DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Star Wars (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/577990-star-wars.html)

TGM 10-12-11 09:29 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Jay G. (Post 10961985)
You misread Spottedfeather's post. His complaint wasn't that George Lucas is greedy. His complain was that George Lucas isn't greedy enough. If Lucas was greedy above all else, he'd release the unaltered versions in order to make more money.

no, this is the epitome of greedy.

I have no doubt that eventually we will get a cleaned up version of the original, unaltered trilogy.

But this way, he releases the updated versions, and people without self control will buy them. Then, when offered the versions they really want, they will buy them again. More people will bitch, yet still buy, the current blurays than bitch and hold off.

BuckNaked2k 10-12-11 10:35 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by TallGuyMe (Post 10962007)
I have no doubt that eventually we will get a cleaned up version of the original, unaltered trilogy.

Really? I can't see this ever happening, but I hope I'm wrong.

I remember back when the OOTs were released as "bonus" discs in non-anamorphic format, there was an e-mail campaign aimed at getting a rethinking of this. The canned response came back thet they are not part of George's "vision", and would not be released in any format other than the garbage 4x3 letterboxed transfers from LD.

Breather 10-13-11 04:05 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Jay G. (Post 10961985)
As for myself, I don't care how many times George Lucas re-releases the films. All I care about is whether I can get the versions I want in a high-quality copy.

My thoughts exactly. He can re-release them until the end of time for all I care. Give me the chance to buy a nice copy of the OOT and I'll be happy.

mcnabb 10-13-11 08:35 AM

re: Star Wars
 
I used to think that Lucas would release the OOT fully restored, but after seeing the sales of the BluRay set, he knows that fans will buy anything he puts out. Trust me, I was one of those people who boycotted the BluRay set (still haven't bought it), but in the end, it didn't make a difference as the set broke BluRay sales records (Lucas is probably laughing at fans like me). Lucas looks at the numbers and justifies in his mind that it would be a waste of time to release the OOT. The only way he was ever going to release the OOT the right way is if fans didn't buy the SE version and sales were terrible.

As I have said before, Lucas could physically take a dump on the movies and people would still buy them saying, "Of course they smell like shit, but they're still Star Wars!"

pinata242 10-13-11 08:46 AM

re: Star Wars
 
He can do whatever he wants at this point. Working on a tip, I found HD conversions of the largely-unaltered original trilogy. That works for me. If he ever decides he wants my money, he knows how to get it.

wishbone 10-13-11 08:49 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by mcnabb (Post 10963304)
As I have said before, Lucas could physically take a dump on the movies and people would still buy them saying, "Of course they smell like shit, but they're still Star Wars!"

Please don't give him any ideas for a "May the Fecal Be With You" edition...

mcnabb 10-13-11 08:54 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by wishbone (Post 10963321)
Please don't give him any ideas for a "May the Fecal Be With You" edition...

:lol:

Fans will be clamoring for a 'behind the scenes' featurette of that ;)

Michael Corvin 10-13-11 10:11 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10963317)
He can do whatever he wants at this point. Working on a tip, I found HD conversions of the largely-unaltered original trilogy. That works for me. If he ever decides he wants my money, he knows how to get it.

Sad to think Star Wars would ever become the new Song of the South.

Hokeyboy 10-13-11 12:41 PM

re: Star Wars
 
^No way. The Original Trilogy consisted of 2 great movies and 1 OK movie. SONG OF THE SOUTH is fucking awful, except for the animated sequences, and those are few and far in between.

Michael Corvin 10-13-11 02:59 PM

re: Star Wars
 
I meant in regards to bootlegging the film, as it is basically the only way to see it unaltered anymore, unless you still have a VCR lying around.

bluetoast 10-13-11 03:46 PM

re: Star Wars
 
I remember this video store I used to go to in college had "editions" of the Holiday Special and Song of the South for rent. Never got around to seeing them, but I was surprised that they would do so.

Hokeyboy 10-13-11 03:50 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 10963857)
I meant in regards to bootlegging the film, as it is basically the only way to see it unaltered anymore, unless you still have a VCR lying around.

Roger that. Disco!

GoldenJCJ 10-14-11 11:50 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 10963946)
Roger Roger. Disco!

fixed. ;)

Doctorossi 10-14-11 12:01 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 10963857)
I meant in regards to bootlegging the film, as it is basically the only way to see it unaltered anymore, unless you still have a VCR lying around.

There is this thing called a DVD player. I think they have them at Sears.

arminius 10-14-11 12:29 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by Doctorossi (Post 10965122)
There is this thing called a DVD player. I think they have them at Sears.

Have no fear of low flying aircraft.

b2net 10-19-11 11:40 AM

re: Star Wars
 
Imagine the material this could jave if it were created after the blu's came out.

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/52175...-george-lucas/

Drexl 10-19-11 12:16 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by b2net (Post 10971037)
Imagine the material this could have if it were created after the blu's came out.

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/52175...-george-lucas/

Just revise it later, as Lucas would do.

applesandrice 10-19-11 12:39 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by b2net (Post 10971037)
Imagine the material this could jave if it were created after the blu's came out.

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/52175...-george-lucas/



The RedLetterMedia website has a good two-part interview with "The People Vs. George Lucas" director Alexandre O. Phillippe, wherein he and the hosts of "Half in the Bag" discuss the Blu-ray release. Here's a link to part one:

http://redlettermedia.com/half-in-th...rs-discussion/

ScissorPuppy 10-23-11 08:53 AM

re: Star Wars
 
A bunch of people who want the Original films remastered for Blu Ray should organize an "Occupy" Lucasfilm in San Francisco hahahaha

RD1973 12-04-11 09:45 PM

re: Star Wars
 
So, were any easter eggs ever found?

The Valeyard 12-04-11 10:24 PM

re: Star Wars
 
The thread lives again!

Breather 12-05-11 02:09 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by RD1973 (Post 11030446)
So, were any easter eggs ever found?

Only if you count the Boba Fett cartoon from the Holiday Special. It's accessible from the menu though, not hidden like normal easter eggs. Adam Gregorich at HTF checked with Lucasfilm and they said the Fett cartoon was it. They could have done more than that.

Josh-da-man 12-05-11 07:11 AM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by the valeyard (Post 11030490)
the thread lives again!

Noooooooo!

milo bloom 12-05-11 09:12 AM

re: Star Wars
 
I've been meaning to drag this thread out myself: been wondering how people are liking this set? Are the deleted scenes all that or are there still too many missing?

I'm still kinda keeping my eyes open for a used set...

toddly6666 12-05-11 01:09 PM

re: Star Wars
 

Originally Posted by RD1973 (Post 11030446)
So, were any easter eggs ever found?

Besides the hidden Boba Fett Cartoon, the two Ewok movies, the complete Droids cartoon series, and the complete Ewok cartoon series?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:31 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.