DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/623982-order-1886-ps4-2-20-2015-a.html)

Deftones 02-17-15 04:28 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
article about the youtube stuff and internet reaction to the game length: http://kotaku.com/youtube-leak-derai...ive-1686385042

Maxflier 02-17-15 06:39 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
Target had it out but the register cockblocked the transaction. They can't sell it until the 20th. Although there were only a few copies left, so there is obviously a way around it.

dsa_shea 02-17-15 07:12 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by Maxflier (Post 12398378)
Target had it out but the register cockblocked the transaction. They can't sell it until the 20th. Although there were only a few copies left, so there is obviously a way around it.

You can have law but you can't have Order.........at least not yet.

starseed1981 02-18-15 08:59 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by Maxflier (Post 12398378)
Target had it out but the register cockblocked the transaction. They can't sell it until the 20th. Although there were only a few copies left, so there is obviously a way around it.

I hate when that happens. My local Super Target always has stuff in the case early and it's always a crapshoot whether or not they'll let you take it. First world problems.

slop101 02-18-15 10:08 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by Deftones (Post 12398280)
article about the youtube stuff and internet reaction to the game length: http://kotaku.com/youtube-leak-derai...ive-1686385042

Fuck 'em! If they're gonna embargo reviews until release date, then they deserve every non-contextualized early impression they get.

Decker 02-18-15 10:18 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
How about if they're going to embargo reviews until the day before release date?

chess 02-18-15 10:25 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
Lots of concern about the length of this game from people who don't have PS4s. :lol:

Spoiler:
Looks like a rental to me. :shrug:

RichC2 02-18-15 10:26 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
Konami should be happy as hell that YouTube wasn't around when MGS came out for the PSX :lol:

foxdvd 02-18-15 10:27 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

chess 02-18-15 10:28 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 12398883)
Fuck 'em! If they're gonna embargo reviews until release date, then they deserve every non-contextualized early impression they get.


Originally Posted by Decker (Post 12398902)
How about if they're going to embargo reviews until the day before release date?

Haven't release day (or day prior) embargoes become the rule and not the exception these days?

I don't like it either, and I'm not that hyped for the Order, but I'm also not sure why any particular game would get singled out for it.

starseed1981 02-18-15 10:53 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 12398883)
Fuck 'em! If they're gonna embargo reviews until release date, then they deserve every non-contextualized early impression they get.

Agree 100%. Especially in the pre-order driven culture that they've created.

RichC2 02-18-15 11:01 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
...I'm still really looking forward to playing this :shrug: Reminds me of those Quantic Dream games with some actual gameplay mixed in.

dsa_shea 02-18-15 11:09 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
I decided to go ahead and get my copy. I will just loan it out to a few friends after I am done.

K&AJones 02-18-15 11:19 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
My Grandmother use to say, "Good news moves like a Turtle and Bad news like a Rabbit".....

God forbid I had to weigh which way I had to go or think based on some or a couple of YouTubers whose main concern is getting attention, hits on their videos and one sided views on a game yet to be released so they can brag about being first. It's like watching CBS news and taking whatever they say and present as the final say and facts ignoring all the other outlets. I look at all sides and as many as I can.

And another thing...a lot of gamers today who didn't experience the first Nintendo, Sega Genesis, PS1, Xbox or any of the early consoles don't realize just how luck they are today. Yet I haven't seen this much moaning and crying in my life going back to the other consoles. We were thrilled to get about anything period. I'll never forget the moaning and bit@hing playing the Destiny Alpha from people about lack of maps, not able to upgrade, not able to do this or go here, no story.....blah, blah, blah

...we need to let it all play out and hear some more from other sources first people. If some have made up their mind base on Mr. Know-It-All YouTuber PlayMeThrough...so be it.

chess 02-18-15 11:27 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by dsa_shea (Post 12398983)
I decided to go ahead and get my copy. I will just loan it out to a few friends after I am done.

Hello friend!

Spoiler:
Seriously, you're right there on my list, so it's official.

dsa_shea 02-18-15 11:30 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
Yes, it is! We are friends!

chess 02-18-15 11:34 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by K&AJones (Post 12398992)
My Grandmother use to say, "Good news moves like a Turtle and Bad news like a Rabbit".....

God forbid I had to weigh which way I had to go or think based on some or a couple of YouTubers whose main concern is getting attention, hits on their videos and one sided views on a game yet to be released so they can brag about being first. It's like watching CBS news and taking whatever they say and present as the final say and facts ignoring all the other outlets. I look at all sides and as many as I can.

And another thing...a lot of gamers today who didn't experience the first Nintendo, Sega Genesis, PS1, Xbox or any of the early consoles don't realize just how luck they are today. Yet I haven't seen this much moaning and crying in my life going back to the other consoles. We were thrilled to get about anything period.

You tell em Buzz!

You know what else was short? Resident Evil 4, and Uncharted, and Last of Us, and Tomb Raider, and Portal. Those games did not suck. This one might, but it won't be because it's short.


I'll never forget the moaning and bit@hing playing the Destiny Alpha from people about lack of maps, not able to upgrade, not able to do this or go here, no story.....blah, blah, blah
I loved the Destiny alpha, but that all turned out to be entirely true, even though I was saying "wait for the full game" at the time. I was dead wrong, because the full game went absolutely nowhere. :shrug:

K&AJones 02-18-15 11:46 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 
Probably one of the best articles about not just this game but how games in general are starting to be looked at across the entire board. Well worth the read....

The Order 1886 Controversy And Why Game Length Doesn't Matter

http://www.ign.com/blogs/kralamoonar...86-controversy

I wasn't going to write a blog about this. In fact, I wanted to finish writing my blog about the "cinematic games debate", but something struck me while I was reading articles about The Order 1886. The CTO and founder of Ready at Dawn, had to blame himself for apparently not communicating the vision of The Order well enough.

And this where I think the criticism of games in general has gotten too far. Now we've gotten to the point where a developer is doubting himself and his team, when in fact, they've done a perfect job of portraying what kind of game they're making. All because of the constant barrage of clickbait articles and rumors from people who only hate them/their game. Even the lead game director has noticed it and commented on it.

In this blog, I argue it's time we start to change our perception of games (not just The Order) and treat them as art -this is the exact reason why games aren't seen as art- because gamers are not seeing them as art. Speaking to a fellow IGN user about the games controversial game length, he stated that "It's one of many reasons games aren't taken seriously as art. Its fans don't treat them as art." And that statement in my opinion couldn't be anymore truer.

"I mean let me set something straight: if you judge a game based on how long it takes someone on YouTube, someone with a vested interest in getting it done as fast possible, you're doing yourself a disservice and it's completely pointless.

Honestly, I facepalm whenever someone claims to watch an entire game on YouTube from start to finish to prove an ideological point. My point? Watching and playing are two completely different things. Gaming as a medium, is best experienced, when your PLAYING it."

slop101 02-18-15 11:46 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by chess (Post 12399017)
You know what else was short? Resident Evil 4, and Uncharted, and Last of Us, and Tomb Raider, and Portal. Those games did not suck. This one might, but it won't be because it's short.

Put down the crack pipe. Except for Portal, all those games were 2x to 3x times longer than Order and Portal was priced appropriately. Whatever point you were tying to make, you made the opposite.

fumanstan 02-18-15 11:50 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 12398883)
Fuck 'em! If they're gonna embargo reviews until release date, then they deserve every non-contextualized early impression they get.

Agree completely. Especially if it's just a regular user that happened to get their hands on the game.


Originally Posted by chess (Post 12398909)
Lots of concern about the length of this game from people who don't have PS4s. :lol:

Can we cut this bullshit? This isn't GAF. Heaven forbid people be interested in this game as a reason to buy a PS4, huh? :shrug: That's why the the earlier assumption that there are folks who would want Bloodborne to do poorly here on this forum is fucking stupid. The better the catalog of PS4 games, the more games i'll be excited to play when I buy one.

Brack 02-18-15 11:58 AM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by fumanstan (Post 12399045)
Heaven forbid people be interested in this game as a reason to buy a PS4, huh? :shrug:

I bought a PS4 partly because of inFamous:Second Son. I ended up finding it repetitive, boring with annoying characters, and traded the game in after 3 weeks. That game had great reviews. Luckily PS+ and a couple of other titles healed that burn. I still don't know about The Order. I'll probably wait until it's around $30 maybe.

chess 02-18-15 12:10 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 12399039)
Put down the crack pipe. Except for Portal, all those games were 2x to 3x times longer than Order and Portal was priced appropriately. Whatever point you were tying to make, you made the opposite.

I'm not sure, nor do I care how long the Order is, and I'd imagine it will vary depending on how it's played.

I finished most of those games in one sitting. Tomb Raider seemed especially short (and especially awesome), and RE4 is one of my favorite games of all time, and there's no way it's more than 10 hours long. Anyway, the point was, I don't think it matters, and neither do your 2x/3x.

I've never been high on the game, but I think this is a patently stupid and unfair point to make against it.

[hits crack pipe]

slop101 02-18-15 12:10 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by chess (Post 12398909)
Lots of concern about the length of this game from people who don't have PS4s. :lol:

This is bullshit and you know it. I have a PS4 and no Xb1, and I was really looking forward to this game, now, not so much, maybe a rental, not so much due to the length, but what seems to be the rudimentary mechanics of the gameplay.

slop101 02-18-15 12:12 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by chess (Post 12399076)
I finished most of those games in one sitting.

Doesn't matter, you're still wrong. If a game have more than one idea, it can stand to be 10+ hours without feeling long or getting old. A shorter game mostly means it doesn't have enough ideas to go any longer.

chess 02-18-15 12:14 PM

Re: The Order: 1886 - PS4 (2/20/2015)
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 12399077)
This is bullshit and you know it. I have a PS4 and no Xb1, and I was really looking forward to this game, now, not so much, maybe a rental, not so much due to the length, but what seems to be the rudimentary mechanics of the gameplay.

Odd. Did I mention you or anyone else here?

The internet is REALLY concerned about the length of this game, like no other game I've ever seen.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:39 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.