If I had to pick a favorite, it'd be Riddler. If I had to pick sheep.. well, we'll see how I do first!

Nick Danger is agitating for Catwoman ... but we can't forget the Penguin and Two-Face.

Catwoman is worth -14 points for the following 7 players:
burnside986
dadaluholla
reverie
RKillgore
Nick Danger
Lokimok
davih777

But could you have done better if you had gone with Two-Face or the Penguin?

Did you flip a coin to decide which villain to go with? If it came up on the Two-Face side, you got -14 points. See -- a Catwoman person would have done better to go with Two-Face because then Catwoman would have been bumped down by two and Two-Face up by two.

JasonF
CaptainMarvel
orangecrush
brainee
Meatwad's Ghost
maxfisher
fumanstan

Which *waugh* *waugh* waugh* leaves the Penguin. *waugh* *waugh* waugh*. He is also worth -14 points for the following players:

brianluvdvd
foggy
Mboyd
ivelostr2
Trevor
The Bus
fujishig

And so, after one question, we have a 20-way tie for the lead:

1 JasonF -14
1 burnside986 -14
1 dadaluholla -14
1 brianluvdvd -14
1 foggy -14
1 Mboyd -14
1 CaptainMarvel -14
1 orangecrush -14
1 reverie -14
1 RKillgore -14
1 ivelostr2 -14
1 brainee -14
1 Trevor -14
1 maxfisher -14
1 The Bus -14
1 fumanstan -14
1 fujishig -14
1 Nick Danger -14
1 Lokimok -14
1 davidh777 -14
21 Rockmjd23 -4
21 Tracer Bullet -4
21 Meatwad's Ghost -4
24 Nogura 0
24 hitman tommy 0

Interesting break downs....!

That's a Sheep First™: all three Sheep answers in the double-digits tied for the same # of points.

2. R: Name a "legacy character" -- a character where two or more people have used the name -- where multiple versions of the character have had their own comic.

We're making Sheep History here!

Let's start with what I believe to be the wrong answers. Some of these are debatable, so have at it.

Hey! Was anybody tending the record books when I claimed that South Park Sheep had a Sheep First™ when the most popular answer in a Reverse question was also incorrect?

Let's start with:

Robin
I believe only the Tim Drake version has had his own series. The Dick Grayson version had solo stories in Batman Family, World's Finest, and Star-Spangled comics, but I don't believe he ever had a solo series.

Thoughts?

That was not a Sheep First™ -- it happened in Other Sheep when we were aksed to name a Milton Bradley game and everyone said "Monopoly."

That was a Sheep question, though, IIRC.

The Question
Vic Sage had his own series, first at Charlton Comics in the 60s and later at DC Comics in the 80s. I don't believe his successor, Renee Montoya, has had her own series yet -- just backups in Detective Comics and appearances in Countdown to the 52 Final Infinities.

Oh, good point.

The last time I will be in the top 10 for this game.

Superman
This is a tricky one. There was never a point -- as with a traditional legacy character -- where they said "We're done telling stories about the old Superman. Here's a new guy in the Superman costume." Superman has always been Clark Kent, mild-mannered reporter for a great metropolitan newspaper. And while they retroactively declared that some of his adventures happened to the Earth-2 version of him, he's not a legacy character in the traditional sense. I'm inclined not to count him.

OK. That's it for the ones I am inclined to count as wrong. What say you, angry mob of participants and spectators?

Oops -- one more I think may be wrong:


Black Canary
Another victim of retconning to turn one character into two via the miracle of editorial fiat. Regardless, I think the current version of Black Canary has had a mini or two along the way, but I don't think the Golden Age Black Canary ever had her own title.

Superman Counts +1.

Hmm.. I wasn't aware that legacy character implied they were never bringing back said character.. I think I misunderstood this. I just thought you were looking for a costume/name that was used by more than one person who both had their own title.

But enough wrong answers. Here are some definitely correct ones:


foggy


hitman tommy


fujishig


Meatwad's Ghost


brainee


dadaluholla


Trevor


Nogura


RKillgore

All unique, all worth the -1 unique bonus.

I would say Superman counts only if you count "the four new Supermen" that came after Superman #75.