Another STAR WARS TRILOGY DVD Release (11/04/2008)
#201
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,483
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Minneapolis, MN, USA
#202
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Is it possible for someone to post some photos of what the insides of these latest Star Wars sets look like? It's just curiosity and not an actual buying decision.
#203
Three year edit!

Last edited by Matt; 09-01-11 at 12:09 PM.
#204
DVD Talk Legend
Sorry here too, my brain didn't shift gears fast enough to get what you meant.
Yeah, I still hold out hope 16x9 versions will appear someday, seems like someone close to George has got to have the cajones to go "really George? A 15 year old laserdisc transfer? Really?" Even Spielberg made his original cut of E.T. available in 16x9, you'd think George would take a lesson from one his BFF's.
Yeah, I still hold out hope 16x9 versions will appear someday, seems like someone close to George has got to have the cajones to go "really George? A 15 year old laserdisc transfer? Really?" Even Spielberg made his original cut of E.T. available in 16x9, you'd think George would take a lesson from one his BFF's.
#206
New Member
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Actually, the better release is the first one, the 4 disc silver boxset. It's the special editions with commentaries and such, and the 4th disc contains trailers, featurettes and a 2.5 hour documentary on the making of the original trilogy.
This newest release of eps 4-6 has the special edition discs, then the three original version discs that are *not* 16x9 enhanced.
So, actually, this is a bad rule of thumb, and is even a carry over from the LD and VHS days of SW releases when newer versions lost extra features from the previous releases.
This newest release of eps 4-6 has the special edition discs, then the three original version discs that are *not* 16x9 enhanced.
So, actually, this is a bad rule of thumb, and is even a carry over from the LD and VHS days of SW releases when newer versions lost extra features from the previous releases.
As for the prequels, I assume that the 2008 release is the one to get?
Also what is the 16x9 version?
Last edited by SuperDayv; 11-18-08 at 12:06 PM.
#207
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,483
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Minneapolis, MN, USA
The new 2008 prequel boxset (I, II, & III) has everything in it, 16x9, features, etc.
#208
New Member
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm guessing that you would prefer the silver box set for the original trilogy (IV, V, VI). It has more features, and doesn't contain the original originals in which you had expressed a lack of interest. The versions of the films are the same as this new boxset, and they are 16x9. With the silver box set, you get an additional disc of bonus features. This additional disc is not part of the new 2008 boxset.
The new 2008 prequel boxset (I, II, & III) has everything in it, 16x9, features, etc.
The new 2008 prequel boxset (I, II, & III) has everything in it, 16x9, features, etc.
Also to be sure, the 2008 release somes with two discs per movie, with the second one being full of special features right? So all of those are included in the 2004 release?
Thanks!
Edit:
My mistake, just looked at the contents again. So as far as the original trilogy goes, one disc contains the 2004 release version while the other contains the original 1977 version?
Last edited by SuperDayv; 11-18-08 at 03:10 PM.
#209
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,483
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Minneapolis, MN, USA
Thanks for the info, but I'm a bit confused. You said that the versions of the film are the same, but that the 2004 release doesn't have the original originals (by that I meant the unaltered 1977 etc release), does that mean the 2008 release does?
Also to be sure, the 2008 release somes with two discs per movie, with the second one being full of special features right? So all of those are included in the 2004 release?
Thanks a bunch.
Also to be sure, the 2008 release somes with two discs per movie, with the second one being full of special features right? So all of those are included in the 2004 release?
Thanks a bunch.
#210
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,483
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Minneapolis, MN, USA
Maybe it'd make more sense to just tell you what I did, and I bet a lot of other people have, as well. It is a sad, tragic tale.
I bought the silver box set, with the extra (4th) disc with the documentaries, etc.
Then, each film in the original trilogy was released in "special editions," which included the disc I already had, plus a second disc with the original film, in non-anamorphic 4:3 widescreen. I also bought each of those, but spread out over several weeks. God damn it, Lucas, I finally bought Return of the Jedi again.
So anyway, each time I bought one of the newer special editions, I plugged it into my silver boxset and sold or otherwise got rid of the old disc. So now I have all of the discs that are currently in the 2008 boxset, but tucked into my silver boxset. I still also retain the 4th disc from the original silver boxset. Best of both worlds, better than the new boxset.
Since you said you didn't want the original originals, it seemed to me that you should get the silver boxset with the additional, fourth disc. Very straightforward decision.
Ooh, unless price is a big issue for you. I see that the new boxset is available online for somewhere around $35, and the old silver box is about $50. So that'd be about $15 for the fourth disc.
You can find out more details on the fourth disc here.
The "Empire of Dreams" documentary makes it a worthwhile purchase, I expect. In fact, I gotta go watch that one again. Oh, and the fourth disc also has trailers and additional docs that are cool, too.
So, to clarify: 2008 boxset: NO "Empire of Dreams," no trailers, etc.
I bought the silver box set, with the extra (4th) disc with the documentaries, etc.
Then, each film in the original trilogy was released in "special editions," which included the disc I already had, plus a second disc with the original film, in non-anamorphic 4:3 widescreen. I also bought each of those, but spread out over several weeks. God damn it, Lucas, I finally bought Return of the Jedi again.
So anyway, each time I bought one of the newer special editions, I plugged it into my silver boxset and sold or otherwise got rid of the old disc. So now I have all of the discs that are currently in the 2008 boxset, but tucked into my silver boxset. I still also retain the 4th disc from the original silver boxset. Best of both worlds, better than the new boxset.
Since you said you didn't want the original originals, it seemed to me that you should get the silver boxset with the additional, fourth disc. Very straightforward decision.
Ooh, unless price is a big issue for you. I see that the new boxset is available online for somewhere around $35, and the old silver box is about $50. So that'd be about $15 for the fourth disc.
You can find out more details on the fourth disc here.
The real bonus content is on the fourth disc, and it's very nice indeed. Front and center is the making-of documentary: "The Empire of Dreams." At two and a half hours, this is a complete film in its own right. Produced and directed by Kevin Burns, who directed the outstanding making-of documentary for Cleopatra, "The Empire of Dreams" follows the making of the three films from beginning to end, using archival footage as well as a bevy of brand-new interviews (from more than 40 participants) to create a detailed picture of the epic story that went on behind the scenes as well as in front of it. Burns was given a mandate by George Lucas to do a truly honest, warts-and-all portrayal, and the result is a fascinating piece that will be a delight to both die-hard fans and relatively casual viewers.
So, to clarify: 2008 boxset: NO "Empire of Dreams," no trailers, etc.
Last edited by evenswr; 11-18-08 at 03:26 PM.
#211
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
2004:
Original trilogy box set, 1 disc per film + 1 disc of special features.
2006:
Individual 2-disc releases for each film, the same 1 disc per film as above + 1 disc with the unaltered version
2008:
Box set featuring the same contents as the three 2-disc sets from 2006.
As for the prequels, they each had an individual release, and the 2008 box set has the same content as the three individual releases.
Hope this helps
Original trilogy box set, 1 disc per film + 1 disc of special features.
2006:
Individual 2-disc releases for each film, the same 1 disc per film as above + 1 disc with the unaltered version
2008:
Box set featuring the same contents as the three 2-disc sets from 2006.
As for the prequels, they each had an individual release, and the 2008 box set has the same content as the three individual releases.
Hope this helps
#212
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 384
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Maybe it'd make more sense to just tell you what I did, and I bet a lot of other people have, as well. It is a sad, tragic tale.
I bought the silver box set, with the extra (4th) disc with the documentaries, etc.
Then, each film in the original trilogy was released in "special editions," which included the disc I already had, plus a second disc with the original film, in non-anamorphic 4:3 widescreen. I also bought each of those, but spread out over several weeks.
So anyway, each time I bought one of the newer special editions, I plugged it into my silver boxset and sold or otherwise got rid of the old disc. So now I have all of the discs that are currently in the 2008 boxset, but tucked into my silver boxset. I still also retain the 4th disc from the original silver boxset. Best of both worlds, better than the new boxset.
Since you said you didn't want the original originals, it seemed to me that you should get the silver boxset with the additional, fourth disc. Very straightforward decision.
Ooh, unless price is a big issue for you. I see that the new boxset is available online for somewhere around $35, and the old silver box is about $50. So that'd be about $15 for the fourth disc.
You can find out more details on the fourth disc here.
The "Empire of Dreams" documentary makes it a worthwhile purchase, I expect. In fact, I gotta go watch that one again. Oh, and the fourth disc also has trailers and additional docs that are cool, too.
So, to clarify: 2008 boxset: NO "Empire of Dreams," no trailers, etc.
I bought the silver box set, with the extra (4th) disc with the documentaries, etc.
Then, each film in the original trilogy was released in "special editions," which included the disc I already had, plus a second disc with the original film, in non-anamorphic 4:3 widescreen. I also bought each of those, but spread out over several weeks.
So anyway, each time I bought one of the newer special editions, I plugged it into my silver boxset and sold or otherwise got rid of the old disc. So now I have all of the discs that are currently in the 2008 boxset, but tucked into my silver boxset. I still also retain the 4th disc from the original silver boxset. Best of both worlds, better than the new boxset.
Since you said you didn't want the original originals, it seemed to me that you should get the silver boxset with the additional, fourth disc. Very straightforward decision.
Ooh, unless price is a big issue for you. I see that the new boxset is available online for somewhere around $35, and the old silver box is about $50. So that'd be about $15 for the fourth disc.
You can find out more details on the fourth disc here.
The "Empire of Dreams" documentary makes it a worthwhile purchase, I expect. In fact, I gotta go watch that one again. Oh, and the fourth disc also has trailers and additional docs that are cool, too.
So, to clarify: 2008 boxset: NO "Empire of Dreams," no trailers, etc.
#214
DVD Talk Legend
Yeah, it's pretty confusing, though I would have done the same thing evenswr did when the original versions were announced, but I'm not buying anymore non-16x9 DVDs. I would have bought this release if he had upgraded the originals and found someone to take the other discs off my hands.




