Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2008 "October Horror Movie Challenge"...
#201
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
I also put Friday the 13th and Halloween in the proper places, and figured Nosferatu is the best choice for the 1st. There are probably other good choices for specific days if we think hard enough. Are the top finishers from last year even still active? I haven't seen most of them in this thread yet.
Last edited by Trevor; 08-23-08 at 12:57 PM.
#202
DVD Talk Legend
#203
DVD Talk Limited Edition
- Nosferatu
- Psycho
- Frankenstein
- Nightmare on Elm Street
- Night of the Living Dead
- The Shining
- Re-animator
- (to be chosen by last year's winner ViewAskewbian)
- (to be chosen by FusionX)
- Rosemary's Baby
- The Exorcist
- Freaks
- Friday the 13th
- (a werewolf film, pending vote) this is the date of the full moon btw
- (to be chosen by Mister Peepers)
- (to be chosen by steelpotato)
- Texas Chainsaw Massacre
- The Invisible Man
- (to be chosen by edwardnortonfan)
- (to be chosen by wlverinefactor)
- The Thing
- Evil Dead
- Shadow of the Vampire
- The Mummy
- Suspiria
- (to be chosen by Crazee4DVDs)
- (to be chosen by EdTheRipper)
- (to be chosen by Dimension X)
- Dracula
- (to be chosen by Chad)
- Halloween
How did I end up before Chad? I thought I finished in tenth place last year.

I don't have a pick yet. Let me think about it for a day or two.
Good call. I had the original werewolf movie in the list originally, must have accidentally edited it out.
How about a quick vote? Which of the above three should go in? I'm good with all three, but probably prefer the original given this context.
And call me a Creature fan, but how about if I put that back in there if one of the finalists from last year doesn't come forward with their vote in the next few weeks?
How about a quick vote? Which of the above three should go in? I'm good with all three, but probably prefer the original given this context.
And call me a Creature fan, but how about if I put that back in there if one of the finalists from last year doesn't come forward with their vote in the next few weeks?
How about putting The Creature From the Black Lagoon in The Invisible Man's slot? (I just watched The Invisible Man and all it's sequels during the SciFi challenge, but I haven't watched The Creature since last October.)
Last edited by Dimension X; 08-23-08 at 02:14 PM.
#206
Moderator
The Innocents
Cat People (orginal)
A Tale of Two Sisters
Session 9
The Changeling
don't mind me I'm just throwing titles off of the top of my head.
Last edited by Giles; 08-23-08 at 02:31 PM.
#207
DVD Talk Gold Edition
#208
DVD Talk Legend
Don't forget Nosferatu. I'm all for more foreign films - Eyes Without a Face, Ringu, Jigoku, Onibaba, Kwaidan, Faust, Kuroneko, Vampyr,Caligari, Bava, etc. I just figured people were less likely to own these titles than American horror films. I could be wrong.
#209
Moderator
#210
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Completely. It's a general failing in most of our film watching behavior I'm sure. Personally, I'm slowly working myself away from American and modern centrism by getting into the Criterion collection sort of films and realizing all that I've been missing.
We could add Audition, or Ringu for an eastern appearance. Although I proudly admit, in this one case, that I like the American The Ring much more.
But you're one of the horror mainstays! You could always do something simple like joining us on these 31 films on the days that you're free to watch them. No commitment, just pop in and join us from time to time.
#211
Moderator
or even Bergman's Hour of the Wolf.
#212
DVD Talk Legend
#213
Moderator
I think I put everyone in the right order, working down from #1 to #12 or so, skipping myself. Figured I'd give Chad the final pick before Halloween, given that this is his baby.
Completely. It's a general failing in most of our film watching behavior I'm sure. Personally, I'm slowly working myself away from American and modern centrism by getting into the Criterion collection sort of films and realizing all that I've been missing.
We could add Audition, or Ringu for an eastern appearance. Although I proudly admit, in this one case, that I like the American The Ring much more.
But you're one of the horror mainstays! You could always do something simple like joining us on these 31 films on the days that you're free to watch them. No commitment, just pop in and join us from time to time.
Completely. It's a general failing in most of our film watching behavior I'm sure. Personally, I'm slowly working myself away from American and modern centrism by getting into the Criterion collection sort of films and realizing all that I've been missing.
We could add Audition, or Ringu for an eastern appearance. Although I proudly admit, in this one case, that I like the American The Ring much more.
But you're one of the horror mainstays! You could always do something simple like joining us on these 31 films on the days that you're free to watch them. No commitment, just pop in and join us from time to time.
Pulse - another essential Asian horror film, though, the original is vastly superior.
#214
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
I'm thinking about trying something different this year, instead of the massive OCD checklist (which you all keep adding to, darn you).
I'm thinking of watching one film from each year since the first horror film, 1896, in chronological order (except for our 31 days list).
There appear to be several early years with no true horror films available, and many of the early ones won't count for length, so I may have to add a few to get to 100.
Any of you want to join me, or perhaps aid me in hunting down the 1897-1920 films?
I'm thinking of watching one film from each year since the first horror film, 1896, in chronological order (except for our 31 days list).
There appear to be several early years with no true horror films available, and many of the early ones won't count for length, so I may have to add a few to get to 100.
Any of you want to join me, or perhaps aid me in hunting down the 1897-1920 films?
#215
DVD Talk Legend
A Terrible Night (1896)
The Bewitch Inn (1897)
The Devil in a Convent (1899)
The Treasures of Satan (1902)
The Merry Frolics of Satan (1906)
Plus, there is The Student of Prague (1913) and The Golem (1915), as well as Edison's version of Frankenstein (1910), which you can watch on Youtube- Parts 1 and 2.
Here is Wikipedia's (obviously) incomplete list of horror films released before 1920.
#216
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Thanks! I found a few of those online last year, and saved them.
Was hoping that Wikipedia would help me more, but, as you saw also, it is quite lacking in the early stuff, even the 1930s have gaps. I'm sure there are dedicated horror sites out there with more complete lists/links.
I thought my collection would be fairly complete from the Universal years onward, but I was wrong. Besides the really early years, I'm missing 1967, 1957, 1950, 1949, 1948, 1947, 1938, and 1937.
Was hoping that Wikipedia would help me more, but, as you saw also, it is quite lacking in the early stuff, even the 1930s have gaps. I'm sure there are dedicated horror sites out there with more complete lists/links.
I thought my collection would be fairly complete from the Universal years onward, but I was wrong. Besides the really early years, I'm missing 1967, 1957, 1950, 1949, 1948, 1947, 1938, and 1937.
#217
DVD Talk Legend
I strongly recommend Curse/Night of the Demon for 1957. A Tourneur classic very much in the vein of his best work for Val Lewton. For your 1967 entry, step into the nightmarish world of Coffin Joe with This Night I Will Possess Your Corpse.
Last edited by NoirFan; 08-23-08 at 03:54 PM.
#218
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
In fact, it looks like Netflix has almost no pre-1958 horror, and only one of the 40 years I "need", so they won't be much help to me in this quest.
Last edited by Trevor; 08-23-08 at 04:40 PM.
#219
DVD Talk Legend
#225
http://www.archive.org/details/Manos-TheHandsOfFate
I'll again put in a general plug for the Internet Archive, which has many classics (Freaks, Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, Nosferafu, Carnival of Souls, the original Cat People, others) as well as "classics" like Manos and other un-MSTed fodder, free for download.
Last edited by Shack; 08-23-08 at 10:20 PM.




