Well, except for the fact that not every Superbit has looked or sounded as good as one would think under that banner. In fact, there are many 2 disc SE titles that beat many Superbit titles.

Of course, it would be unlikely this time, seeing as they're being put out at the same time...

I'll probably wait for a review on SE vs SB first...

But then the SE at BB has a bonus disc with the "VH1 Goes Inside Spider-Man" feature. Is this feature any good?

2.5 is out early next year?

or atleast in 2007 when Spidey 3 comes out.

Superbit for me

The optimal decision would be to get either the Gift Set or 2-Disc AND the Superbit. The extras on the Special Edition are truly special and deserved to be watched.

I pre-ordered the Superbit. As others have mentioned, there will be a ton of used copies of the 2-Disc available for re-sale for close to nothing in a short period of time. I'll probably pick one of these copies up for the supplemental material. If one is willing to wait, I'm sure the price of the Spider-man 2 Gift Set will likely come done in price as well. The original Spider-man Gift Set came down in price in short order and can now be purchased for only $19.99 at Best Buy. Then there is the rumored Spider-man 2 2.5 version lurking on the horizon. I'm sure I'll be happy with my Superbit with it's optimal transfer and DTS until I decide on my options related to the other releases.

What are the extras on the SE? And are their any extras at all on the SB?

The extras on the SE are as follows:

Commentary by director Sam Raimi, actor Tobey Maguire, producer Ani Ahrati, and coproducer Grant Curtis

Technical commentary

"Spidey Sense 2" pop-up trivia track

Blooper reel

Four Web-isodes: original online featurettes

Train music video: "Ordinary"

Disc 2:

"Making the Amazing": A 2 hour 12-part documentary

"Hero in Crisis": a deeper look into Peter Parker and his personal battles

"Ock-umentary: Eight Arms to Hold You"

"Interwoven: The Women of Spider-Man"

"Enter the Web": groundbreaking multi-angle look behind the scenes

Art gallery

Behind-the-scenes look at the Activision game

Superbits do not contain extras, except for the Superbit of the original Spider-Man, it had a 1.0 Commentary with Tobey Maguire and J.K. Simmons.

according to Movie Gallery's PVD release schedule you will be able to get the 2 disc SE for 9.99 December 13.....I believe the buy 2 get 2 free will still be going on them so we're planning to pick up athe se then.

Superbit for me too.

i dont see myself watching all the extras more than once. Superbit for me!

Superbit.

The sound on the 2-Disc was pretty good, so I'll probably pass on the Superbit.

2-Disc SE

I thought the 2.5 was scheduled for next year :(

If not, then I'll probably pick up the SE

SE for me via Columbia House.

Superbit! The only extras I'll miss are the commentaries.

Gift Set arrived from Amazon today... Can't wait to watch it later tonight. :)

I havent tried a Superbit yet on my big HDTV and I think I just might give it a go with this one

2-disc SE for me.

I can't decide!!! :( :(

2-Disc. Superbit is a waste...wait until real HD arrives.

do a search...this one is still pretty fresh

spidey double dip

or...

ps)..i got both 2-disc and sb for free...go me.