DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   overrated cult classics (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/369376-overrated-cult-classics.html)

Keyser Soze 06-14-04 02:14 AM


Originally posted by Matt Millheiser
Donnie freakin' Darko :thmbsdwn:
I'm watching this dvd right now (and enjoying it again)

:lol:

-k
###

FuzzyBallz 06-14-04 03:55 AM

Let me see...

- Brazil - Huh?
- This Is Spinal Tap - I don't this is a parody at all.

Michael Corvin 06-14-04 06:44 AM


Originally posted by Calculon
1. Escape from New York

:up: It was a decent movie, but it definitely gets more praise than it deserves.

and I will add:
Blade Runner

PixyJunket 06-14-04 08:16 AM


Originally posted by Matt Millheiser
Donnie freakin' Darko :thmbsdwn:
Amen to that, what an uninteresting turd of a movie.

Hiro11 06-14-04 08:34 AM


Originally posted by FuzzyBallz
- This Is Spinal Tap - I don't this is a parody at all.
... ... .... ........... ohhhhkaaaaay...

Giles 06-14-04 08:48 AM

'Can't Stop the Music' - I was expecting a lot more music :D

DVDho78DTS 06-14-04 09:13 AM


Originally posted by scott1598
"Near Dark"

Didn't think it was a good vampire movie, horror movie or any movie at all.

I watched this recently and thought the same thing.

I like Donnie Darko even more now after seeing those who don't like it. -ptth- :lol:

custom001 06-14-04 09:20 AM

Memento.

Not as clever as it wants to be.

xmiyux 06-14-04 09:43 AM

All this talk of Donnie Darko is making me curious - i saw the first 15 minutes one day and it seemed like a very slow odd movie and i haven't seen anymore since. Maybe i need to check it out. Does it get creepy or surreal or what later on?

chanster 06-14-04 09:44 AM

Barely.

whynotsmile 06-14-04 10:16 AM

i agree with SPINAL TAP. way overrated. i own it but didnt finish it. im sure ill pick it up again. Just didnt make me laugh. Best in show was 10 times better IMO.

Also, DEad alive is one of my favorite films ever. I actually think dead alive is a bit UNDERRATED since evil dead 2 steals all its thunder

fumanstan 06-14-04 10:59 AM


Originally posted by Michael Corvin

Blade Runner

:up: Great visuals but incredibly slow and boring to me.

NaturalMystic79 06-14-04 11:25 AM

Ferris Bueller's Day Off. <-- did not understand what all the hype was about.

Rival11 06-14-04 11:33 AM

Little off topic but since it's been mentioned a bunch of times - is Dead Alive scary at all?

It looks freakin' fantastic and it's a cheap buy and I'm in the mood for a SCARY gorefest.

Even if it's not freaky thorughout - how scary is it?

whynotsmile 06-14-04 11:36 AM

its not scary at all. its very gory, but there is nothing remotely scary about it. its 100 percent violent comedy. unless you are a 5 year old, nothing will scare you.

Rival11 06-14-04 11:42 AM


Originally posted by whynotsmile
its not scary at all. its very gory, but there is nothing remotely scary about it. its 100 percent violent comedy. unless you are a 5 year old, nothing will scare you.
Are you serious? Sorry but the Exorcist 1 & 3 freak me out to no end.

Well, thanks for the Dead Alive tip.

wordtoyamotha 06-14-04 11:54 AM

One movie comes to mind: Fight Club

*ducks behind bullet proof wall*

gmal2003 06-14-04 11:57 AM

Lost In Translation

TheAllPurposeNothing 06-14-04 11:59 AM

Buckaroo Banzai
UHF

BTW, Rushmore rules!

Daytripper 06-14-04 12:00 PM


Originally posted by NaturalMystic79
Ferris Bueller's Day Off. <-- did not understand what all the hype was about.
I didn't realize this was even considered a cult movie.

Re: "Donnie Darko". O.K., I can see where some might feel it's overrated. But no way is it a "turd of a movie". It wasn't even the worst film released that week. Until this thread, I've never seen anyone say anything bad about it.

necros 06-14-04 12:08 PM

Here's another vote for Rocky Horror. It's just fookin stupid.

As far as evil dead goes, I LOVE Army of Darkness (the 3rd movie). However, I think the first 2 are just aweful. A friend of mine loves em all and worships the ground Rami and Bruce Campbell walk on, but I just can't get into them. I hated Dead Alive too.

freudguy 06-14-04 12:44 PM

I never have liked Army of Darkness as much as ED 1 & 2, but do not consider it overrated.

My picks for overrated:

Easy Rider - maybe it means more to those that grew up during this generation. I don't deny the effect it had on people when it first came out, but it didn't appeal to me. I always thought Electra Glide in Blue was a better movie.

Another vote for Rocky Horror - blecch

Not really movies but I never liked Xena or Hercules, a bit too campy for me.

Looking at some of the other lists in this thread, many of you wouldn't like my library of flicks ;)

Rival11 06-14-04 12:47 PM


Originally posted by necros
Here's another vote for Rocky Horror. It's just fookin stupid.
I started watching some of it and couldn't believe how bad it was - then it got worse when somebody told me all of the rituals that go on in the theater - freakin' horrible.

Drop 06-14-04 12:50 PM

I'll agree with Escape from NY. It was a fun entertaining movie, but it wasn't as cool as I was hoping, and was pretty damn chessy. That probably comes from the fact that I saw Escape from LA first. So it was also a case of been there, done that. I perfer LA over NY, it just seemed like a better made film. I imagine if I saw NY first though, I'd have the opposite opinion.

A side note about my other side note. It's not that I lose respect for a poster (poor choice of words), it's just I value their opinion less. I still like them as people, I just can't trust a reccomendation of theirs as much anymore. But that's just how opinions go, no one is going to agree on anything %100, let alone something as personal as films, and the even more personal Cult flicks.

DodgingCars 06-14-04 12:58 PM


Originally posted by Numanoid
This whole discussion is rather silly. Cult Classics, by definition, appeal to only a select group (you know, the "cult" part). Which naturally means that the majority will not be big fans. If you consider one to be "overrated", I guess that means you just don't happen to be in that particular cult.
Maybe it should have asked: Which are most overrated on DVDTalk.

:)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:08 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.