Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
#201
Moderator
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
for those in the DC area - the AFI Silver is showing "Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan" on the big screen this Saturday and next Tuesday (I'll be at the latter).
#203
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
Here's the direct link to the TCM page for the July 20th films: http://www.tcm.com/thismonth/article/?cid=241098
You're a brave man to talk about Gabbo and not give him the respect he deserves. Many men have died for less.
We actually were supposed to discuss including fantasy this year but it got handwaved off before it got started. I'm not sure what good discussion ever does, anyway. We always get stuck with the original draft of rules because people get so attached to them they fight tooth and nail every change regardless of the potential of improvement.
Since it was a sci-fi challenge, I didn't want to specifically include fantasy, in name. Since sci-fi and fantasy are closely linked, I thought fantasy fans would be happy since all they had to do was find a sci-fi aspect in it to be allowed. Then it could still be a sci-fi challenge but fantasy people could still watch most of their stuff.
#204
Moderator
#205
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
This is only year two of Sci-fi, and there wasn't really much of a call for change. And even this one has had changes/additions since it started (adding the checklist and the weekly watch list for example).
#206
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
Do I have to include the days on the List Thread? I've already watched a lot of stuff and can't remember what days I watched what on.
#208
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#210
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
#211
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#214
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#215
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
Can we use wild cards? I'd like to watch The Right Stuff and For All Mankind, not to mention the 50's sci-fi doc included with Forbidden Planet.
#216
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
okay official dvdtalk challenge expert here laying down some laws!
sci-fi themed porn is okay, just as long as you list according to the rules specified in the op. fast-forwarding is strickly forbidden though. and dont worry bout the females in here - they can count fantasy-porn in the upcoming fantasy challenge tba by rob and dimension soon.
the matrix is always a good movie to watch. so watch it now. the sequels though are optional.
finally, i bravely await and am looking forward to the coming of gabbo.
sci-fi themed porn is okay, just as long as you list according to the rules specified in the op. fast-forwarding is strickly forbidden though. and dont worry bout the females in here - they can count fantasy-porn in the upcoming fantasy challenge tba by rob and dimension soon.
the matrix is always a good movie to watch. so watch it now. the sequels though are optional.
finally, i bravely await and am looking forward to the coming of gabbo.
#217
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
3 wild cards for all.
Use for those shows you want to watch but know they really don't count. The ones where it's really close to counting. Wild cards also count for all fantasy shows/movies.
Last edited by The Man with the Golden Doujinshi; 07-09-09 at 10:07 AM.
#219
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
Anyone ever watch Earth2? I got the set for $5 or something, have never seen an episode, and am contemplating it if I finish BSG before the month ends.
#220
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
How do I know nothing of this!? Off to wiki it.... Is it good, or at least fun?
Great choice! Love the Venture Bros.
And how was the Sunshine commentary?
How do you like these? I love the books, but have never gotten around to watching these.
How are these holding up for you? I loved it as a kid, but have a feeling it will be one of those shows that I wouldn't like as an adult.
I was afraid of that (1 star). Loved the original, and the completest in me is compelled to buy the "sequel", even knowing how awful it is.
And how was the Sunshine commentary?
How do you like these? I love the books, but have never gotten around to watching these.
I was afraid of that (1 star). Loved the original, and the completest in me is compelled to buy the "sequel", even knowing how awful it is.
#221
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
If I finish TNG Season 7 before the end of the month I plan on alternating this with Deep Space 9. I've never seen it before so I'm looking forward to it.
#223
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
#224
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
The fun part of these challenges is you end up watching films you'd never otherwise see. I doubt if there are other circumstances under which I would view one Critters film, let alone all four.
#225
Senior Member
Re: Summer Sci-Fi Challenge 09 - Discussion Thread
It doesn't hold up very well but it is still fun to watch these episodes and see all the famous guest stars that pop up. I had been meaning to watch this set sooner and this challenge gave me reason to finally.




