DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/565943-ultimate-battle-free-pinball-thread.html)

chuckd21 02-07-13 12:53 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11569206)
Um thanks. I'll repeat what I've said many times here : I think this is a shitty business model. If Zen can somehow work completely under the radar and produce ten, TEN Star Wars tables without anyone even knowing about it, I'm pretty sure Far Sight could have made a Twilight Zone emulation without a Kickstarter project behind it. Their bullshit excuse, that "We don't want to pass on these licensing costs to the consumer because it wouldn't make the tables commercially viable" doesn't hold water when they charge double for the table anyway. If they hadn't completely bungled the launch of the table -- I literally had to search for it in the PSN store; if they had made a big deal out of the launch of this impressive table the way Zen would have, I'm sure they would have made their money back just fine. Ditto for TNG table which will be released next month, again I assume, with little to no fanfare.
[/rant]

To believe in your theory means that you have to believe that Farsight is flatout lying to their most rabid fanbase and therefore exploiting them. So why would you ever give them any of your money for their products if you hate this process so?

I don't think there's a remote chance in hell that licensing Star Wars property and licensing ancient tech and countless likeness rights are in any way similar.

To follow that logic... a tiny company like Zen was able to license Star Wars but MGM can't renegotiate simple music rights on countless DVD releases? Come on!

Rights are not the same across the board. Companies aren't all on equal financial footing from the start.

Decker 02-07-13 02:32 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Okay, I get that. It's not the same thing, and licensing can be pricy.

I wouldn't call them "liars" exactly, but I think it's a little disingenuous to put out a Kickstarter video
<iframe width="853" height="480" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/LruHUjxaXG8" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
where he says that it wouldn't be commercially viable to pass those licensing fees onto the consumer, then once they raise enough Kickstarter money to cover all the licensing fees, still charge (essentially) twice as much as any of their other tables. I don't mind paying $5 for the table at all, but something about that does strike me as fishy.

I don't support the process of using Kickstarter to launch their tables (and didn't really care enough about either of the tables to be upset if they never got made), so I didn't contribute. I do mostly enjoy the final results that Far Sight puts out so I buy every DLC pack when it comes out on PSN without waiting for a sale or even doing the demo most of the time. I support their preserving the tables and show my support by buying every one. That's the sort of publisher/consumer relationship I can get behind.

Anyway, I guess I'm looking at things through the prism of a small business owner. We take financial risks with every undertaking; there's no guaranty of profit but if we feel there's a good potential of success we roll the dice and plunge on in. I personally don't like the Kickstarter model because it basically eliminates risk for the company and doesn't incentive them to make an outstanding product since they're already in the profit before the table is even available. Having said that, the table (at least on the PS3) is outstanding and I'm very happy with the outcome.

So thank you to the Kickstarters who made this table available. It's superb. I hope the table is a huge DLC success and that Far Sight will see the success as a new business opportunity to bring over more licensed tables without having to organize a fund raiser for every one. We shall see.

pinata242 02-07-13 02:45 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
There's something to be said about doing whatever you can to get a big time "get" as soon as possible. Them going after those tables, which are near the top of whatever the pinball ranking list is, are huge. Not to mention tapping into the massive ST fanbase. Truth be told, I and others tried desperately to get it noticed by that community as a whole to get ST:TNG funded alongside TTZ table. Mostly selfishly as it would have double the value of my original pledge. But that's water under the bridge.

I wonder if they found out about Zen's deal with Lucas through the grapevine or even directly by going to Lucas for licensing of real world tables and decided they needed to act quick to pre-empt that launch with their own competitors? Where better to go than ST?

Jcheckel 02-07-13 03:04 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
I'm curious whether there will be more premium tables after Star Trek, that may not have a kickstarter but get the premium $5 pricing for the table just based on the complexity of the tables. I've felt like I've been paying $5 per table all along since all the packs have had a repeat from the Williams collection. The next two non Star Trek releases have their repeat tables from the Gottlieb collection which I have way less time on.

Play a little on Twilight Zone, it's probably been about 15 years since I played the real thing. I still hate those bumpers on the left, the ball goes down the left outlane from in there so much, just like the real thing. I can't think of another table that punished you that badly for hitting a successful skillshot. The left outlane is just pure evil.

Decker 02-07-13 03:13 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 11569493)
There's something to be said about doing whatever you can to get a big time "get" as soon as possible. Them going after those tables, which are near the top of whatever the pinball ranking list is, are huge. Not to mention tapping into the massive ST fanbase. Truth be told, I and others tried desperately to get it noticed by that community as a whole to get ST:TNG funded alongside TTZ table. Mostly selfishly as it would have double the value of my original pledge. But that's water under the bridge.

I wonder if they found out about Zen's deal with Lucas through the grapevine or even directly by going to Lucas for licensing of real world tables and decided they needed to act quick to pre-empt that launch with their own competitors? Where better to go than ST?

That's a thought. I think they could do more with their marketing to drum up support and sales. They've blundered so badly on XBLA that I can't imagine they have much of a following on that format at all. They've been much better with PS3, but still when they come out with a table pack, it's months after it came out for the iPad and buried deep in the weekly Drop. If they put out tables on multiple formats at once, they would probably get more attention. And as I pointed out two days ago, by either incompetence or unfortunate timing, their announcement on the Playstation Blog about the release of Twilight Zone came hours after the huge Zen Star Wars reveal, making it feel like a complete afterthought. I like the product but their marketing sucks. Just look on Facebook and compare the Pinball Arcade page with their stream of random announcements about different tables and packs to the Zen Studios page with its slick appearance and clear focus on their upcoming Star Wars tables-- the difference is striking.

flashburn 02-07-13 04:20 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Jcheckel (Post 11569528)
I'm curious whether there will be more premium tables after Star Trek, that may not have a kickstarter but get the premium $5 pricing for the table just based on the complexity of the tables. I've felt like I've been paying $5 per table all along since all the packs have had a repeat from the Williams collection. The next two non Star Trek releases have their repeat tables from the Gottlieb collection which I have way less time on.

Play a little on Twilight Zone, it's probably been about 15 years since I played the real thing. I still hate those bumpers on the left, the ball goes down the left outlane from in there so much, just like the real thing. I can't think of another table that punished you that badly for hitting a successful skillshot. The left outlane is just pure evil.

Not sure if there will be non-Kickstarter premium tables, but they have said they plan on doing a Kickstarter for T2 over the summer. They might of also mentioned The Addams Family, but I don't remember.

They've said that because of the licensing fees they would of had to charge $10 a table if it wasn't for Kickstarting them.

Decker 02-07-13 04:47 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
They may have said that but I have a hard time believing that either Terminator or Addams Family would cost four times as much to license as all the Universal Monsters on the Monster Bash table. It might in fact be true, but I sort of doubt it. It's just too an easy excuse to go back to the well for more fundraising.

Besides, I think I read that they couldn't have the T2 table on Pinball Arcade because it wouldn't be rated E and that's what the main game is rated.

flashburn 02-07-13 06:13 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11569698)
They may have said that but I have a hard time believing that either Terminator or Addams Family would cost four times as much to license as all the Universal Monsters on the Monster Bash table. It might in fact be true, but I sort of doubt it. It's just too an easy excuse to go back to the well for more fundraising.

Besides, I think I read that they couldn't have the T2 table on Pinball Arcade because it wouldn't be rated E and that's what the main game is rated.

What is there in T2 that would cause it not to be rated E? I owned the machine for a few months and I can't think of anything, outside of the unofficial "profanity roms" that would justify a higher rating.

Decker 02-07-13 06:17 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Perhaps just the cyborg skulls and pistol launcher are enough to warrant an https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/i...44F3-1MOKruSqA rating?

It was a while ago and I don't remember where I read it.

flashburn 02-07-13 06:23 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
I dunno, they said in some podcast interview a month or two ago (check a few pages back, I posted cliffnotes), that they will be doing T2 next. It sounded definite. I don't see how a shotgun launcher is any worse than the gun launcher in STTNG.

UncleGramps 02-07-13 06:36 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
I haven't been following this at all, but I did participate in the Far Sight Kickstarter thing. Did they ever deliver the 360 table or is that still in limbo?

pinata242 02-07-13 06:37 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Limbo.

flashburn 02-07-13 06:44 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by UncleGramps (Post 11569806)
I haven't been following this at all, but I did participate in the Far Sight Kickstarter thing. Did they ever deliver the 360 table or is that still in limbo?

I think they said next month we should see it get resolved and all the tables start to come out.

neilo13 02-08-13 07:55 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Got my TZ code about 24 hours after the release, so I am very happy now. Table plays just like the real thing, and for all the times i've played it, I never noticed that there is a skill shot! The custom balls are a neat bonus, but i don't think i'd pay extra for them if i hadn't been all about funding this. The same goes for the Pro mode, it's neat to mess around with, but really doesn't do much for me. Speaking of funding this, where can I view the backers list that I'm supposed to be on?

As for the lack of promotion on the PS Store, I never really noticed this as the game itself prompts for an update and shows newly available tables within the game menu. I guess advertising this on store would bring in new customers, but for folks already with the game, you can easily see what you haven't yet purchased.

Spiderbite 02-08-13 08:25 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
I wish the Xbox 360 would get on fucking board with this game, dammit.

Decker 02-08-13 09:46 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by neilo13 (Post 11570336)
Got my TZ code about 24 hours after the release, so I am very happy now. Table plays just like the real thing, and for all the times i've played it, I never noticed that there is a skill shot! The custom balls are a neat bonus, but i don't think i'd pay extra for them if i hadn't been all about funding this. The same goes for the Pro mode, it's neat to mess around with, but really doesn't do much for me. Speaking of funding this, where can I view the backers list that I'm supposed to be on?

As for the lack of promotion on the PS Store, I never really noticed this as the game itself prompts for an update and shows newly available tables within the game menu. I guess advertising this on store would bring in new customers, but for folks already with the game, you can easily see what you haven't yet purchased.

It's actually featured quite prominetly on the first page of Add-Ons in the PSN Store. I stand corrected, but like I said there should have been some lead-in announcement rather than just saying "It's available now".

A couple of questions about the table : I don't really see that much that is actually based on the TV show plots or anything. It seems to be more based on the opening credits. Am I wrong there? Do they reference famous episode storylines? It has been decades since I saw the show.

Also I'm a little curious why were the licensing fees so high for this game. I get Star Trek TNG, but here you've only got 1) Twilight Zone series, 2) Twilight Zone theme, 3) Rod Sterling likeness and audio clip, 4) Rockwell Song. I would think that's it (besides the table license that they already had). Sure that's a few, but needing $110K? It just seems to me it would have been harder and more expensive to license Monster Bash than that.

Did they give you Kickstarter a breakdown of the licensing fees?

pinata242 02-08-13 11:08 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
When you say $110K, you're intentionally adding the cost for TZ and ST:TNG, even though you're actively only talking about TZ? You know that's misleading, right?

On top of that, they did honor their commitment to use the overage of TZ's initial $55,000 goal to lower the initial ST:TNG goal to only $45,000 additional.

Decker 02-08-13 11:35 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Not intentional. I had remembered the $110K figure and thought that was the goal. If it were half that cost, it makes more sense. I should have checked the Kickstarter page. I stand corrected. Sorry.

pinata242 02-08-13 11:39 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Oh, ok. Sorry, I thought you were playing games :) Yeah, it was 55k for each, but the 2nd was lowered because the 1st went a little over.

Music 02-08-13 03:28 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Decker don't play that homey!

Decker 02-08-13 04:00 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Damn straight.

Decker 02-09-13 06:57 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by UncleGramps (Post 11569806)
I haven't been following this at all, but I did participate in the Far Sight Kickstarter thing. Did they ever deliver the 360 table or is that still in limbo?

Hidden at the bottom of a recent Pinball Arcade Facebook post:


Next week, we plan to be post the latest news for 360 players. We understand your frustration. Unfortunately, the complicated process of transferring the publishing rights when a bankruptcy is involved prevents us from announcing locked in Table Pack release dates at this time. We will update you with the latest information that we have.

The Dr. Dude and Firepower screenshots just posted are from the 360 version.
And if there's any question as to what I meant about Pinball Arcade not marketing well, I suggest checking out their official website http://www.pinballarcade.com where the Latest News was last updated Jan 18th. -ohbfrank-

flashburn 02-09-13 10:14 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Dr. Dude, such an odd, random choice.

Decker 02-09-13 11:48 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
And more than a bit dated. That's still four or more releases away on PS3 though. God knows how many on the 360.

flashburn 02-10-13 06:04 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11572877)
And more than a bit dated. That's still four or more releases away on PS3 though. God knows how many on the 360.

Dated? It's pinball, pretty much every release is retro on some level. Dr. Dude is from 1990, Firepower is 1980. I just found it an odd choice since it isn't a very popular title.

Decker 02-10-13 10:16 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Not dated in the sense that it's an old pinball table, but rather dated in the sense that the table spoofs Wayne & Garth, Bill & Ted sort of dynamics and that is something that has fallen way far out of favor. Their dialog is super-annoying, at least based on the clips they've shown. It's different than Tales of Arabian Nights or Bride of Pinbot. I just thought it was a weird choice.

Here's the trailer:
<iframe width="853" height="480" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/wDnoUGE2oWY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Decker 02-10-13 11:14 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Also just noticed that Pinball Arcade is trying to get on Steam via Greenlight. I have no idea why it isn't already on Steam; it's a finished, high-quality product that's already a well-known quantity on numerous platforms. It almost seems beneath them to be competing with amateur indie games and the like. Anyway, I voted for it even though I'm unlikely to re-buy everything on another platform. I also saw that the Pro Pinball game that didn't get Kickstarted was also there. Don't know where they are in development, but it's certainly not at the same level as Pinball Arcade. I don't know how that would work; I though games had to be finished before they get Greenlighted.

flashburn 02-10-13 11:19 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11573182)
Also just noticed that Pinball Arcade is trying to get on Steam via Greenlight. I have no idea why it isn't already on Steam; it's a finished, high-quality product that's already a well-known quantity on numerous platforms. It almost seems beneath them to be competing with amateur indie games and the like. Anyway, I voted for it even though I'm unlikely to re-buy everything on another platform. I also saw that the Pro Pinball game that didn't get Kickstarted was also there. Don't know where they are in development, but it's certainly not at the same level as Pinball Arcade. I don't know how that would work; I though games had to be finished before they get Greenlighted.

For whatever reason Valve has shit on Pinball for a while now, which makes no sense, since they have pin's in their offices! They told Farsight that it isn't popular enough and won't sell. So that is why they went the Greenlight route, and have been trying to for like 4+ months. At this point, I doubt TPA will be on Steam at any point in the near future. I don't get why Valve gives a fuck, they have tons of shit for sale that is well... shit, so what's the problem?

Decker 02-10-13 01:01 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
That's mind-boggling. They don't think TPA, which has sold very well on iOS, won't sell at least as well as some of the dreck they bundle into Indie bundles on a routine basis? That's so counter-intuitive.

chuckd21 02-11-13 10:36 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11569698)
They may have said that but I have a hard time believing that either Terminator or Addams Family would cost four times as much to license as all the Universal Monsters on the Monster Bash table. It might in fact be true, but I sort of doubt it. It's just too an easy excuse to go back to the well for more fundraising.

Universal is quite loose with the licensing for the "monsters". Terminator will definitely cost way more than that license did.

Decker 02-12-13 10:04 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Bought table pack 7 tonight. Tried it just for a few minutes. Elvira Scared Stiff is a cool table. Lots of stuff to do. Ranked #14 on the Internet Pinball Database. I'm going to enjoy it a lot more than the last Elvira table which I wasn't into at all. The other table is old. Big Shot is very simple, but it's a nice change of pace to have an EM table in the collection. Won't play it much, but it's cool to have at least one from the "Old Days".

My patient with the table collection invited me to his house to check his collection out. Really excited to play a real TZ table. Apparently his pride & joy is a Big Bang Bar table that is very rare. It was initially a prototype made by Capcom before they abandoned the idea after making 14 of them. In 2006 Gene Cunningham made a run of 181 tables. So I guess it's super-rare. Looking forward to trying it out. He's also having me over for the unveiling of Wizard of Oz table next month. That table looks amazing. I read a great article about it and the future of pinball in Slate.

Jcheckel 02-12-13 10:37 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
I grabbed the new pack too and ended up playing quite a bit of Big Shot. The last few weeks I've been playing quite a bit of PA on the PS3 and its gotten a lot better with the lighting effects since it first came out.

Just got done playing Scared Stiff a few times. I like it a lot, but it's definitely the easiest table on PA. So many free balls, the one from points is only at 6 million, and hitting the right ramp I think it's 8 times lights the extra ball. That's 8 times on the game, not in a row or even on one ball.

Spiderbite 02-13-13 06:59 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by brianluvdvd (Post 11570372)
I wish the Xbox 360 would get on fucking board with this game, dammit.

I'll quote myself again for any Microsoft assholes who happen to be reading this thread. Fuckers.

flashburn 02-13-13 07:26 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by brianluvdvd (Post 11577166)
I'll quote myself again for any Microsoft assholes who happen to be reading this thread. Fuckers.

... Blame their old publisher going bankrupt.

flashburn 02-13-13 07:29 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 11576960)
Bought table pack 7 tonight. Tried it just for a few minutes. Elvira Scared Stiff is a cool table. Lots of stuff to do. Ranked #14 on the Internet Pinball Database. I'm going to enjoy it a lot more than the last Elvira table which I wasn't into at all. The other table is old. Big Shot is very simple, but it's a nice change of pace to have an EM table in the collection. Won't play it much, but it's cool to have at least one from the "Old Days".

My patient with the table collection invited me to his house to check his collection out. Really excited to play a real TZ table. Apparently his pride & joy is a Big Bang Bar table that is very rare. It was initially a prototype made by Capcom before they abandoned the idea after making 14 of them. In 2006 Gene Cunningham made a run of 181 tables. So I guess it's super-rare. Looking forward to trying it out. He's also having me over for the unveiling of Wizard of Oz table next month. That table looks amazing. I read a great article about it and the future of pinball in Slate.

Yeah, an original Big Bang Bar is extremely rare, like you said only 14 of them were made. Gene is actually selling the original Serial #1 for only... $50,000!

Decker 02-13-13 09:58 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
Honestly, I don't know if he has an original or a reproduction. I'll let you know. I might stop over this afternoon. $50K. Wow,

pinata242 02-13-13 10:07 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
<iframe width="640" height="360" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/rOajo2uBvbE" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

pinata242 02-13-13 10:10 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
I was hoping for fewer "sound-alike" audio clips, but they aren't bad. Probably less noticeable in the heat of a game with all the other noises anyway.

Decker 02-13-13 10:18 AM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
They blow the pants off the Avengers' sound-alikes.

Here's a hands-on preview of the Star Wars table pack : link

flashburn 02-13-13 07:59 PM

Re: The Ultimate Battle Free Pinball Thread
 
So, all those pin's at Valve... say goodbye. Apparently they are all owned by Jeri Ellsworth and she was just fired/laid off this week:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BC8-zQHCcAA3oUy.jpg:large

Further proof that Valve hates pinball!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:56 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.