DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/577071-official-rock-band-thread-music-game-evolution.html)

chuckd21 10-24-10 05:46 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10449900)
You can have as many patches as you want, but past the first two would cost the publisher money. Unless that publisher is Microsoft of course. :)

Oh okay, gotcha.

chuckd21 10-24-10 06:22 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
Okay so I guess what I'm looking for from you folks who lucked out and got the game early is... is it the greatest thing ever? Is it the best RB game yet? We're all pretty hardcore RB fans here. Does it do everything you want it to?

flashburn 10-24-10 06:48 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
Pretty much. Although there are some things it could do better. For one, character creation still isn't the best it could be, the tattoo/logo editor is really limiting. I wish for drums that it had real high-hat functionality. There's also the fact that around 90% of the RBN songs don't have pro drums support, but aren't distinguished as such. Luckily going forward this shouldn't be a problem with new RBN songs. It'd also be nice if they could render all five characters at once for the songs where it applies.

Other then that, its pretty great. The overshell and music library are really great. I like being able to do an entire playlist and then skip songs, or continue playing a given song if I fail it.

I'd say there is still room for improvement, but I really don't expect to see another iteration until the next-gen consoles come out in (probably) 2013.

One other thing I would like would be a very in depth career mode. RB and RB2 tried it, but they were pretty cosmetic and still nothing more than just playing sets of songs. It'd be cool if you could truly manage your bands career, from plotting out a tour, to recording albums and tracking sales. Choosing which songs you want to be singles, etc. I think that could be pretty fun.

pinata242 10-24-10 07:42 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10449911)
Jesus Christ, read much?


Also with Twisted Pixel, do you know if there has indeed been "nothing"? Or just the fact that the patch hasn't been released? Maybe it failed certification and needed to be resubmitted?

Jesus Christ, read much? ;) Yes I know it hasnt been released because I check every day and there hasn't been a single update. Also all the forums that talk about such things corroborate this. I did say that there might have been a problem with "that" patch. All I know is they said they delivered the fix.

Let's not act like MS has been on the ball with every facet of updates, especially with XBLA achievements (Snoopy Flying Ace, Things on Wheels come to mind instantly).

Also you can most likely fix your issue by trying on non-Pro and not waiting for a patch unlike the rest of us.

chuckd21 10-24-10 07:47 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
You both realize that zombie Jesus cannot read much anymore, as he's dead. Right?

flashburn 10-24-10 07:49 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 10450193)
You both realize that zombie Jesus cannot read much anymore, as he's dead. Right?

Oh, well I figured that Pinata could read to him anyway. It would help both of them out.

pinata242 10-24-10 07:49 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
He tweets a lot. @Jesus_M_Christ #JesusAfterDark

pinata242 10-24-10 07:50 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10450195)
Oh, well I figured that Pinata could read to him anyway. It would help both of them out.

:lol: I'm in stitches over here! rotfl

pinata242 10-24-10 07:58 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
:toast:

Mad Dawg 10-24-10 08:02 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 10450022)
Okay so I guess what I'm looking for from you folks who lucked out and got the game early is... is it the greatest thing ever? Is it the best RB game yet? We're all pretty hardcore RB fans here. Does it do everything you want it to?

Yes, best RB ever. If you can get over the fact that RB2 has been with us for 2 years and 3 is different enough to cause a little culture shock, I think you'll agree.

My only big complaint/concern right now is the animation bug mentioned earlier that causes the need to restart the XBox. It happens once every 4 or 5 times that animation pops up, and it's a real annoyance for me. I hope it gets patched soon.

Otherwise, I think it's almost perfect.

Supermallet 10-24-10 08:20 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10450073)

One other thing I would like would be a very in depth career mode. RB and RB2 tried it, but they were pretty cosmetic and still nothing more than just playing sets of songs. It'd be cool if you could truly manage your bands career, from plotting out a tour, to recording albums and tracking sales. Choosing which songs you want to be singles, etc. I think that could be pretty fun.

That really would be fantastic. Be able to design album cover art, maybe you can have rivalries with other bands, etc.

Spiderbite 10-24-10 08:27 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
Is the build on the keyboard as solid as it looks? They already had those out at my local BB and they looked really good. Mine is on order from Amazon so I won't be seeing it for several days unfortunately.

Mad Dawg 10-24-10 08:50 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
I haven't played around with a real keyboard in years, but yes, it feels very sturdy and solid and I'm guessing it compares favorably with a real one.

flashburn 10-24-10 09:02 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by Suprmallet (Post 10450260)
That really would be fantastic. Be able to design album cover art, maybe you can have rivalries with other bands, etc.

Yeah, I'm not really sure how any of it would work, but I think there is something to the whole "career" mode they could explore more in depth. I'd love to be able to basically start a band and then be able to try to shape how it grows. Would they become a huge arena filling band, or would they break up after only two albums? The only odd thing would be the fact that you are still just doing covers of songs, but I still think it could work.

jdpatri 10-24-10 09:40 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by brianluvdvd (Post 10450274)
Is the build on the keyboard as solid as it looks? They already had those out at my local BB and they looked really good. Mine is on order from Amazon so I won't be seeing it for several days unfortunately.

As I mentioned, the build is surprisingly sturdy. I don't know how it really plays but it sounds brilliant in my head.

jdpatri 10-24-10 09:41 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10450351)
Yeah, I'm not really sure how any of it would work, but I think there is something to the whole "career" mode they could explore more in depth. I'd love to be able to basically start a band and then be able to try to shape how it grows. Would they become a huge arena filling band, or would they break up after only two albums? The only odd thing would be the fact that you are still just doing covers of songs, but I still think it could work.

Can we get Sid Meier in on this for a week?

chuckd21 10-24-10 09:51 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
I think a path to become the world's greatest and most prolific cover band would be rather fun.

pinata242 10-24-10 10:19 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by chuckd21 (Post 10450436)
I think a path to become the world's greatest and most prolific cover band would be rather fun.

I know the final boss:

Spoiler:
<object width="640" height="505"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/cIRiZsDObrU?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US&amp;hd=1"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/cIRiZsDObrU?fs=1&amp;hl=en_US&amp;hd=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="640" height="505"></embed></object>

pinata242 10-24-10 10:20 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10450351)
Yeah, I'm not really sure how any of it would work, but I think there is something to the whole "career" mode they could explore more in depth. I'd love to be able to basically start a band and then be able to try to shape how it grows. Would they become a huge arena filling band, or would they break up after only two albums? The only odd thing would be the fact that you are still just doing covers of songs, but I still think it could work.

Lego Rock Band kind of dabbled in this.

MJG87 10-24-10 11:54 PM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10450504)
Lego Rock Band kind of dabbled in this.

Exactly, I thought RB3 would include these well received features.

discostu1337 10-25-10 02:55 AM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by flashburn (Post 10449287)
Does anyone know what the trick is for getting the "Play 3 80's Metal songs" achievement? I've beat 4 or 5 from the disc, and then another 5 that are DLC but it still hasn't unlocked. I'm wondering if this is yet another busted achievement that I can't do on pro drums, however the other ones were all drum specific.

Dunno if this was answered, but it must be done on guitar. It's listed under one of the guitar challenges in Career, even though the description does not specify.

flashburn 10-25-10 04:46 AM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by discostu1337 (Post 10450748)
Dunno if this was answered, but it must be done on guitar. It's listed under one of the guitar challenges in Career, even though the description does not specify.

Lame! Thanks stu. I won't go out of my way to get it for now.

flashburn 10-25-10 04:47 AM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 10450504)
Lego Rock Band kind of dabbled in this.

You're right, I forgot about Lego Rock Band. They did build on career mode a bit, but it was still only about 5-10% of what I'd like to see from a real career mode.

SuperBatMan 10-25-10 07:50 AM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
Thanks to Amazon not having the pro cymbals in stock until Sunday(10/31 and a delivery date of next Wed.), I cancelled from there and ordered from NewEgg, who already had them in stock, and should be delivered Wednesday.

Not sure why Amazon is having them in stock so late, but they lost a sale.

Drexl 10-25-10 08:10 AM

Re: The Official Rock Band Thread of Music Game Evolution
 
They probably don't want designing album covers because of the inevitable obscenities that would get uploaded.

I know I'd like to edit the cover art used for songs to get rid of all the damn greatest hits covers.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:31 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.