkPish
What kind of overtones?
overtones
#116
Suspended
The guys who will really have it tough this weekend are the albino mullets, also known as mullbinos... already a misunderstood minority, now terminally undecided about seeing "The Da Vinci Code"...










Last edited by baracine; 05-19-06 at 05:28 PM.
#117
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Dec 1999
Posts: 2,632
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Long Island
Originally Posted by Sierra Disc
You are kidding, right? 40 million copies of the book sold. That's the market. Whether it's a good movie or sucks, it'll definitely have at least $50 million opening weekend. Long term, who knows, but the movie certainly has a wide appeal.
#118
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 9,921
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Guelph, Ontario
Well I was certainly disappointed. I wasn't letting the negative reviews disuade me from seeing this, because I thought the book was a fast paced fun piece of pop fiction and was hoping for the same thrilling, fun
of a movie...but somehow, in sticking TOO CLOSELY to the book, they managed to make a movie that isn't nearly as fun, thrilling or interesting as IT thinks it is.
I think had they condensed some things, streamlined events and exposition and beefed up the action a bit (or at least better mine the action out of the few scenes in the film) it could have been a great 100min thrill ride. But instead, they chose to be slavishly true and lost all the "essence" of what made the book great in the first place.
It's tough to see Tom Hanks and Audrey both turn in ridgid, stiff and dull performances, but somehow, Howard manages to turn both leads into the cinematic equivalent of carrots dangling on a string, leading the audience along on a ride that seems to think the destination is more important than the journey. I'm sure anyone who hated the book is going to LOATHE the movie. I thought Paul Bettany was pretty good (although, I know 2 albinos, and they got the eyes wrong) and Ian McKellan was the films saving grace.
I think if the film had been in the hands of another creative team, we could have had something really special. Howard is in his element with stuff like "Cinderella Man" but like "The Missing" action/thrillers are not his fortay - both Missing and DaVinci are great eye candy, but they manage to take excellent ideas and dilute them with overlong running times, stiff acting and lackluster pacing.
The first real bitter disappointment of the summer for me. Hopefully X3 next week will put things back on track.
MATT
p.s. I find it funny how critics/audiences all called "National Treasure" the lite version of DaVinci Code...and now that both films are here, "National Treasure" ended up being the one that ACTUALLY delivered.
Spoiler:
I think had they condensed some things, streamlined events and exposition and beefed up the action a bit (or at least better mine the action out of the few scenes in the film) it could have been a great 100min thrill ride. But instead, they chose to be slavishly true and lost all the "essence" of what made the book great in the first place.
It's tough to see Tom Hanks and Audrey both turn in ridgid, stiff and dull performances, but somehow, Howard manages to turn both leads into the cinematic equivalent of carrots dangling on a string, leading the audience along on a ride that seems to think the destination is more important than the journey. I'm sure anyone who hated the book is going to LOATHE the movie. I thought Paul Bettany was pretty good (although, I know 2 albinos, and they got the eyes wrong) and Ian McKellan was the films saving grace.
I think if the film had been in the hands of another creative team, we could have had something really special. Howard is in his element with stuff like "Cinderella Man" but like "The Missing" action/thrillers are not his fortay - both Missing and DaVinci are great eye candy, but they manage to take excellent ideas and dilute them with overlong running times, stiff acting and lackluster pacing.
The first real bitter disappointment of the summer for me. Hopefully X3 next week will put things back on track.
MATT
p.s. I find it funny how critics/audiences all called "National Treasure" the lite version of DaVinci Code...and now that both films are here, "National Treasure" ended up being the one that ACTUALLY delivered.
#119
Originally Posted by exm
It's really a guess, but I would say it makes around $25m opening weekend. So many people I speak with that are regulars in the movies are skipping this one.
#122
DVD Talk Legend
Saw it. Thought both the book and the movie were pretty good, but nothing more than that level. I agree with the claim that they were too faithful to the book; did we really need to have Silas' backstory, not to mention so much background on both Langdon and Sophie? Akiva Goldsman sure didn't have problems tinkering with some of source material for A Beautiful Mind, wish he had done so in this case. Like I said, entertaining, but paint by the numbers at best. Action/Thriller really isn't Ron Howard's strong point as a director, as most of his attempts at darker material like Ransom and The Missing are rather lackluster IMO. This movie seemed like he was trying to be Brian DePalma, which is like Spielberg trying to be Kubrick.
So in a nutshell, and I hate to say this, I am counting on a movie directed by Brett Ratner to kick my summer movies into high gear. How scary is that? The movies thus far have not been that bad (well, Poseidon was), but none of them have floored me like the days of Gladiator, Indiana Jones, or the Star Wars movies did in summers past.
So in a nutshell, and I hate to say this, I am counting on a movie directed by Brett Ratner to kick my summer movies into high gear. How scary is that? The movies thus far have not been that bad (well, Poseidon was), but none of them have floored me like the days of Gladiator, Indiana Jones, or the Star Wars movies did in summers past.
#124
DVD Talk Hero
16% at Rotten Tomatoes
First box office reports
First box office reports
Predominantly Catholic countries like Italy and Mexico close to breaking box office records. In Italy, Da Vinci Code seeing huge grosses, and, based on an exit poll there, 75 percent thumbs up, 15 percent neutral, and 10 percent not liking.*
Same thing happened around the U.S.: for instance, TV news reports in Portland, Ore, and Miami Beach, Fla., are featuring quickie interviews with just-out-of-screening moviegoers and they're loving it. (Do film critics matter any more?) Early reports say the matinees out of New York City were "giant-sized." I've learned that Sony execs are "very happy."
#125
Senior Member
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 501
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Hualien, Taiwan
I just got back from seeing this. I enjoyed it and it was very very close to the book. A little slow I admit, but it doesn't deserve the negative feedback either from the public or the church. Get over it people!!



