DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   overrated cult classics (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/369376-overrated-cult-classics.html)

whynotsmile 06-12-04 04:06 PM

overrated cult classics
 
what are some cult classics that you just dont enjoy, or think is overrated?

my picks: REEFER MADNESS and SHAFT

zak52 06-12-04 04:44 PM

Repo Man

MSD 06-12-04 04:51 PM

HALLOWEEN

PopcornTreeCt 06-12-04 06:45 PM

Rocky Horror Picture Show -God, that movie is AWFUL!

BigPete 06-12-04 07:14 PM

Almost all cult classics are overrated by some percentage of the fanbase.

Everything from Full Metal Jacket to Monty Python and the Holy Grail and Attack of the Killer Tomatoes is spoiled to some degree by people who heap on praise in the hope of being seen as cool by their peers. In many cases, perhaps most obvious with Kubrick films, the most vocal audience is praising the movie with no concept of the actual film or its implications. They see 'ultra-violence' and run with it from there.

PopcornTreeCt 06-12-04 07:41 PM

hey man Full Metal Jacket is a great film. The Shining on the other hand isn't.

RyoHazuki 06-12-04 07:46 PM

The Shining is the 2nd best horror movie ever. Great film.

Reefer Madness is a cult classic BECAUSE it sucks.

conscience 06-12-04 07:52 PM

Full Metal Jacket? The Shining?

<strike>Cult</strike> Classics

RandyC 06-12-04 08:27 PM

Eraserhead

I don't know... but though it evoked something very creepy, it was just a little too strange.

Repo Man was better, but not something I would watch again.

whynotsmile 06-12-04 09:08 PM

FMJ i would never think of a cult classic. well, maybe the first half. i mean, theres a doll out and everything. Oh, and for the record, shining was great IMO.


reefer madness sadly bored me. there was some funny stuff but overall it was just too "straight" and "normal" nothing really hilariously over the top

MahatmaPetey 06-12-04 10:55 PM

i have to agree with Reefer Madness. Thank God I only paid $5 for the cheapo version. I was expecting something a lot more crazy than it was.

cruzness 06-12-04 11:05 PM

Rocky Horror Picture Show.
I don't get it. I was even taken to one of the midnight shows with people dressed up like characters and I just didn't understand the whole fascination with it.

RandyC 06-12-04 11:54 PM


Originally posted by cruzness
Rocky Horror Picture Show.
I don't get it. I was even taken to one of the midnight shows with people dressed up like characters and I just didn't understand the whole fascination with it.

WHAT!??!

It's Astounding!

Time is fleeting

Madness... takes it toll.

fumanstan 06-12-04 11:57 PM

Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

Hokeyboy 06-13-04 12:34 AM

Donnie freakin' Darko :thmbsdwn:

Abranut 06-13-04 12:36 AM

200 Motels, Freaks.

kninestile 06-13-04 12:45 AM

Good Burger.

Rival11 06-13-04 12:51 AM

Rushmore - horrible movie.

Gizmo 06-13-04 12:55 AM


Originally posted by Rival11
Rushmore - horrible movie.
WHAT, WHAT WHAT ?!?!?

Rival11 06-13-04 12:59 AM


Originally posted by GizmoDVD
WHAT, WHAT WHAT ?!?!?
To me, this is one of the worst movies ever made but hey, that's my opinion.

CKMorpheus 06-13-04 01:03 AM

Donnie Darko

Mountain Biker 06-13-04 02:34 AM

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre - good, but way overrated

Blake 06-13-04 02:44 AM

Harold and Maude

Tyler_Durden 06-13-04 02:44 AM


Originally posted by Matt Millheiser
Donnie freakin' Darko :thmbsdwn:
I agree.

Panda Phil 06-13-04 03:16 AM


Originally posted by cruzness
Rocky Horror Picture Show.
I don't get it. I was even taken to one of the midnight shows with people dressed up like characters and I just didn't understand the whole fascination with it.

Saw it a few times. Thought it was a fun movie right up until the 'Sweet Transvestite' number. Just got borig as hell from that point on.


I never understood the point of putting films like this out on video. Rocky Horror and Reefer Madness are meant to be watched in a theater full of rabid fans, not in the privacy of your living room.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:27 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.