DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/574862-kick-ass-blu-dvd-digital-copy-august-3rd.html)

jdslater1 07-30-10 02:40 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
It's a 3 disc set. The DVD is seperate to the DC. Stupid and a waste as some companies can do it.

calhoun07 07-30-10 05:36 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
Why is the DVD included a waste? Just because you don't want to use it doesn't mean a lot of other people would never use it. Most folks have only one blu-ray player but have DVD players elsewhere so it offers them the ability to play the movie in any player they have. It's a great idea...more studios should do it!

Bob_Bobbson 07-30-10 05:58 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by calhoun07 (Post 10295970)
Why is the DVD included a waste? Just because you don't want to use it doesn't mean a lot of other people would never use it. Most folks have only one blu-ray player but have DVD players elsewhere so it offers them the ability to play the movie in any player they have. It's a great idea...more studios should do it!

I think he was refering to the fact that the Digital Copy and DVD copy were two separate discs. A few studios have recently switched to where they were both on one DVD disc.

It is a waste of space if they put in 2 extra discs instead of a DVD/DC combo.

MTRodaba2468 07-30-10 08:42 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by calhoun07 (Post 10295970)
Why is the DVD included a waste? Just because you don't want to use it doesn't mean a lot of other people would never use it. Most folks have only one blu-ray player but have DVD players elsewhere so it offers them the ability to play the movie in any player they have. It's a great idea...more studios should do it!

As Bob said, I think he was referring to having the DC on a separate disc than the DVD copy, instead of them both sharing the same disc. Frankly, I agree with him.

Mr. Salty 07-30-10 09:07 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by Bob_Bobbson (Post 10295999)
It is a waste of space if they put in 2 extra discs instead of a DVD/DC combo.

There are arguments to be made as to whether Digital Copies are a waste, but I strongly disagree that they should be forced onto the DVD. All of the DCs I've seen are more than a gigabyte in size. I would rather that space be used for better video and audio quality on the DVD.

jdslater1 07-31-10 06:12 AM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
I was referring to the fact they are not on the same disc.
I love these "triple plays". I just bought the Losers and have given my mum the DVD as they have no BD player yet. I still haven't got my Holmes DVD from them!
I see Mr Saltys point about space on the DVD given over to better AV and AQ but if that DVD hasn't got all the extras then there should be enough for both.
It would save on production costs at least.

TylerDurden_73 08-01-10 01:36 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
No DVD and DC on same disc is a waste. Out of curiosity i have watched some scenes of these DVD versions and Outside the fact that these are in SD, didn't notice anything out of the ordinary.

taco5 08-04-10 07:01 AM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by Adboy151 (Post 10231631)
Folks should be aware that this will be shipping with two different covers for retail.

Listed as "conservative box art," possibly some form of Kick-A$$, it will be available for the DVD and BD versions.

Blu-ray
Contains 3 Discs
UPC 031398121381

Conservative Box Art Blu-ray
Contains 3 Discs
UPC 031398126119

Anyone see alternate cover art? I went to Target, Walmart and Best Buy and they all seemed the same.

snausages 08-05-10 02:55 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by taco5 (Post 10303471)
Anyone see alternate cover art? I went to Target, Walmart and Best Buy and they all seemed the same.

Didn't see any alternate cover, but UK has a lovely box set and other countries have some nice packaging and various cover art as well. Click here to check it out.

Matthew Chmiel 08-05-10 03:13 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
Warner is the only studio that will create a specific DVD to put in the Blu-ray edition, a DVD that provides your standard-definition copy plus your digital copies (one for WMV, another for MPEG-4). However, for those who actually watch the DVD, you're going to notice more-than-usual compression. The digital copies portion of Clash of the Titans, a 107 minute film, takes up 3.5GB. You're now only left with 4GB for the film itself. The shorter the film, the better as one may not notice the compression; but the longer the film (say The Informant!), you're going to notice the compression. I did compare scenes on The Final Destination and Ninja Assasin BDs compared with the DVDs that came them and it was night-and-day. If you wanted someone to switch over to Blu, compare both of these titles on a 50" HDTV.

What I've noticed with Kick-Ass, is that the DVD included is bare-bones... almost as if it was created for rental purposes or for the Blu-ray itself. Nothing from your retail DVD (audio commentary, the 20-minute featurette or the promotional material) are found on the DVD included, but they're all on the BD.

Studios like Disney and Fox/MGM include the standard retail DVDs (like James and the Giant Peach which includes the original Special Edition DVD release).

Personally, I'd rather take a DVD over a Digital Copy.

Peep 08-05-10 03:41 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
I'd rather have the standard retail DVD and give up the digital copy.

taco5 08-05-10 03:44 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by snausages (Post 10306309)
Didn't see any alternate cover, but UK has a lovely box set and other countries have some nice packaging and various cover art as well. Click here to check it out.

Thread not working at this time.

I already have the UK steelbook and UK Collector's Edition pre-ordered.

PerryD 08-05-10 10:23 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
I watched it tonight and definitely enjoyed it. Took a little time to get going, mostly since he was so awkward. I'll spend some more time with it this weekend to watch the bonus features.

snausages 08-05-10 10:32 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by taco5 (Post 10306401)
Thread not working at this time.

I already have the UK steelbook and UK Collector's Edition pre-ordered.

It should work now. Are you getting the German steelbook too?

RocShemp 08-06-10 04:40 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
I purchased Kick-Ass today at Best Buy. The audio is fantastic but the video sports a really schizophrenic transfer. It keeps flip-flopping from grainy and detailed to DNR'ed and waxy (with some minor ringing to boot) with no rhyme or reason. It still looks good overall but the inconsistensy of the transfer gets really annoying.

doctorthodt 08-06-10 04:42 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10308491)
I purchased Kick-Ass today at Best Buy. The audio is fantastic but the video sports a really schizophrenic transfer. It keeps flip-flopping from grainy and detailed to DNR'ed and waxy (with some minor ringing to boot) with no rhyme or reason. It still looks good overall but the inconsistensy of the transfer gets really annoying.

That's exactly how the film looked in theaters. It's a perfectly accurate transfer.

RocShemp 08-06-10 05:02 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by doctorthodt (Post 10308495)
That's exactly how the film looked in theaters. It's a perfectly accurate transfer.

Thanks. I never saw it in theaters so that really took me by surprise. Still weird, though. If it happened for specific scenes only I'd maybe understand. But the transfer is all over the place.

Josh Z 08-07-10 12:06 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 10308491)
I purchased Kick-Ass today at Best Buy. The audio is fantastic but the video sports a really schizophrenic transfer. It keeps flip-flopping from grainy and detailed to DNR'ed and waxy (with some minor ringing to boot) with no rhyme or reason.

I don't think that "DNR'ed" is the right term in this case. The movie has quite a bit of the digital airbrushing effect on actors' faces, similar to Charlie and the Chocolate Factory or Sweeney Todd. As much of an annoyance as this is, it was deliberate.

taco5 08-07-10 03:30 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
Did anyone have issues with the bonus features? When I go into "The Making of Kick-Ass" the screen freezes up but the counter continues to run. Happens on both of my Sony BD players.

Gizmo 08-07-10 07:43 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
This disc has some major loading problems. Took forever.

TheMovieman 08-07-10 07:48 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
Typical Lionsgate menus... I don't remember which title it was, might have been The Spirit, but I remember it took forever to load as well.

Solid Snake 08-07-10 08:24 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
I've never encountered loading issues on any Lionsgate film.

taco5 08-07-10 08:25 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
I'm going to exchange mine. Hopefully I just got a bum disc...

Gizmo 08-07-10 08:28 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 

Originally Posted by TheMovieman (Post 10310046)
Typical Lionsgate menus... I don't remember which title it was, might have been The Spirit, but I remember it took forever to load as well.

It was. I read others are experiencing load times of 5 minutes for this movie on Sony BD players. My LG took two-three minutes.

PopcornTreeCt 08-07-10 09:08 PM

Re: Kick-Ass (Blu + DVD + Digital Copy) --> August 3rd!
 
Blu-rays having to load... this effing format.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:02 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.