Mike86

I'd almost consider doing this if I could get the films on disc. I don't have a Blu-ray burner and wouldn't want to invest in one for just these films though. I really think there's a chance we may one day get the original Original Trilogy officially released. My guess is if it happens though they'll make us shell out for it and make us buy all the films in one set.

hanshotfirst1138

I was wonder that, I admire fan editors who work from big masters, but I suppose that getting it back onto something can watch when it's 50 GB would be harder, I guess that you would either need big Blu-rays and a Blu-ray burner, or you would have to put it onto an external hard drive with a lot of space, one of the two. I live in mortal fear of getting an illegal fan edit in finding someone in a position of legal authority at my door telling me that orange really IS the new black, Plus I might have a she's playing them back, but a number of them are quite intriguing to me… This one is a course at the top of that list, and it looks like it's the best we're ever going to get.

E Unit

The 50GB blu's usually cost 2-3 times more than a 25GB disc. You can get a spindle of 25GB discs on sale for under $20, but buying the same with 50GB discs cost $40-50. And then just hope the burn is done correctly the first time. They can become costly mistakes. But just as an FYI, the Harmy version of Episode IV comes in under 25GB, so a single layer blu works just fine.

rocket1312

Do you have a dvd burner? There are AVCHD versions (burn on a dual layer DVD, but disc is formatted as a BD) out there and the full size ones can be streamed to your BD player or played via usb.

I don't want to tell you that it's not illegal to download these. Even in the most liberal interpretations of the law, it's a gray area at best. If you choose not to download because you're taking a moral stand, then that's commendable. If you're not downloading because you are afraid of the police showing up to your door, then I don't know what to say other than THEY DO NOT CARE. People in the original trilogy community with contacts at Lucasfilm have confirmed that they know about fanedits and such. THEY DO NOT CARE. Let me repeat that one more time. THEY DO NOT CARE. Just watch the damn movies. You'll get it out of your system and you'll be free to move onto whatever else there is to worry about.

davidh777

It would be really interesting to hear sales figures. I wonder if it may just be the wrong generation. People like us who consider the original trilogy as mileposts in their lives are more inclined toward collecting and paying for physical media. The digital generation might not have the same attachment to Star Wars if they grew up with the bad films, granted that it's likely they've watched the older ones at some point. Maybe they'd rather watch Transformers.

Alan Smithee

Did you see my posting about that guy selling counterfeit DVDs at the freakin' CALIFORNIA STATE FAIR, a public family-oriented event with LOTS of security and police presence, at least three years in a row without getting so much as a slap on the wrist, even when I TRIED to get him busted each time? (I resented that he was making money off his illegal activities and that people were buying his stuff thinking it was legit, not that he was ripping off the poor movie studios.) If he can get away with that, I don't think there's really much concern about what you download in the privacy of your home. I've heard at least one story of someone getting busted for downloading some dumb but popular movie, but that might just have been published to scare everyone.

I've had to order my 50GB Blus; the only ones I've seen in stores are ridiculously expensive and just available in single or 2-packs, but the spindles you can order are a lot more reasonably priced, just a couple bucks per disc. Been meaning to see how much standard-def video I can cram onto one.

hanshotfirst1138

If it's as good as they say, then it'd be worth the investment, but I don't have a Blu-ray burner or BD-ROM drive anyway. I'd assume the former will also function as the latter?

So how can I put Christopher Frayling audio commentaries on my iPod then ?

Three's all kind of stuff out there on bootleg that I'm curious about, and many a fan edit.

Nah, just Catholic guilt .

Unless of course this was my cellmate :



Like poverty, race riots, existential malaise, equal rights, climate change, economics, inequality, aging, lying media, drugs and alcohol, quality of life, that kind of stuff? That sounds less fun.

It was a epochal film for a certain generation (and its residue, such as I, who grew up with it on video), but now I think that the brand name is of more interest for ancillary stuff; kids probably love the cartoons, the toys, etc. Like I say, the audience for the OOT is probably just the interested parties in places like this, and not a large enough collection of people to be of financial interest.

No, I didn't. That is a little nuts. But I guess it means that Toho are less incline to care if someone is torrenting an HD Godzilla flick, of if someone has a ROM of 30-year old Nintendo game.

I'd imagine lots of homebrew kind of stuff is expensive to do. It amazes me that some fan in his basement will take care of a film he loves so much in his basement with disposable income while multibilliondollar studios won't.

While it obviously wouldn't be commercially viable for studios, especially given the current state of the market, I've always wondered about cramming SD content on a BD. I mean, if you have a show which just has SD masters, you could probably release whole seasons on BDs with room to spare, though of course it's not the kind of thing any kind of store would want to sell. It'd certainly save shelf space if you could put all of Boy Meets World or Dark Shadows onto a disc.

I was thinking something almost identical....

hasslein

I haven't done this, so I don't know, but can't you just put the Harmy editions on a flash drive & plug it into bd player?

rocket1312

Of course a blu-ray burner can read blu-rays. How could they not? Oh, and they're $50. It's barely an investment.

See this link.

The short answer is yes. The long answer is that it depends on your model of BD player. Some players demand that usb devices be formatted with the Fat32 file system. Fat32 has a size limit of 4gb. Some players are also limited in the filetypes that can be played. There are ways around all of this stuff, but I've found it's just easier to burn to disc.

hanshotfirst1138

I figured it would obviously have to be able to . I'll check my local Best Buy. I'll get an external one to attach to my cheap PC now so I can attach it to a computer worth a damn in the future .

That is the most annoying and condescending thing on the Internet, I swear... But I'll have a look.

While we can use it for this and that, what was the major impetus for having that USB port? My DVR has one too, though it doesn't help me in my quest to get stuff off of it .

rocket1312

a. It's meant to be the most annoying and condescending thing on the internet.

b. It's exactly the information you're looking for explained with a level of care and detail that can't be replicated by a post on a message board.

hanshotfirst1138

Doesn't make it any less irritating.

Touche.