View Poll Results: Is the content discription too much?
No, it perfect for curious parents



44
61.11%
yes its a bit much



10
13.89%
I don't care what it says



18
25.00%
other.



0
0%
Voters: 72. You may not vote on this poll
Animatrix parental warning, helpfull or pointless?
#27
Retired
I love to see stuff like this.
Not all parents are going to know what the Animatrix is, and it's unrated as far as I know so they can't just look at the rating like they normally due with videos.
They could fairly easily mistake it for a typical superhero cartoon and think nothing of buying it for their 8 year old or whatever. Now they can read that, and see that it ties in with an R-rated movie and is designed with that audience in mind, and thus wouldn't likely be appropriate for their child.
Not all parents are going to know what the Animatrix is, and it's unrated as far as I know so they can't just look at the rating like they normally due with videos.
They could fairly easily mistake it for a typical superhero cartoon and think nothing of buying it for their 8 year old or whatever. Now they can read that, and see that it ties in with an R-rated movie and is designed with that audience in mind, and thus wouldn't likely be appropriate for their child.
#29
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 1,176
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Texas
OMG, how dare they ? How dare they ruin my animatrix DVD with a warning on the case !!! Those inconsiderate jerks ! Let's blame this on the parents !!! yeah !! How stupid do they have to be to put a parental warning on a DVD that contains material that is not rated ? I mean that's about as dumb as you can get ! What a stupid idea !!! What kind of idiot parent reads the back of a DVD to find out what it is about and if the material is suitable for their children !!!
#30
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,960
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: in the land of humidity
I guess my only complaint...hell, it's not really a complaint...its just a bit more wordy than your average warning. I'm used to PARENTAL ADVISORY: EXPLICIT CONTENT as my warning as opposed to the miniature novel written on it. Then I found it a bit redundant to show up on the screen when I popped in the DVD... perhaps just the PARENTAL ADVISORY thingy on the box, and then the more detailed warning on the DVD itself? I dunno...
As long as it doesn't censor what I wanna see, go ahead and warn all ya want.
As long as it doesn't censor what I wanna see, go ahead and warn all ya want.
#31
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally posted by caiman
So parents are dumb for not knowing the exact content of the Animatrix DVD?
So parents are dumb for not knowing the exact content of the Animatrix DVD?
...well I didn't know a game called Grand Theft Auto was so violent...
#34
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Well, why would you buy your kids something based on an R rated film? still, I think the warning is fine because there isn't a rating on it. I'd have been more mad if they watered it down to get a lower rating, even if it is based on an R rated movie (like the game was.)
#39
DVD Talk Hero
Isn't there a PG-13 rating on the back cover of the Animatrix? I'll have to check my copy if no one knows.
Parents should try to screen the "cartoons" their children watch if it appears to be of questionable content (meaning, if you think it might be, it probably is), it's part of being a parent.
Parents should try to screen the "cartoons" their children watch if it appears to be of questionable content (meaning, if you think it might be, it probably is), it's part of being a parent.
#40
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally posted by duz
The Matrix toys (which are for sale at toys r us) say on them "Recommened for the Mature Collector" and "Not for children under 17"
Partly due toa big bruhaha over the fact that there are action figures for r rated movies and m rated video games, some parents would rather censor the world then actually do some parenting but i digress
The Matrix toys (which are for sale at toys r us) say on them "Recommened for the Mature Collector" and "Not for children under 17"
Partly due toa big bruhaha over the fact that there are action figures for r rated movies and m rated video games, some parents would rather censor the world then actually do some parenting but i digress
Once again, where's Jackskeleton when you need him?
#41
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by Patman
Isn't there a PG-13 rating on the back cover of the Animatrix? I'll have to check my copy if no one knows.
Isn't there a PG-13 rating on the back cover of the Animatrix? I'll have to check my copy if no one knows.
The scan from the 1st page clearly shows 'not rated'
#42
DVD Talk Godfather
The only short that was rated is Final Flight, which was PG-13, since it aired in front of Dreamcatcher.
As for the warning, i could care less. If it helps parents make a decision on buying it, then great.
As for the warning, i could care less. If it helps parents make a decision on buying it, then great.
#43
Retired
Originally posted by Michael Corvin
Does it have to be an impulse buy? Take 5 minutes and look it up online find out what it is about and if it is suitable for kids. Same goes for anything...
Does it have to be an impulse buy? Take 5 minutes and look it up online find out what it is about and if it is suitable for kids. Same goes for anything...
Originally posted by Michael Corvin
...well I didn't know a game called Grand Theft Auto was so violent...
...well I didn't know a game called Grand Theft Auto was so violent...
At any rate, I don't see why anyone would care about this. Who cares if there's a warning on the back? How does that affect your enjoyment of the DVD?
Oops. I forgot this is DVD talk and many here are so anal they can't enjoy a movie if they don't like the cover art.
#44
DVD Talk Limited Edition
The warning's a good thing; part of being a responsible parent would include reading the box before you got it. Irresponsible parents would buy it if it was NC17, and had pictures of blowing-up heads on the cover (as long as there was no nudity shown).
As far as advisories in general, overall, I like the fact that now they tell you the reason why things are rated as they are (although some of them are really stupid). It seems much more informative than just giving a rating with no explanation, and allows parents to make a fairly informed decision before actually watching something.
As far as advisories in general, overall, I like the fact that now they tell you the reason why things are rated as they are (although some of them are really stupid). It seems much more informative than just giving a rating with no explanation, and allows parents to make a fairly informed decision before actually watching something.
Last edited by Ginwen; 06-04-03 at 02:45 PM.
#46
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
This warning is to help parents when their kid picks it up off the shelf in Wal-mart and is begging them to buy it for them. Sure if the kid just asks for it sometime, they can take a few minutes and look it up, but the warning helps parents make an informed decision on the spot.
#47
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Alright, I watched up to the one with the Cat. With the exception of the guy and his brains coming out, and the brief nudity in "the second rennasonce", I thought most of this was tame. Now I highly enjoyed this program, its just that the violence isn't that bad.
#48
Cool New Member
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Surprise, AZ
Originally posted by Rypro 525
Alright, I watched up to the one with the Cat. With the exception of the guy and his brains coming out, and the brief nudity in "the second rennasonce", I thought most of this was tame. Now I highly enjoyed this program, its just that the violence isn't that bad.
Alright, I watched up to the one with the Cat. With the exception of the guy and his brains coming out, and the brief nudity in "the second rennasonce", I thought most of this was tame. Now I highly enjoyed this program, its just that the violence isn't that bad.



