Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
#101
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
No, what you describe is definitely the definition of a legacy character. The question is, has there been more than one person who has used the Superman name and who has had his own title? Do the Earth-1, Earth-2, and Post-Crisis Clark Kent count as three people or one?
#103
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
I'd say yes- see Bus' post for why.
(oh, and all the different Earths would count as 1 I'd say, too)
(oh, and all the different Earths would count as 1 I'd say, too)
Last edited by reverie; 08-10-09 at 12:16 PM.
#104
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
One.
#105
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep

Look at all those different versions of Firestorm, several of which had their own titles over the years. 2 poitns each for:
CaptainMarvel
ivelostr2
#107
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep

There have been a number of different versions fo Hawkman over the years, to the point where DC, at one point, threw up its hands and stopped publishing the character because they couldn't figure out which was which. 2 points.
Mboyd
Rockmjd23
#108
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
Which leaves our final two examples, and the two I had in mind when I came up with this question:


Not pictured: Kyle, Guy, John, Wally, and Bart.


Not pictured: Kyle, Guy, John, Wally, and Bart.
#109
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
Each was worth 3 points!
Flash
JasonF
fumanstan
brianluvdvd
Green Lantern
The Bus
Lokimok
davidh777
Flash
JasonF
fumanstan
brianluvdvd
Green Lantern
The Bus
Lokimok
davidh777
#110
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
Which makes the wrong answers worth 4 points. Since nobody has spoken up in defense of any of them besides Superman, all of the others are wrong. Superman still feels a little fishy to me, but I will allow it on the strength of the Reign of the Superman storyline.
#112
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
Now we're starting to see some separation in the players:
1 dadaluholla -15
1 foggy -15
1 orangecrush -15
1 RKillgore -15
1 brainee -15
1 Trevor -15
1 fujishig -15
1 davidh777 -11
8 Mboyd -12
8 CaptainMarvel -12
8 reverie -12
8 ivelostr2 -12
12 JasonF -11
12 brianluvdvd -11
12 The Bus -11
12 fumanstan -11
12 Lokimok -11
18 burnside986 -10
18 maxfisher -10
18 Nick Danger -10
21 Meatwad's Ghost -5
22 Rockmjd23 -2
22 Tracer Bullet -2
24 Nogura -1
24 hitman tommy -1
1 dadaluholla -15
1 foggy -15
1 orangecrush -15
1 RKillgore -15
1 brainee -15
1 Trevor -15
1 fujishig -15
1 davidh777 -11
8 Mboyd -12
8 CaptainMarvel -12
8 reverie -12
8 ivelostr2 -12
12 JasonF -11
12 brianluvdvd -11
12 The Bus -11
12 fumanstan -11
12 Lokimok -11
18 burnside986 -10
18 maxfisher -10
18 Nick Danger -10
21 Meatwad's Ghost -5
22 Rockmjd23 -2
22 Tracer Bullet -2
24 Nogura -1
24 hitman tommy -1
#115
Thread Starter
Suspended
#118
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
OK. The Excel problem is fixed now. Because davidh was a last-minute entrant, I forgot to tweak one of the formulas for his line of the spreadsheet. Problem solved now.
#120
Thread Starter
Suspended
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
Nobody went with 2000 AD (or the Beano, for that matter). But let's talk about your answer. It perplexed me, particularly since you used Google. The Bus's answer was, and I quote:
Vaillant*

Yeah. We're going to go ahead and count that as wrong, mkay?
Vaillant*

Yeah. We're going to go ahead and count that as wrong, mkay?
#125
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Comic Book Sheep 2: Crisis on Infinite Sheep
You know it's not Prince Valiant, right?










