DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/558224-xbla-thread-part-400-pinatas-got-brown-nose.html)

maingon 08-26-09 02:45 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I wish I had one of the new 3D capable tvs, so I just tried it out using the Blue/Yellow classes from Monsters vs Alens Super Bowl special and there were some good depth mainly with the leaves blowing and some of the grass in the foreground.

superfro 08-26-09 03:00 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Schloob1 (Post 9670504)
Can you elaborate further as your post is confusing. I personally do not see a problem if these games would become the benchmark of what to expect from a $15 game? or did I misunderstand your post superfro?

Because if this is what we would begin to expect of a $15 game then the other games coming out would not sell at that pricepoint unless they were of the same caliber and would in theory be priced for less than. I would at least hope so, and if not the same caliber but priced the same not sell well and then eventually be marked down sooner.

Your second paragraph is exactly my point. IMO Shadow Complex should've been a $25-$30 game. I know it's crazy talk to suggest such a thing, but I think coupled with the recent concern over increasing pricing in downloadable games, that it's actually setting a really tough benchmark for the rest of the field. In actuality, as pinata mentioned above, Shadow Complex should be looked at as a really good deal. Unfortunately what I worry will happen is you'll now have $15 games come out and people will say "How is that the same price as SC?!"

Now should anyone at Chair Entertainment or anyone involved with Shadow Complex be worried about the above? Probably not at all. If they made a game like they did, are able to sell it for $15 and turn a profit, then good for them. It's certainly a call to arms for the other downloadable game makers out there as to what is possible at what price points. (As L&O has mentioned in multiple places here as well.) But even on that point I wonder....would MS/Epic take a loss up front to make money on volume and/or positive press? That's a whole other can of worms that I don't even want to think about. :lol:

Liver&Onions 08-26-09 03:05 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I'm not sure i've said this yet, but shadow complex is a bar raising game.

Decker 08-26-09 03:39 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Liver&Onions (Post 9670597)
I'm not sure i've said this yet, but shadow complex is a bar raising game.

:lol: You might be on to something there.

If people expect all XBLA games priced at 1200 points to be anywhere as good as Shadow Complex or Battlefield 1943, then they're foolish or insane. It's a little denigrating to even call Shadow Complex an XBLA game - like calling The Sopranos a TV Drama, it's an accurate description that doesn't do the subject justice.

But having said that, I've always felt there should be something special about a 1200 point game. I thought that for that premium price point there should really be a unique selling point or extraordinary content to justify it. Death Tank an R-Type seemed to be priced capriciously and if they didn't sell well, it moved the median price down a little bit since. We saw both Madballs and TMNT Reshelled get repriced, and rightly so. So if Shadow Complex achieves more representative pricing as a result, I'm all for it. (But I still think they left a lot of money on the table; if any game could justify a 1600 point price tag, that's it).

fumanstan 08-26-09 03:51 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I didn't get to spend much time with Shadow Complex yet, maybe only an hour of casual play and getting used to the mechanics, but I don't see it being considerably more worthy of the 1200 point pricing then most of the others out there like Castle Crashers or Braid. It's probably different for you hardcore Metroid/Castlevania guys, but I dunno... maybe it's just me :shrug:

superfro 08-26-09 03:52 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 9670686)
(But I still think they left a lot of money on the table; if any game could justify a 1600 point price tag, that's it).

And that may be becoming the most interesting point the more I think of all this. How did they make the game and decide on $15. The conspiracy theorist in me wants to have a field day with the topic, but it would all be speculation since I don't have anything concrete to back any of it up. The Epic/MS involvement just makes me suspicious.

I've been working with Chair in regards to an interview for a few weeks now. Hopefully it'll happen cause I'd love to ask how they were able to do the game like they did and put it out there for $15.

Decker 08-26-09 04:08 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by fumanstan (Post 9670709)
I didn't get to spend much time with Shadow Complex yet, maybe only an hour of casual play and getting used to the mechanics, but I don't see it being considerably more worthy of the 1200 point pricing then most of the others out there like Castle Crashers or Braid. It's probably different for you hardcore Metroid/Castlevania guys, but I dunno... maybe it's just me :shrug:

Castle Crashers is a fun, high quality game, but it's pretty repetitive and still feels like a downloadable game (albeit an excellent one), Braid is beautiful and very clever, but it is pretty short with absolutely no re-playability. It's a special game and certainly worth the $15 price. Still, neither game has the quality of design, graphics and gameplay of Shadow Complex, which has highly detailed and realistic HD graphics, full cut scenes and quality voice acting. It has nearly endless re-playability and absolutely feels like it could be a $60 retail game -- honestly the difference between it and Uncharted (a short but full priced game I absolutely loved) are minimal, IMO. Nothing else in the Arcade feels even remotely that way to me.

fumanstan 08-26-09 04:32 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 9670743)
Castle Crashers is a fun, high quality game, but it's pretty repetitive and still feels like a downloadable game (albeit an excellent one), Braid is beautiful and very clever, but it is pretty short with absolutely no re-playability. It's a special game and certainly worth the $15 price. Still, neither game has the quality of design, graphics and gameplay of Shadow Complex, which has highly detailed and realistic HD graphics, full cut scenes and quality voice acting. It has nearly endless re-playability and absolutely feels like it could be a $60 retail game -- honestly the difference between it and Uncharted (a short but full priced game I absolutely loved) are minimal, IMO. Nothing else in the Arcade feels even remotely that way to me.

But again, depends if you're really into the Metroid type of game play that determines the re-playability of the game, isn't it? Not everyone is hunting for 100% completion and all the achievements like the completionists online.

These are just my first impressions since I haven't gotten far enough into the game, but so far Shadow Complex feels as much a downloadable game as the other high quality games out there to me. Great at $15, or even $20, but I know I wouldn't pay $60 for the release.

Michael Corvin 08-26-09 07:43 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
There's no way Shadow Complex is a $30 game. $20 tops. I think everyone's just riding that hype train right now since it's new.

pinata242 08-26-09 08:51 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I've played through it 3 (well, 2.5) times already. The price is right, $20 would have been fine too.

It is short, even going for 100%. Once you hit level 20 and the whole map is available to you with items from the beginning, there's no reason not to get 100%. Except for those 2 or 3 items that are hidden by other map deficiencies :mad:

pinata242 08-26-09 11:12 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
Serious Sam HD Trailer is full of :wtf: :lol:

<object classId="clsid:d27CDB6E-AE6D-11cf-96B8-444553540000" width="480" height="418" id="VideoPlayerLg41010"><param name="movie" value="http://g4tv.com/lv3/41010" /><param name="allowScriptAccess" value="always" /><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true" /><embed src="http://g4tv.com/lv3/41010" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" name="VideoPlayer" width="480" height="418" allowScriptAccess="always" allowFullScreen="true" /></object><div style="margin:0;text-align:center;width:480px;font-family:Arial,sans-serif;font-size:12px;color:#FF9B00;"><a href="http://g4tv.com/" style="color:#FF9B00;" target="_blank">Video Games</a> - <a href="http://g4tv.com/e3" style="color:#FF9B00;" target="_blank">E3 2009</a> - <a href="http://g4tv.com/trailers/index.html" style="color:#FF9B00;" target="_blank">Video Game Trailers</a></div>

slop101 08-27-09 01:01 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by pinata242 (Post 9671561)
Serious Sam HD Trailer is full of :wtf: :lol:

Too bad the game's not as entertaining as that ad.

Michael Corvin 08-27-09 07:38 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
You sir, are crazy. Serious Sam is a blast. I will admit that it is overly long and gets monotonous about halfway through, but breaking up your play time alleviates that problem.

Shagrath 08-27-09 08:17 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
Deals of the month for September:
http://www.gamerbytes.com/2009/08/de...vealed_for.php

Week 1 - Penny Arcade 2 - 800 pts
Week 2 - Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords - 400 pts
Week 3 - Lode Runner - 800 pts
Week 4 - Pinball FX - 400 pts

Michael Corvin 08-27-09 08:23 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
Sweet, Lode Runner. :up: I missed out on the ebay seller who had them cheap.

pinata242 08-27-09 08:26 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I may end up getting all of those, but Puzzle Quest that I already have. If it were Galactrix, I'd bite.

PixyJunket 08-27-09 08:36 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Shagrath (Post 9671893)
Deals of the month for September:
http://www.gamerbytes.com/2009/08/de...vealed_for.php

Week 1 - Penny Arcade 2 - 800 pts
Week 2 - Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords - 400 pts
Week 3 - Lode Runner - 800 pts
Week 4 - Pinball FX - 400 pts

Sweet, I'll grab Lode Runner.

I'd like a Deal of the Week on Flock next.

Decker 08-27-09 09:00 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
Nice to see an all XBLA deal. Too bad I already own 3/4 of them and have no interest in PA.

Pixy, you missed it, but Amazon sold the XBLA version of Flock! for $10 when it came out and PSN sold it for $7.49 during their last sale. Personally, I'm not a fan of that game -- it seems like it should be fun, but at least for me, it isn't. I haven't played it in a long time.

EVERYONE should get Pinball FX for that price; it's a lot of fun. The two licensed
DLC tables available for it are great as well. Lode Runner is cool, looks great and is loaded with content and game modes, but it's challenging.

murray731 08-27-09 09:07 AM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I'll definitely be in for Lode Runner and maybe Pinball.

Liver&Onions 08-27-09 12:31 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I'm down with pinball - if it's as even half as good as Zen, I'll be happy for that price.

boredsilly 08-27-09 02:38 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 9671253)
There's no way Shadow Complex is a $30 game. $20 tops. I think everyone's just riding that hype train right now since it's new.

For what I'm willing to pay for games, I absolutely agree, but when I see some of the stuff that comes out at $60, SC seems like it would be fairly priced at $30. That would be the price of a DS or PSP game after all -- just without the resale value.

superfro 08-27-09 03:09 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 9671253)
There's no way Shadow Complex is a $30 game. $20 tops. I think everyone's just riding that hype train right now since it's new.

Well of course that's going to be subjective, but yeah...I would've paid $30 for Shadow Complex and still felt like I got a deal. No problem.

Spicollidriver1 08-27-09 03:38 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 
I agree with you but I'm not sure the demo and the hype would of sold me on $30 we may say that now but that is because we have played it through and know what we were getting no matter how great it is if you price it too high it won't get purchased.

Gooter 08-27-09 03:54 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Michael Corvin (Post 9671905)
Sweet, Lode Runner. :up: I missed out on the ebay seller who had them cheap.

Yeah, what happened to those sellers? There were at least two of them who sold XBLA games cheap but they all disappeared.

UncleGramps 08-27-09 04:14 PM

Re: XBLA Thread Part 400 - Pinata's got a brown nose
 

Originally Posted by Gooter (Post 9673216)
Yeah, what happened to those sellers? There were at least two of them who sold XBLA games cheap but they all disappeared.

I guess they're laying low, waiting for the heat to die down. Either that, or there are no more trucks driving around their neighborhood with the back doors open, dropping codes everywhere. ;)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:19 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.