The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
#526
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I don't recall that one at all... but there's lots of that season I truly don't remember. I started it on Amazon Prime video at work to see if it rings a bell and so far, no. But it looks quite good. It's HD and hopefully a indication of how the Blu-ray discs will look - the DVDs are "dark" soft and just look "old" - especially so after recently watching TOS on BR in its restored version.
One thing that *always* gets me on these early episodes is how "odd" Worf looks. He just looks "wrong" as they tweaked his makeup over the years and got it looking much better.
One thing that *always* gets me on these early episodes is how "odd" Worf looks. He just looks "wrong" as they tweaked his makeup over the years and got it looking much better.
I agree about you with Warf, it's a bit distracting at first, but I do get used to his features after a bit. It's only when you see an earlier version really close to an older one that it's really jarring.
I use Movie Collector but the trick for me is to actually update it after I watch something.
Not being a huge Star Trek fan, I had to read up on all the hate against him but as I was watching the series, I wasn't seeing what everyone else was. Lots of other cast had their own special episodes. I didn't see him taking over or anything.
Not being a huge Star Trek fan, I had to read up on all the hate against him but as I was watching the series, I wasn't seeing what everyone else was. Lots of other cast had their own special episodes. I didn't see him taking over or anything.
The biggest issue I had with Wesley was he was a *kid* and *allowed almost full access on the bridge* of a *military/exploration* starship.
I wasn't too keen on the whole "we have our families in part of the ship but the saucer can break away to fight if there's trouble" concept. As it turned out the fx to separate the saucer was so expensive that they only did it a few times over the course of the series. I always posited that if they were truly "military" then the families should have stayed "at home" but if they were a "exploration" ship then *the families should have stayed at home* as well. Either can be a very dangerous situation and having "civilians" aboard can compromise decisions and situations significantly.
I wasn't too keen on the whole "we have our families in part of the ship but the saucer can break away to fight if there's trouble" concept. As it turned out the fx to separate the saucer was so expensive that they only did it a few times over the course of the series. I always posited that if they were truly "military" then the families should have stayed "at home" but if they were a "exploration" ship then *the families should have stayed at home* as well. Either can be a very dangerous situation and having "civilians" aboard can compromise decisions and situations significantly.
#527
Senior Member
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I have a question about whether or not a movie qualifies. The name is Paradox, it's from 2016 and the director is Michael Hurst. It is showing on Netflix Streaming. It is listed as Action, Drama on IMDB and Action, Thriller on AllMovie, although the sub-genres on Allmovie are Action Thriller and Supernatural Thriller. The movie's description shows it is about what happens when someone travels in time one hour and then returns. The plot keywords in IMDB include Time Travel, nonlinear timeline and time paradox. I would like to count it toward Time Travel for the checklist. Does anyone know of this movie or have any problem with it being used?
#528
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Pretty sure Time Travel is still regarded as science fiction...
#529
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Nope, go for it. If you watch and for some reason you don't think it's sci-fi because the summary was misleading, you can use a wildcard. But as long as it has time travel in it, it would definitely qualify.
#530
Senior Member
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Thanks for the quick answers!
#531
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I don't the think I'll go to Star Wars tonight. I'm leaving tomorrow night, so wore myself out today. I might watch it on my tablet though.
#532
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I finished S2 of Science Fiction Theatre earlier this evening. S2 was, overall, better than S1 in that it had more SF than melodrama with light SF nods as in many S1 episodes. It is a interesting precursor to series like The Twilight Zone and The Outer Limits but not one I feel I'll revisit often. Still, I'm glad I've seen it.
I then moved on to Star Trek: TNG and "Encounter at Farpoint." While I still feel it's a rather weak episode I must say the Blu-ray remaster is has superb PQ and audio. It's superior to the original DVD release in every way. Scenes that were dark/soft/grainy on the DVD are brighter, sharper, have better color, and exhibit little grain. The upgraded vfx are also quite good. I almost wish I'd not purchased those DVD sets but had I *not* purchased them I'd have likely not purchased the Blu-ray set as it was watching S1-S6 (I never made it to S7 although I do own it) that convinced me there are more good episodes than I'd given the series credit for having. It's still not my favorite of the Trek series (dead last on my list) but *is* better than many other SF series.
Next up, "The Naked Now" which is a blatant, and inferior, remake of the original series episode "The Naked Time." I've read Roddenberry wanted to remake many of the original episodes to take advantage of better effects technology but there was such a backlash from fans over this practice, and that TNG failed to take off as anticipated, that he backed off that plan. Had he not I doubt the series would have lasted beyond S1.
I then moved on to Star Trek: TNG and "Encounter at Farpoint." While I still feel it's a rather weak episode I must say the Blu-ray remaster is has superb PQ and audio. It's superior to the original DVD release in every way. Scenes that were dark/soft/grainy on the DVD are brighter, sharper, have better color, and exhibit little grain. The upgraded vfx are also quite good. I almost wish I'd not purchased those DVD sets but had I *not* purchased them I'd have likely not purchased the Blu-ray set as it was watching S1-S6 (I never made it to S7 although I do own it) that convinced me there are more good episodes than I'd given the series credit for having. It's still not my favorite of the Trek series (dead last on my list) but *is* better than many other SF series.
Next up, "The Naked Now" which is a blatant, and inferior, remake of the original series episode "The Naked Time." I've read Roddenberry wanted to remake many of the original episodes to take advantage of better effects technology but there was such a backlash from fans over this practice, and that TNG failed to take off as anticipated, that he backed off that plan. Had he not I doubt the series would have lasted beyond S1.
#533
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Not being a huge Star Trek fan, I had to read up on all the hate against [Wesley] but as I was watching the series, I wasn't seeing what everyone else was. Lots of other cast had their own special episodes. I didn't see him taking over or anything.
A better question - especially from a marketing perspective - is why Dr. Crusher gets such short shrift, and why Tasha was completely ignored during the anniversary celebrations. And to add insult to injury, both often get passed over in favour of young Wesley..!
Hopefully it was clear that I was railing against people generally and not you specifically... I get why people read sexism (even misogyny) and the like into the comic. I can see why people would assume rape, and I even see why Barbara gets put with the WiR crowd as a woman-used-as-a-tool-to-add-motive-for-a-man (even Mr Moore has mostly agreed with this criticism). But while I understand it, I think it's unfair to read it that way. This is not Batgirl getting the short end of the stick. This is 'wrong place, wrong time'. This Joker/Batman/Gordon and everyone else is a pawn, not just Barbara. If it were Gordon's son in her shoes, everything would have played out identically. Which is - despite the circumstances - surely the definition of equality..?
Presumably an Oracle foreshadowing..? I haven't seen it, but that seems logical...
#534
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
#535
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Got in two recent releases: Stranger Things and Star Trek Beyond. Stranger Things is very thrilling and enjoyable. I felt that it transcends the 80s gimmick and is its own thing while still providing plenty of nostalgia-baiting homages. Star Trek Beyond is definitely my favorite of the new movies. Plenty of action and lots of Bones, a character that is underused in the first two installments. This may be the thing that pushed it past the first film for me. McCoy is my favorite Star Trek character and is likely to remain so unless someone on Enterprise (or the new series) is better.
I am curious: who are your favorite Star Trek characters?
I am curious: who are your favorite Star Trek characters?
#536
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I'm happy I got some sci-fi in on my vacation. Woke up in the middle of the night to a wet tent, so decided to stay up. I brought my tablet over to an outlet and watched the Season 6 episode of Ancient Aliens, 'The Power Of Three', on History Channel On Demand, on Sling TV.
#537
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,765
Received 1,726 Likes
on
1,388 Posts
From: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I used to include critical comments in my list posts but then I stopped because I was convinced no one was reading them, so I just do one-line summaries now.
But some other participants are including comments and they're definitely worth reading. I especially recommend Gobear's post in the list thread for this challenge (#16), quite an entertaining read. Also check out: #31 (numbercrunch), #39 (pagefrance) and #44 (brainee). My own list is #6.
But some other participants are including comments and they're definitely worth reading. I especially recommend Gobear's post in the list thread for this challenge (#16), quite an entertaining read. Also check out: #31 (numbercrunch), #39 (pagefrance) and #44 (brainee). My own list is #6.
#538
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
TOS - Uhura and Spock
TNG - Data
DS9 - basically everyone except Ezri
VOY - The Doctor and Seven
ENT - Mayweather and Hoshi
#539
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Got in two recent releases: Stranger Things and Star Trek Beyond. Stranger Things is very thrilling and enjoyable. I felt that it transcends the 80s gimmick and is its own thing while still providing plenty of nostalgia-baiting homages. Star Trek Beyond is definitely my favorite of the new movies. Plenty of action and lots of Bones, a character that is underused in the first two installments. This may be the thing that pushed it past the first film for me. McCoy is my favorite Star Trek character and is likely to remain so unless someone on Enterprise (or the new series) is better.
TOS: McCoy, Scott, Spock
TNG: Dr. Crusher, Worf
DS9: Dax, Quark
VOY: The Doctor, Neelix
ENT: Dr. Phlox, Archer
Last edited by BobO'Link; 07-30-16 at 10:32 AM.
#540
Senior Member
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
STRANGER THINGS
looks like alot of folks on this thread other than me have watched Stranger Things. I cured that problem last night . I watched first three episodes and fell asleep halfway through the fourth. My GF said the fourth episode really got twisted towards the end, so im looking forward to completing it today
looks like alot of folks on this thread other than me have watched Stranger Things. I cured that problem last night . I watched first three episodes and fell asleep halfway through the fourth. My GF said the fourth episode really got twisted towards the end, so im looking forward to completing it today
#541
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
So a kid being on the bridge just is what it is and I didn't know any better.
I also hated Dr Crusher's replacement. There would have been no possible way to have her character continue with the series while keeping the same attitude she had at the start. She did appear to try and soften up but you could still tell she was the same under the surface.
I work and sit next to two people like her. It's awful.
#542
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I also hated Dr Crusher's replacement. There would have been no possible way to have her character continue with the series while keeping the same attitude she had at the start. She did appear to try and soften up but you could still tell she was the same under the surface.
#543
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Hey guys, haven't been a big part of this challenge but if there is any stat tabulation at the end I can add all the pertinent details to my "list" if requested.
+1 on the Stranger Things love
+1 on the Stranger Things love
Last edited by SterlingBen; 07-30-16 at 12:22 PM.
#545
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Thanks to Chad's earlier comments about watching the colorized Earth vs. Flying Saucers on BR I looked up prices. Hmmm.... it was *less*expensive (about half the cost) than the DVD!?! I ordered a copy and it came in yesterday. I just finished a viewing of the colorized version. Like other Legend efforts, it's quite good. Without checking I'd say this is possibly the best one they've done. Many scenes look "natural" with only a few suffering from a "colorized" look, and those scenes are the ones which have issues on the BW print which is the root cause of the color issues. This is one I may opt for colorized in the future...
#546
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I agree, she wasn't bad.
I prefer the uniform Deanna Troi wore in the first episode than the weird suit she wore most of the time. They should have stuck with the original series types of uniforms.
I have some of their other releases and the colored versions don't look bad at all. I'm old enough to remember when Ted Turner started colorizing old movies and remember how awful they used to look.
I prefer the uniform Deanna Troi wore in the first episode than the weird suit she wore most of the time. They should have stuck with the original series types of uniforms.
Thanks to Chad's earlier comments about watching the colorized Earth vs. Flying Saucers on BR I looked up prices. Hmmm.... it was *less*expensive (about half the cost) than the DVD!?! I ordered a copy and it came in yesterday. I just finished a viewing of the colorized version. Like other Legend efforts, it's quite good. Without checking I'd say this is possibly the best one they've done. Many scenes look "natural" with only a few suffering from a "colorized" look, and those scenes are the ones which have issues on the BW print which is the root cause of the color issues. This is one I may opt for colorized in the future...
#547
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
One odd thing... After watching the colorized version I thought several scenes were excessively grainy so I pulled my DVD (in The Harryhausen Gift Set) to see if there were a difference in the prints. The DVD looks better overall - less grain and a cleaner image. I'd have thought the colorized one, also being Blu-ray, would have a slight edge but it did not.
#548
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I also hated Dr Crusher's replacement. There would have been no possible way to have her character continue with the series while keeping the same attitude she had at the start. She did appear to try and soften up but you could still tell she was the same under the surface.
I work and sit next to two people like her. It's awful.
I work and sit next to two people like her. It's awful.
Don't usually do stats but please put at least a short (numbered) list down if you haven't already if you want to be eligible for the prize selection.
#549
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Watching Predator at the moment. Who could have predicted two of its stars would be elected as state governors?
#550
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 9th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Add me to the Pulaski haters club.



