Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
#1
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
OHN QUESTIONS THE VALIDITY OF MOLLY'S PREGNANCY, ON "EXTANT," AT ITS NEW TIME, WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 6 AT 10:00 PM
Editor's note: "Extant" and "Criminal Minds" swap time periods starting Wednesday, July 30.
Josh Malina Guest Stars as Dr. Beck, Who Treats Molly
Academy, Golden Globe and Emmy Award Winner Louis Gossett, Jr. Returns as Quinn, Molly's Father
"What on Earth is Wrong?" - When the validity of Molly's pregnancy comes into question, John begins to doubt her mental state, on EXTANT, at its new time, Wednesday, August 6 (10:00-11:00 PM, ET/PT) on the CBS Television. Meanwhile, Ethan suffers a serious setback, and John and Julie clash over how to care for him. Josh Malina guest stars as Doctor Beck who treats Molly. Academy Award winner Louis Gossett Jr. returns as Quinn, Molly's estranged father.
SERIES REGULARS:
Halle Berry (Molly Woods)
Goran Visnjic (John Woods)
Pierce Gagnon (Ethan Woods)
Hiroyuki Sanada (Hideki Yasumoto)
Michael O'Neill (Alan Sparks)
Grace Gummer (Julie Gelineau)
AND:
Camryn Manheim (Sam Barton)
GUEST CAST:
Tyler Hilton
Sam Golzari
WITH:
Josh Malina
AND:
Louis Gossett, Jr.
WRITTEN BY: Peter Ocko
DIRECTED BY: Dan Lerner
Episode 5 of 13
Previous Threads:
Episode 4
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/621...7-30-14-a.html
Episode 3
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/621...7-23-14-a.html
Episode 2
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/621...7-16-14-a.html
Episode 1
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/621...7-09-14-a.html
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
Quickly gaining on Under The Dome. No evidence of being pregnant? Come on...
But still enjoying the rest of the show. Didn't see the artificial leg scene coming. And I find that woman more attractive than HB, so that was a great scene.
But still enjoying the rest of the show. Didn't see the artificial leg scene coming. And I find that woman more attractive than HB, so that was a great scene.
Last edited by hdnmickey; 08-12-14 at 05:23 PM.
#4
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
I'm still enjoying the show, but if this forum is any indication, interest is dying down.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
#6
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,917
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
I'm still enjoying the show, but if this forum is any indication, interest is dying down.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
I really wanted to land there, but given the 2014 era standards used to determine she was pregnant, they don't get to turn around and make the same signs impossibly reversible without some complex explanation. Maybe if they had something other than a blood test and ultrasound. And like Mulder, I want to believe.
#8
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
It's not Under The Dome...yet. The acting is better and the writers appear to be taking things a little more seriously. It does have train-wreck potential down the line.
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,917
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
I really wanted to land there, but given the 2014 era standards used to determine she was pregnant, they don't get to turn around and make the same signs impossibly reversible without some complex explanation. Maybe if they had something other than a blood test and ultrasound. And like Mulder, I want to believe.
The bottom line is you're just not going to accept perfectly plausible explanations because for whatever (valid) reason, you just don't like the show. I'm never going to argue that someone should like a particular piece of art, but I can't say the reasons given for why some folks don't like Extant ring true for me.
I have my issues with the show as well, but they're more along the lines of falling short, not treating the characters (and the audience) like idiots -- which is what I felt while watching S1 of Under The Dome (I didn't watch S2). I'd give it somewhere around a B- to C (depends on how it plays out). Here's hoping its worst sin will remain "underwhelming" not "stupid".
#10
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
As I said, I'm still enjoying the show; I think I'm enjoying it more than other people are, but she's not a highlight for me but she certainly isn't hampering my enjoyment. I made no comment on her attractiveness, either.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
The bottom line is you're just not going to accept perfectly plausible explanations because for whatever (valid) reason, you just don't like the show. I'm never going to argue that someone should like a particular piece of art, but I can't say the reasons given for why some folks don't like Extant ring true for me.
I have my issues with the show as well, but they're more along the lines of falling short, not treating the characters (and the audience) like idiots -- which is what I felt while watching S1 of Under The Dome (I didn't watch S2). I'd give it somewhere around a B- to C (depends on how it plays out). Here's hoping its worst sin will remain "underwhelming" not "stupid".
Last edited by hdnmickey; 08-13-14 at 08:48 AM.
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 1,917
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
And yet, that's what the vast majority of people in real life do. This woman has spent her life in the pursuit of science and space exploration. I doubt she's given much thought to what to do if you have to suddenly leave your whole life behind and go on the run. They didn't present it as a smart option, they presented it as an option driven by panic. Smart people do dumb things all the time in real life, especially in a panic situation.
There are more in any show. But the stuff you've pointed out aren't things that are without any possible explanation. And the more you poke at minor explainable things that don't really matter to the overall story, the more you indicate one of two things...
A) You're not exactly enjoying it all that much, because most people simply don't spend the vast majority of their time and energy knocking things they enjoy
or
B) You just like complaining
So while I certainly don't get to speak for you, I do get to comment on my perception of your public comments. IMO, associating it with Under The Dome speaks volumes about your perception of the show.
As I've said, I certainly have no desire to change your (or anyone else's) opinion of the show. But I think it'd be a disservice to those who may be trying to decide whether to watch the show to leave these threads with a prevailing perception that this show is, "just as sucky as Under The Dome," filled with inexplicably stupid actions and events.
I can't say. I'll watch it as long as it entertains me, then I won't. Personally, I don't care if it keeps going. Based on what I've seen, I'd rather it be a one and done. It's not compelling, it's passable.
A) You're not exactly enjoying it all that much, because most people simply don't spend the vast majority of their time and energy knocking things they enjoy
or
B) You just like complaining
So while I certainly don't get to speak for you, I do get to comment on my perception of your public comments. IMO, associating it with Under The Dome speaks volumes about your perception of the show.
As I've said, I certainly have no desire to change your (or anyone else's) opinion of the show. But I think it'd be a disservice to those who may be trying to decide whether to watch the show to leave these threads with a prevailing perception that this show is, "just as sucky as Under The Dome," filled with inexplicably stupid actions and events.
I can't say. I'll watch it as long as it entertains me, then I won't. Personally, I don't care if it keeps going. Based on what I've seen, I'd rather it be a one and done. It's not compelling, it's passable.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
But I think it'd be a disservice to those who may be trying to decide whether to watch the show to leave these threads with a prevailing perception that this show is, "just as sucky as Under The Dome," filled with inexplicably stupid actions and events.
#14
Moderator
Re: Extant (S1E05) -- "What on Earth is Wrong?" -- 8/06/14
I binged watched all five eps over the last few days... and I'm a bit indifferent with this show. I'll still watch it for the acting and the tech... and Lou Gossett Jr.