Universal Horror in September
#101
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
Yeah, I'll probably cave in and get the Frank set too. I love Universal horror! I think there was small mention that these 2 would also appear on HD DVD, but that doesn't look like it's going to be the case, at least for now.
#103
Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Does anyone know if there are any plans in releasing something like the Classis Monster Collection a few years ago? I only have interest in the original Universal Monster movies like Dracula, Frankenstein (and Bride of Frankenstein), The Wolf Man, The Mummy, The Creature from the Black Lagoon, The Invisible Man, and The Phantom of the Opera. I'd like to either buy the set or each individually but they're all pretty much out of print. Has anyone heard anything?
#104
DVD Talk Legend
at this point I haven't heard of them doing it, and really doubt they will since hte Legacy collections seemed to do so well. I see the original set pop up in used stores and web sites from time to time....may be your best route.
#105
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally Posted by Linko
Does anyone know if there are any plans in releasing something like the Classis Monster Collection a few years ago? I only have interest in the original Universal Monster movies like Dracula, Frankenstein (and Bride of Frankenstein), The Wolf Man, The Mummy, The Creature from the Black Lagoon, The Invisible Man, and The Phantom of the Opera. I'd like to either buy the set or each individually but they're all pretty much out of print. Has anyone heard anything?
#107
Suspended
I just want to correct a few mistakes contained in the dvdbeaver.com's comparison of the Classic Monster Collection edition of "Dracula" and the new 75th Anniversary edition (see: http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film/DVDRev...acula_1931.htm ):
The CMC edition I own has English as well as French subtitles in the English "Dracula". It does not have a French dub track and probably never had one. Furthermore, in at least the Canadian edition I own, the Spanish version was progressive scanned and not interlaced, as mentioned in this review.
Having said this, I had to double dip with the new edition. I had grown used to the too-dark CMC edition and this new cleaned-up version is a nice improvement, in spite of more aggressive cropping. The image, if anything, is even brighter than indicated by the screen captures. It also brings back a little bit of music at the end of the concert scene which was missing from the CMC. (I never even considered buying the dismal "Legacy Collection" edition.) The Spanish version is also improved and cleaned-up.
I find both versions somewhat lacking in the sound department. There is so much silence in this film, it would have been nice to clean up the tracks a little bit more to eliminate background hiss and scratches (which is still preferable, IMHO, to Philip Glass's depressing score). For comparison purposes, listen to the soundtrack of MGM's "The Ghoul" (1933) which has been "sweetened" by Sonic Solutions and is simply astounding: clear as a bell, full spectrum, no hiss, no grating. And why doesn't anyone restore Van Helsing's closing speech, which I remember seeing in a late-night showing of the film a few years back and which is excerpted in the docu "The Road to Dracula"?
Here's an excerpt of dvdreview.com's review ( http://www.dvdreview.com/reviews/pages/2423.shtml ):
I should add that the new commentary by Steve Haberman (scriptwriter of the excellent Mel Brooks' film "Dracula: Dead and Loving It") is unduly harsh to the Spanish version, in view of the fact that it certainly influenced the Mel Brooks version as much as the English one.
The Spanish version is better preserved, has more camera movement, has a modern look, better sound, better and creepier special effects, livelier actors, is 20 minutes longer, using a lot of scenes that were cut from the original (like the mysterious roadside "fire" on the way to Castle Dracula and Van Helsing and Harker coming back from Lucy/Lucia's grave) and gives a precious understanding of how the same script, art direction and concept can yield two different films. My dream version of "Dracula" would incorporate all the extra scenes from the Spanish version (some of which show Lugosi in long shots, by the way) into the existing footage of the English version.
The CMC edition I own has English as well as French subtitles in the English "Dracula". It does not have a French dub track and probably never had one. Furthermore, in at least the Canadian edition I own, the Spanish version was progressive scanned and not interlaced, as mentioned in this review.
Having said this, I had to double dip with the new edition. I had grown used to the too-dark CMC edition and this new cleaned-up version is a nice improvement, in spite of more aggressive cropping. The image, if anything, is even brighter than indicated by the screen captures. It also brings back a little bit of music at the end of the concert scene which was missing from the CMC. (I never even considered buying the dismal "Legacy Collection" edition.) The Spanish version is also improved and cleaned-up.
I find both versions somewhat lacking in the sound department. There is so much silence in this film, it would have been nice to clean up the tracks a little bit more to eliminate background hiss and scratches (which is still preferable, IMHO, to Philip Glass's depressing score). For comparison purposes, listen to the soundtrack of MGM's "The Ghoul" (1933) which has been "sweetened" by Sonic Solutions and is simply astounding: clear as a bell, full spectrum, no hiss, no grating. And why doesn't anyone restore Van Helsing's closing speech, which I remember seeing in a late-night showing of the film a few years back and which is excerpted in the docu "The Road to Dracula"?
Here's an excerpt of dvdreview.com's review ( http://www.dvdreview.com/reviews/pages/2423.shtml ):
All in all, the verdict is very easy. This 75th Anniversary Edition of "Dracula" is the release fans have been waiting for. The fact that Universal decided to put everything that is related to the movie on this disc, beginning with the newly done score and exhaustive commentary tracks, all the way to the full Spanish version and the lengthy documentaries on the film's subject, is more than laudable. This disc is a perfect example how DVD can make film lovers' dreams come true, making all the material accessible to anyone with the single push of a button on your remote control. In fact, because this DVD improves dramatically on an already stellar previous release and is so impressive in its completeness and presentation that it deserves to be honored with our "Gold Seal Of Excellence". Everything you ever wanted to know can be found on this DVD - and then quite some more!
The Spanish version is better preserved, has more camera movement, has a modern look, better sound, better and creepier special effects, livelier actors, is 20 minutes longer, using a lot of scenes that were cut from the original (like the mysterious roadside "fire" on the way to Castle Dracula and Van Helsing and Harker coming back from Lucy/Lucia's grave) and gives a precious understanding of how the same script, art direction and concept can yield two different films. My dream version of "Dracula" would incorporate all the extra scenes from the Spanish version (some of which show Lugosi in long shots, by the way) into the existing footage of the English version.
Last edited by baracine; 09-27-06 at 10:51 AM.
#108
Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Fincher Fan
#109
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Great news about the better transfer. I too actually thought that the spanish Dracula was in some ways superior I just personally didn't like the actor who played the count and that is major.
Lugosi is damn scary.
Lugosi is damn scary.
#110
Suspended
Originally Posted by Davy Mack
Great news about the better transfer. I too actually thought that the spanish Dracula was in some ways superior I just personally didn't like the actor who played the count and that is major.
Lugosi is damn scary.
Lugosi is damn scary.
#112
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 3,178
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: WV
I got the Dracula 75th Anniversary Edition DVD. I compared the transfer to the Legacy Collection and it looks pretty much the same. I did not see any huge improvements.
This review also confirms that the improvement is minimal:
http://www.dvdactive.com/reviews/dvd/dracula2.html
"This new remastered image does boast fewer film scratches and slightly better image clarity, but nothing worth the purchase price alone."
This review also confirms that the improvement is minimal:
http://www.dvdactive.com/reviews/dvd/dracula2.html
"This new remastered image does boast fewer film scratches and slightly better image clarity, but nothing worth the purchase price alone."




