Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
#26
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Road Warrior is, hands down, the best of the three.
Mad Max is good, but it's very different from either Road Warrior or Beyond Thunderdome. It doesn't have the same post-apocalyptic, sci-fi feel that the two sequels did. I suppose it sort of makes sense in that regard, in that the world is progressively going to hell with each installment.
Beyond Thunderdome is easily the least of the three, but it's not exactly terrible... we're not in Jaws 3 or Jaws: The Revenge territory here. If you can get past the stunt-casting of Tina Turner and the lighter tone, it's not a bad entry in the franchise.
Mad Max is good, but it's very different from either Road Warrior or Beyond Thunderdome. It doesn't have the same post-apocalyptic, sci-fi feel that the two sequels did. I suppose it sort of makes sense in that regard, in that the world is progressively going to hell with each installment.
Beyond Thunderdome is easily the least of the three, but it's not exactly terrible... we're not in Jaws 3 or Jaws: The Revenge territory here. If you can get past the stunt-casting of Tina Turner and the lighter tone, it's not a bad entry in the franchise.
#27
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
I hope they do a comprehensive release of this one. I know the US theatrical version was cut: http://www.madmaxmovies.com/mad-max-...ion/index.html
But I suspect that we'll just get a reissue of the old blu-ray.
#29
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#30
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
I've only got Road Warrior on HD DVD, the others on DVD, so buying this seems to make sense. I'll wait until it hits $25 or less, though.
#31
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Have to say I liked Thunderdome for all the characters. Tina never looked so good. Liked Gibson with the long hair at first. The Master Blaster was great. And the Lost Tribe of Kids made it more than just all about "Max"....



I actually had a "crush" on her....her accent just killed me...



I actually had a "crush" on her....her accent just killed me...
#32
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Apparently Byron Kennedy, George Miller's longtime producing partner, was killed in a helicopter crash while location scouting and as a result, Miller only wanted to direct the action scenes and Oglive directed the actors. It certainly shows, as the film does tend to lack a cohesive vision. Perhaps his heart wasn't in it, as on review I once read said, plus at that point, the franchise was dumbing itself down to a PG-13 movie. The first 45 minutes or so are pretty strong, I think, then the movie completely shifts gears to Mad Max becoming a babysitter and the movie kind of falls apart. Some of the production design and post-apocalyptic imagery is (Are?) interesting, and some of the action scenes are cool, I know a lot of people who really like the chase sequence.
#33
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
If WB is going to use the existing disc for Mad Max, keep in mind that the blu-ray is missing features from the special edition DVD. This was somewhat remedied by MGM with their combo pack, but if WB doesn't make this a combo pack set people may want to keep this in mind when deciding between buying the individual releases or the box set.
#34
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Will definitely get this, and FWIW, I like Thunderdome, in spite of Tina Turner.
#35
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Amazon has a listing and pics
List Price: $49.99
Price: $34.86
Spoiler for size
List Price: $49.99
Price: $34.86
Spoiler for size
Spoiler:
#36
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Interesting. That looks like a 2-piece tin rather than a SteelBook or MetalPack.
#37
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
So are these remastered or what?
#38
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Back in stock at Best Buy for $24.99 for local pickups but no shipping.
Not sure if it is the Tin case.
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/mad-max-...&skuId=9143059
Not sure if it is the Tin case.
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/mad-max-...&skuId=9143059
#39
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Nope, same old releases that can be had in their separate 1 disc versions. Some would say for Mad Max, that is good thing (issues with the Shout! remaster)
Back in stock at Best Buy for $24.99 for local pickups but no shipping.
Not sure if it is the Tin case.
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/mad-max-...&skuId=9143059
Not sure if it is the Tin case.
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/mad-max-...&skuId=9143059
#40
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#42
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
I didn't catch the extreme time lag in the thread bump. 
Got to disagree. The way the back is formed is really weird and makes the whole case far thicker than it needs to be. Should have at least been in the kinds if tins they used for Band of Brothers or the Target exclusives of The Walking Dead.

Got to disagree. The way the back is formed is really weird and makes the whole case far thicker than it needs to be. Should have at least been in the kinds if tins they used for Band of Brothers or the Target exclusives of The Walking Dead.
#43
DVD Talk Legend
#45
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Yup, new encode and upgrade in audio. Most reviews say the differences are minimal, but they are there and I was wrong to say imply is is the exact same disc as before. Same transfer though which I would say most people are looking for before jumping on an upgrade. But it does seem to be the exact same disc for Thunderdome, and the same first 1 disc Mad Max BD, unless I missed something.
#46
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
The new Mad Max movie is fighting an uphill battle in regards to being successful and considered part of the original series. If it's not great it's going to be eviscerated among the fanbase. Imagine how hated Kingdom of the Crystal Skull would be if some relatively-unknown actor (and no, Tom Hardy is not a household name) was playing Indy instead of Harrison Ford.
#47
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
I'm sure most here was thinking the same thing.There's a new pre order page on Amazon which incl. Fury Road
http://www.amazon.com/Mad-Anthology-...MFH0FQ5NYDHAJ8
#48
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Does it include anything new, or just a repackaging of the old trilogy set with FR stuck in it? UV codes would be nice, but I wouldn't buy a whole new set just for them, and I've heard that MM2 is one Vudu's aspect ratio foul-ups.
#50
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Mad Max trilogy - 6/4/13
Get the 3-disc tin. It contains the best versions currently available. Road Warrior is the upgraded version. Mad Max is the older version, but by all accounts, actually has better PQ than the new version released in May, although it's missing a few superfluous new extras.
The amray sits nicely on my shelf, while the crappy tin makes a decent cigar case.
The amray sits nicely on my shelf, while the crappy tin makes a decent cigar case.







