View Poll Results: What Cataloging System Do You Use?
DVDProfiler



105
44.30%
DVDAficionado



62
26.16%
DVDPedia



8
3.38%
Delicious Library



7
2.95%
Microsoft Word/Excel



16
6.75%
Other



23
9.70%
None At All



16
6.75%
Voters: 237. You may not vote on this poll
DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
#126
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: ramble
But do I put BD and HD-DVD in with the DVDs? If not, some trilogies or sets are broken up in different areas.
How do you deal with double/triple features with all the films on one disc or in one case? Alphabetical by first title? But then browsing the shelves for the later movies is difficult.
Box sets are difficult. Some are in individual cases and the films can be separated and sorted alphabetically, but many aren't.
How do you deal with double/triple features with all the films on one disc or in one case? Alphabetical by first title? But then browsing the shelves for the later movies is difficult.
Box sets are difficult. Some are in individual cases and the films can be separated and sorted alphabetically, but many aren't.
Firstly, do I sort The Sopranos - The Complete Fifth Season before The Sopranos - The Complete Second Season because "Fifth" alphabetizes before "Second," or do I go with the chronological meaning of the subtitle? I elected to go with the latter, though the part of me that adheres to strict rules is bothered by this.
Secondly, stand-up and music releases. Does Jerry Seinfeld: I'm Telling You for the Last Time: Live on Broadway go under J's or I's? I noticed recently that the Half Price Books I frequent actually alphabetizes such things by the performer's surname, so in their system it would go with the S's!
It can become exasperating at times, and all I can say is that I genuinely appreciate that this online community exists where I can vent about such trivial issues as how to properly organize my video library and not be mocked for being the uber-geek that I am.
#128
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 3,818
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Kansas City, MO
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
I wrote my own. My primary motive was to get some practice coding, as I'm trying to learn Visual Basic.net. Also, I wanted a program that consisted of just MY movies. So yes, that means everytime I get a new DVD I have to enter all the info into it (I've only gotten about half of my DVDs in there so far). But hey, it's my own, and I like that.

It's got the option to display whichever details I want (Title, year, director, language, my rating, packaging type, MPAA rating, etc, etc), it's got the ability to filter out only DVDs I haven't watched, I can choose to view the database with or without the thumbnails, it's got a "wish list" function, it can add or edit records easily, and lots of other little things.
And it's got a pretty nifty search function that allows me to search by any criteria I choose (that's what the "search by" drop down is), as well as an advanced search where I can combine criteria (Like, say, I wanted to find all the Dario Argento movies from the 1970s that I rated 85 or higher, I could do it here):

And it's got a stats page that summarizes my collection:

Just thought I'd share.

It's got the option to display whichever details I want (Title, year, director, language, my rating, packaging type, MPAA rating, etc, etc), it's got the ability to filter out only DVDs I haven't watched, I can choose to view the database with or without the thumbnails, it's got a "wish list" function, it can add or edit records easily, and lots of other little things.
And it's got a pretty nifty search function that allows me to search by any criteria I choose (that's what the "search by" drop down is), as well as an advanced search where I can combine criteria (Like, say, I wanted to find all the Dario Argento movies from the 1970s that I rated 85 or higher, I could do it here):

And it's got a stats page that summarizes my collection:

Just thought I'd share.
#129
DVD Talk Legend
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
^ That looks pretty sharp, caiman! 
In your stats, I appreciate the total runtime feature. I've wondered many times how many months/years viewing time I have at my disposal or how long it would take me to get through my unwatched pile if I didn't buy another DVD.

In your stats, I appreciate the total runtime feature. I've wondered many times how many months/years viewing time I have at my disposal or how long it would take me to get through my unwatched pile if I didn't buy another DVD.
Last edited by Cardsfan111; 12-01-09 at 01:33 AM.
#131
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Ditto! My initial plan was to do something similar with excel/access/google docs (or ask you for your program). But with ~5000 titles, I have decided there is no way I'd manually enter all the data I want to track. I'm going to have to choose one of the current programs, and hope it doesn't go DVDSpot on me.
#132
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Recently downloaded the trial versions of both DVD Profiler and Collectorz Movie Collector. These seemed the best from a PC perspective (no I am not starting a Mac vs PC debate).... Of the programs listed in this Poll that are PC compatible, DVD Profiler is by far the best for my applications... but... I tried Movie Collector... It has the extra versitility I require (in addition it is for more than just DVD, HD-DVD, and Blu-Ray.. it is for all movie formats.. VHS, LaserDisc, etc).... and it allows for Text exports as well output to a Palm based (not starting Palm vs iPhone vs Blackberry debate either) output. Thank you to everyone in this post that helped lead to this decision.
#134
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
I wrote my own. My primary motive was to get some practice coding, as I'm trying to learn Visual Basic.net. Also, I wanted a program that consisted of just MY movies. So yes, that means everytime I get a new DVD I have to enter all the info into it (I've only gotten about half of my DVDs in there so far). But hey, it's my own, and I like that.

It's got the option to display whichever details I want (Title, year, director, language, my rating, packaging type, MPAA rating, etc, etc), it's got the ability to filter out only DVDs I haven't watched, I can choose to view the database with or without the thumbnails, it's got a "wish list" function, it can add or edit records easily, and lots of other little things.
And it's got a pretty nifty search function that allows me to search by any criteria I choose (that's what the "search by" drop down is), as well as an advanced search where I can combine criteria (Like, say, I wanted to find all the Dario Argento movies from the 1970s that I rated 85 or higher, I could do it here):

And it's got a stats page that summarizes my collection:

Just thought I'd share.

It's got the option to display whichever details I want (Title, year, director, language, my rating, packaging type, MPAA rating, etc, etc), it's got the ability to filter out only DVDs I haven't watched, I can choose to view the database with or without the thumbnails, it's got a "wish list" function, it can add or edit records easily, and lots of other little things.
And it's got a pretty nifty search function that allows me to search by any criteria I choose (that's what the "search by" drop down is), as well as an advanced search where I can combine criteria (Like, say, I wanted to find all the Dario Argento movies from the 1970s that I rated 85 or higher, I could do it here):

And it's got a stats page that summarizes my collection:

Just thought I'd share.
#135
Banned
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 1,033
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Royersford, PA
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
all these set up are nice. but can they be viewed by others without having to send them a file? as in a web page or something? thats why i built my own website. so others can view my collection. my fiends/family use it all the time when buying me gifts to make sure i dont already have something. and my other collecting friends go to it to see what i've recently bought.
#136
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 3,818
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Kansas City, MO
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
#137
Member
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
all these set up are nice. but can they be viewed by others without having to send them a file? as in a web page or something? thats why i built my own website. so others can view my collection. my fiends/family use it all the time when buying me gifts to make sure i dont already have something. and my other collecting friends go to it to see what i've recently bought.
#138
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Cataloging my library is something I'm geek enough to enjoy doing, and I just realized this is one of the best parts of "going Blu." Now that I already have a system in place for this stuff, I can keep much better records of my purchases than I did with DVD!
#139
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
I just downloaded the program from Collectorz.com .. Pretty good and easy to use. I also have been using dvd aficionado for years.
#140
Banned
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
#141
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Dvd Aficionado but Im not a fan of their interface and am considering trying another website, can anyone recommend a good one for keeping track of dvds that I lend out to friends and family?
#142
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#143
Member
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
collectorz.com has a "Loan movie" feature...you can keep track of who you rented to on what date and what date you want it returned...and then when you get it back you can "return" it.
#145
Cool New Member
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Hi All,
Just a quick question - while this post may have been inactive for a while, I wanted to see if anyone could provide me with some info.
I have a pretty large collection - 1400 titles on dvd, about 500 video game titles, and maybe 600 cd's
I would really like some form of software that could make use of ALL these forms of media but I'm not having much luck looking out on the web. Could anyone make any recommendations? I have most of this already contained in excel, so importing would be a great feature.
Thanks!
Just a quick question - while this post may have been inactive for a while, I wanted to see if anyone could provide me with some info.
I have a pretty large collection - 1400 titles on dvd, about 500 video game titles, and maybe 600 cd's
I would really like some form of software that could make use of ALL these forms of media but I'm not having much luck looking out on the web. Could anyone make any recommendations? I have most of this already contained in excel, so importing would be a great feature.
Thanks!
#147
Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 200
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: California
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
I have a pretty large collection - 1400 titles on dvd, about 500 video game titles, and maybe 600 cd's
I would really like some form of software that could make use of ALL these forms of media but I'm not having much luck looking out on the web. Could anyone make any recommendations? I have most of this already contained in excel, so importing would be a great feature.
I would really like some form of software that could make use of ALL these forms of media but I'm not having much luck looking out on the web. Could anyone make any recommendations? I have most of this already contained in excel, so importing would be a great feature.
I haven't tried them, but they offer free trials. (their products aren't free)
#148
Cool New Member
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Unfortunately I've been trying to find something that combines them all into one database. Seems to be more difficult than I had hoped. Libra would've been awesome to use, but seems to have no support now and cannot reach out to any databases.
I do not mind working in excel, it would just be nice to have something that put all the info in for me directly as I am missing about 50% of it (run times, ratings, year released, etc...) as well as having nice little thumbnails of the covers or what not.
I do not mind working in excel, it would just be nice to have something that put all the info in for me directly as I am missing about 50% of it (run times, ratings, year released, etc...) as well as having nice little thumbnails of the covers or what not.
#149
Senior Member
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
My understanding is that the current DVD Profiler beta supports other media types. The catch is that their online database won't, so while you can use the program to enter this stuff, you'll be entering it in all by hand. I don't have any firsthand experience with this as I'm not a fan of beta software.
#150
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: DVD Cataloging - What Program Do You Use?
Anyone have a good iphone app that will work with Profiler? I've got something called "imovies collection" right now that seems to pull my collection from my online list on profilers website. Problem is, it doesnt really list as much info about each title as I would like, the main one being format. I see that Collectorz iphone app lists this, as well as a bunch of other info, and lets you do some cool sorting things. I dont really want to input all my titles into another program, though. And I cant seem to find anything that says collectorz will input whatever Profiler will put out. Anyone have any thoughts?


