Top DVDs of 2005, According to US
#26
DVD Talk Gold Edition
1 - Major Dundee (Extended)
2 - Lifeboat SE
3 - Val Lewton Collection
4 - Star Wars 3
5 - Naked - Criterion
6 - Ben Hur CE
7 - Sin City - (Extended)
8 - King Kong CE
9 - Wizard of Oz 3 disc set
10 - Jimi Hendrix-Live at Woodstock (if it qualifies)
TV-
1) First Person - The Complete Series (the only tv box set I bought this year, and one of the great tv series of all time)
And a general woo-hoo! for all the Peckinpah that came out and is about to come out, and the Jerry Lewis SEs.
2 - Lifeboat SE
3 - Val Lewton Collection
4 - Star Wars 3
5 - Naked - Criterion
6 - Ben Hur CE
7 - Sin City - (Extended)
8 - King Kong CE
9 - Wizard of Oz 3 disc set
10 - Jimi Hendrix-Live at Woodstock (if it qualifies)
TV-
1) First Person - The Complete Series (the only tv box set I bought this year, and one of the great tv series of all time)
And a general woo-hoo! for all the Peckinpah that came out and is about to come out, and the Jerry Lewis SEs.
#27
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
TV
1.) LOST Season 1 (Emmmy Award Winner and a very Comprehensive TV set)
2.) Chappelle's Show Season 2 (Well, its a great followup to the top selling TV-DVD)
3.) Simpson Season 6 - Homer Head (A complete makeover packaging)
4.) Master of the Universe Season 1 Vol. 1 (Long Overdue TV Set for the 80's popular cartoons)
5. Sex In The City Complete Season 1-6 (probably the flagship of complete series TV set release)
Movies
1.) Batman Begins: 2-disc deluxe edition with comic
2.) Saw: Uncut
3.) Evil Dead 2: Book of the Dead
4.) AppleSeed Limited Edition with Robot Action Figure
5.) StarWars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
6.) Contanstantine: Deluxe Edition
7.) Lemony Snicket's: A Series of Unfortunate Events CE with book
8.) The Incredibles
9.) Cinderella
10.) Office Space Special Edition
1.) LOST Season 1 (Emmmy Award Winner and a very Comprehensive TV set)
2.) Chappelle's Show Season 2 (Well, its a great followup to the top selling TV-DVD)
3.) Simpson Season 6 - Homer Head (A complete makeover packaging)
4.) Master of the Universe Season 1 Vol. 1 (Long Overdue TV Set for the 80's popular cartoons)
5. Sex In The City Complete Season 1-6 (probably the flagship of complete series TV set release)
Movies
1.) Batman Begins: 2-disc deluxe edition with comic
2.) Saw: Uncut
3.) Evil Dead 2: Book of the Dead
4.) AppleSeed Limited Edition with Robot Action Figure
5.) StarWars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
6.) Contanstantine: Deluxe Edition
7.) Lemony Snicket's: A Series of Unfortunate Events CE with book
8.) The Incredibles
9.) Cinderella
10.) Office Space Special Edition
#28
Senior Member
Here are a few to save my spot:
1. King Kong Collector's Tin
2. To Kill A Mockingbird Legacy Series
3. Ben Hur 4 disc set
4. Hoop Dreams Criterion Collection
5. Raging Bull 2 disc Special edition
6. Wizard of Oz 3 disc set
7. Incredibles
8. Jaws: 30th Anniversary
9. Life Aquatic Criterion Collection
10. Howards End - The Merchant Ivory Collection
TV Shows:
1. Arrested Development: Season 2
2. Veronica Mars: Season 1
3. Scrubs: Season 1
4. This is Wonderland: Season 1
5. Wonderfalls: The Complete Series
I'm not sure which category to put it in The Director's Label Volume 2 set is one of this year's best releases.
1. King Kong Collector's Tin
2. To Kill A Mockingbird Legacy Series
3. Ben Hur 4 disc set
4. Hoop Dreams Criterion Collection
5. Raging Bull 2 disc Special edition
6. Wizard of Oz 3 disc set
7. Incredibles
8. Jaws: 30th Anniversary
9. Life Aquatic Criterion Collection
10. Howards End - The Merchant Ivory Collection
TV Shows:
1. Arrested Development: Season 2
2. Veronica Mars: Season 1
3. Scrubs: Season 1
4. This is Wonderland: Season 1
5. Wonderfalls: The Complete Series
I'm not sure which category to put it in The Director's Label Volume 2 set is one of this year's best releases.
Last edited by Atreus; 01-02-06 at 09:54 PM.
#29
DVD Talk Legend
The list consist of movie and TV titles of 2005 that I purchased.
Movies
1) King Kong (1933)
2) Ran CC
3) Batman Begins: DE with comic book
4) Laura - Fox Film Noir Collection
5) WDT: Donald Duck Vol 2
6) Bambi PE
7) Kagemusha CC
8) 40 Year Old Virgin
9) Warner Gangster Collection
10) Classic Comedies Collection
TV
1) Muppet Show Season 1
2) Murphy Brown S1
3) The Simpsons S7
4) The Simpsons S6
5) Batman TAS Vol 3
Movies
1) King Kong (1933)
2) Ran CC
3) Batman Begins: DE with comic book
4) Laura - Fox Film Noir Collection
5) WDT: Donald Duck Vol 2
6) Bambi PE
7) Kagemusha CC
8) 40 Year Old Virgin
9) Warner Gangster Collection
10) Classic Comedies Collection
TV
1) Muppet Show Season 1
2) Murphy Brown S1
3) The Simpsons S7
4) The Simpsons S6
5) Batman TAS Vol 3
Last edited by LorenzoL; 01-02-06 at 09:38 AM.
#31
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 1,609
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Out of the sandbox!
Hello 2006, goodbye 2005!
Movie
1. Batman Begins: Two-disc Deluxe Edtion
2. Sin City EE
3. King Kong Collectors Tin
4. Star Trek: The Motion Pictures Collection
5. Million Dollar Baby: 3 Disc Deluxe Edtion
6. Saw: Uncut Edtion
7. American Pycho: Killer Collector's Edtion
8. The Truman Show: Special Edtion
9. Jumanji: Deluxe Edtion
10. Appleseed: Limited Collector's Edtion
TV
1. Stargate SG-1: Season 8
2. Ghost in the Shell LE Vol 7 Tin
3. Thundercats Season 1 Vol 1
4. Thundercats Season 1 Vol 2
5. Lost Season 1
Movie
1. Batman Begins: Two-disc Deluxe Edtion
2. Sin City EE
3. King Kong Collectors Tin
4. Star Trek: The Motion Pictures Collection
5. Million Dollar Baby: 3 Disc Deluxe Edtion
6. Saw: Uncut Edtion
7. American Pycho: Killer Collector's Edtion
8. The Truman Show: Special Edtion
9. Jumanji: Deluxe Edtion
10. Appleseed: Limited Collector's Edtion
TV
1. Stargate SG-1: Season 8
2. Ghost in the Shell LE Vol 7 Tin
3. Thundercats Season 1 Vol 1
4. Thundercats Season 1 Vol 2
5. Lost Season 1
Last edited by gijon213; 01-02-06 at 12:08 PM.
#32
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,122
Received 1,721 Likes
on
1,411 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Movie
1. Sin City (Recut & Extended Edition)...I know it isn't out yet, but one of my most favorite movies of the year will get the deluxe edition with what will be my most favorite DVD set of the year!
2. Batman Begins (2-Disc Deluxe Edition)...movie blew me away, took me by surprise and didn't let go. extremely entertaining!
3. Léon: The Professional (Deluxe Edition)...what needs to be said about this instant classic that got the royal treatment earlier this year.
4. Jaws (30th Anniversary Edition)...scraed the bejesus out of me. "better than Gremlins, better than E.T.!"
5. King Kong (Collector's Tin Edition) (1933)
6. The Fly (Special Edition)
7. The Outsiders: The Complete Novel
8. Gladiator (Extended Edition)
9. Cannibal Holocaust: 25th Anniversary Edition...been wanting this one for awhile. haven't watched it yet, but the set will be amazing i'm sure.
10. Ben-Hur (Collector's Edition)
TV
1. Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Chosen Collection ...with all its crimson red glory. one of my most favorite series of all time.
2. Scrubs: The Complete 2nd Season
3. Degrassi Junior High: All 3 Seasons
4. Undeclared: The Complete Series...haven't watched, but i hear good things.
5. Scrubs: The Complete 1st Season
ps) didn't Raging Bull come out late last year?
1. Sin City (Recut & Extended Edition)...I know it isn't out yet, but one of my most favorite movies of the year will get the deluxe edition with what will be my most favorite DVD set of the year!
2. Batman Begins (2-Disc Deluxe Edition)...movie blew me away, took me by surprise and didn't let go. extremely entertaining!
3. Léon: The Professional (Deluxe Edition)...what needs to be said about this instant classic that got the royal treatment earlier this year.
4. Jaws (30th Anniversary Edition)...scraed the bejesus out of me. "better than Gremlins, better than E.T.!"
5. King Kong (Collector's Tin Edition) (1933)
6. The Fly (Special Edition)
7. The Outsiders: The Complete Novel
8. Gladiator (Extended Edition)
9. Cannibal Holocaust: 25th Anniversary Edition...been wanting this one for awhile. haven't watched it yet, but the set will be amazing i'm sure.
10. Ben-Hur (Collector's Edition)
TV
1. Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Chosen Collection ...with all its crimson red glory. one of my most favorite series of all time.
2. Scrubs: The Complete 2nd Season
3. Degrassi Junior High: All 3 Seasons
4. Undeclared: The Complete Series...haven't watched, but i hear good things.
5. Scrubs: The Complete 1st Season
ps) didn't Raging Bull come out late last year?
Last edited by OldBoy; 11-17-05 at 07:49 PM.
#34
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,122
Received 1,721 Likes
on
1,411 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Originally Posted by Scott Weinberg
Also, Scrubs: Season One and Scrubs: Season Two are two separate releases. Great picks, IMO, but please rank 'em individually. (I think S2 is a tiny bit better.)
#37
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by scott1598
Movie
TV
1. Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Chosen Collection ...with all its crimson red glory. one of my most favorite series of all time.
ps) didn't Raging Bull come out late last year?
TV
1. Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Chosen Collection ...with all its crimson red glory. one of my most favorite series of all time.
ps) didn't Raging Bull come out late last year?
Raging Bull is a 2005 release. It came out in February.
#38
10. The Man Who Fell to Earth CC
9. Harakiri CC
8. The Incredibles
7. Naked CC
6. Gladiator Extended Edition
5. Raging Bull
4. Batman Special Edition
3. Ugetsu CC
2. To Kill a Mockingbird
1. The Wizard of Oz
9. Harakiri CC
8. The Incredibles
7. Naked CC
6. Gladiator Extended Edition
5. Raging Bull
4. Batman Special Edition
3. Ugetsu CC
2. To Kill a Mockingbird
1. The Wizard of Oz
#39
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 899
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Movie:
1. Film Noir Classic Collection, Vol. 2
2. Harold Lloyd Comedy Collection
3. King Kong
4. Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection
5. No Direction Home: Bob Dylan
6. Bambi
7. Warner Gangsters Collection
8. Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
9. Raging Bull SE
10. Kagemusha
TV:
1. Arrested Development Season 2
2. Muppet Show Season 1
3. Sopranos Season 5
4. Simpsons Season 6
5. The West Wing Season 4
That's the final one for me now. The West Wing season 5 and the Simpsons Season 7 are both close, but the season sets for those and the ones on my list are pretty similar, so I'm going to stick with the earlier ones.
1. Film Noir Classic Collection, Vol. 2
2. Harold Lloyd Comedy Collection
3. King Kong
4. Hitchcock Masterpiece Collection
5. No Direction Home: Bob Dylan
6. Bambi
7. Warner Gangsters Collection
8. Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith
9. Raging Bull SE
10. Kagemusha
TV:
1. Arrested Development Season 2
2. Muppet Show Season 1
3. Sopranos Season 5
4. Simpsons Season 6
5. The West Wing Season 4
That's the final one for me now. The West Wing season 5 and the Simpsons Season 7 are both close, but the season sets for those and the ones on my list are pretty similar, so I'm going to stick with the earlier ones.
Last edited by kingtopher; 12-16-05 at 10:23 PM.
#40
DVD Talk Reviewer
Films:
1) Batman Begins DE
2) Batman Anthology
3) Star Wars Episode III
4) Sin City
5) Donnie Darko Director's Cut
6) The Outsiders Complete Novel
7) Unleashed Unrated
8) Titanic SE
9) American Psycho Unrated
10) The Big Lebowski SE
TV:
1) Lost Season 1
Only new TV to DVD purchase I made in 2005. What a great one.
1) Batman Begins DE
2) Batman Anthology
3) Star Wars Episode III
4) Sin City
5) Donnie Darko Director's Cut
6) The Outsiders Complete Novel
7) Unleashed Unrated
8) Titanic SE
9) American Psycho Unrated
10) The Big Lebowski SE
TV:
1) Lost Season 1
Only new TV to DVD purchase I made in 2005. What a great one.
#41
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,122
Received 1,721 Likes
on
1,411 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
Originally Posted by Sweet Baby James
Since I'm playing thread cop, you'll have to replace Buffy. The OP specifically used Buffy as an example for exclusion. It's in the small print of his first post that nobody ever bothers to read.
Raging Bull is a 2005 release. It came out in February.
Raging Bull is a 2005 release. It came out in February.
#42
DVD Talk Special Edition
TV
1.FRIENDS:Season 10(Very one-sided vote,as this is my favorite show and a acceptable DVD)
2.Lost:Season 1
3.Seinfeld Season 5 & 6 Box Set
4.Seinfeld Season 4
5.Everybody Loves Raymond Season 4
Movies
1.War of the Worlds:LE
2.Batman SE Anthology
3.Star Wars Episode III
4.Jaws 30th AE
5.Batman Begins DE
6.Sin City:EE
7.The Fly-Collector's Edition
8.Toy Story 10 AE
9.Toy Story 2 SE
10.Incredibles SE
1.FRIENDS:Season 10(Very one-sided vote,as this is my favorite show and a acceptable DVD)
2.Lost:Season 1
3.Seinfeld Season 5 & 6 Box Set
4.Seinfeld Season 4
5.Everybody Loves Raymond Season 4
Movies
1.War of the Worlds:LE
2.Batman SE Anthology
3.Star Wars Episode III
4.Jaws 30th AE
5.Batman Begins DE
6.Sin City:EE
7.The Fly-Collector's Edition
8.Toy Story 10 AE
9.Toy Story 2 SE
10.Incredibles SE
Last edited by TNAJason; 01-01-06 at 08:05 PM.
#43
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 10,380
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Blu-ray.com
1. Greta Garbo Boxset (Warner Brothers)
2. Der Untergang (Columbia) –FOR THE FILM, NOT THE DVD!!!!
3. Andjei Wajda-Three War Films (Criterion)
4. L’Eclisse (Criterion)
5. East of Eden (Warner Brothers)
6. The Fernando Arrabal Collection (Cult Epics)
7. Ben Hur 4DVD (Warner Brothers)
8. Reconstruction (Palm Pictures)
9. Arven a.k.a The Inheritance (HVE)
10. Partner- (NoShame Films)
Sorry...I do not watch TV product or collect it.....
Ciao,
Pro-B
2. Der Untergang (Columbia) –FOR THE FILM, NOT THE DVD!!!!
3. Andjei Wajda-Three War Films (Criterion)
4. L’Eclisse (Criterion)
5. East of Eden (Warner Brothers)
6. The Fernando Arrabal Collection (Cult Epics)
7. Ben Hur 4DVD (Warner Brothers)
8. Reconstruction (Palm Pictures)
9. Arven a.k.a The Inheritance (HVE)
10. Partner- (NoShame Films)
Sorry...I do not watch TV product or collect it.....
Ciao,
Pro-B
#44
Senior Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 678
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Gainesville, FL
Here's my list so far:
Movies
10. Reserved for Sin City Recut & Extended Edition
09. The Fifth Element SE
08. High Tension Unrated
07. Tale of Two Sisters
06. The Fly SE
05. Wizard of Oz
04. Star Wars Episode III
03. Oldboy
02. Batman Begins DE
01. Reserved for King Kong
TV
05. Newsradio S1&2
04. Undeclared Complete Series
03. Scrubs S2
02. House M.D. S1 (I know it's not anamorphic, but it's a great show that I would've missed if it didn't come out on DVD!)
01. Lost S1
Movies
10. Reserved for Sin City Recut & Extended Edition
09. The Fifth Element SE
08. High Tension Unrated
07. Tale of Two Sisters
06. The Fly SE
05. Wizard of Oz
04. Star Wars Episode III
03. Oldboy
02. Batman Begins DE
01. Reserved for King Kong
TV
05. Newsradio S1&2
04. Undeclared Complete Series
03. Scrubs S2
02. House M.D. S1 (I know it's not anamorphic, but it's a great show that I would've missed if it didn't come out on DVD!)
01. Lost S1
#45
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by scott1598
why would I exclude "Buffy"?...it is an amazing release with a new bonus disc that just came out yesterday.
#48
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 829
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Deep in the Heart of Texas
Films:
1) Star Wars Revenge of the Sith
2) The Incredibles
3) Batman Begins (2-disc limited edition with comic)
4) Elf, Infinifilm
5) Battlefront Europe
6) National Treasure
7) Bambi
8)
9)
10)
TV:
1) Lost: S1
2) Sopranos: S5
3) Seinfeld: S4
4) Everyone Loves Raymond: S4
5) Stargate: S8
Thats it so far
1) Star Wars Revenge of the Sith
2) The Incredibles
3) Batman Begins (2-disc limited edition with comic)
4) Elf, Infinifilm
5) Battlefront Europe
6) National Treasure
7) Bambi
8)
9)
10)
TV:
1) Lost: S1
2) Sopranos: S5
3) Seinfeld: S4
4) Everyone Loves Raymond: S4
5) Stargate: S8
Thats it so far
#49
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally Posted by mike7162
TV-
1) First Person - The Complete Series (the only tv box set I bought this year, and one of the great tv series of all time)
1) First Person - The Complete Series (the only tv box set I bought this year, and one of the great tv series of all time)
- Being in the UK i'm none too familiar with many US TV series but have to say i found this immensely enjoyable/informative etc.As for choosing 4 others wouldn't know where to begin as i'd be struggling to think of any(R1 at any rate)..as for film...wouldn't know where to begin in deciding an order, on the whole i've been very pleased with what has been made available in 2005.
#50
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 332
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Movies:
1. Sin City ReCut
2. Office Space Gift Set (BB)
3. Batman Begins Deluxe
4. Gladiator Extended
5. Big Lebowski Achiever's Edition (rip-off, but damn cool)
6. Saw Uncut
7. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Deluxe
8. Donnie Darko DC
9. American Psycho Killer
10. Get Shorty SE
TV:
1) Arrested Development Season 2
2) Curb Your Enthusiasm Season 4
3) South Park Season 6
4) Family Guy Volume 3
5) Ali G Show Season 2
1. Sin City ReCut
2. Office Space Gift Set (BB)
3. Batman Begins Deluxe
4. Gladiator Extended
5. Big Lebowski Achiever's Edition (rip-off, but damn cool)
6. Saw Uncut
7. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Deluxe
8. Donnie Darko DC
9. American Psycho Killer
10. Get Shorty SE
TV:
1) Arrested Development Season 2
2) Curb Your Enthusiasm Season 4
3) South Park Season 6
4) Family Guy Volume 3
5) Ali G Show Season 2



