Rock Band: Official Thread of Everyone is Rocking now (sorry, Wii)
#501
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,860
Received 1,685 Likes
on
1,200 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
#502
Member
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 122
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just don't get all this GH:WT hate.
I picked up GH:WT at the Best Buy midnight launch and have been having a blast playing since. RB2 is my favorite video game ever and I've never had more fun playing a game since it came out. It will probably remain my favorite game until RB3 comes out, but I haven't put it in my Xbox since GH:WT came out.
You RB fanboys can enjoy playing the same old tracks you've been playing the last few months along with the sub-par DLC you got this week and next. I'm gonna go have more fun playing great songs like Trapped Under Ice, Death Magnetic album, Band on the Run, Hotel California, Pull me Under, Beat It, Mr. Crowley, Crazy Train, No Rain, Are You Gonna go my Way, Anything, Stranglehold, Nugent/Wylde Guitar Battles, The Joker, Assassin, Hot for Teacher, Satch Boogie, Purple Haze, Rebel Yell, Hollywood Nights, Hot Blooded, Jessie's Girl, Do it Again & many many more.
Sure, they aren't quite as polished as they would be if they were in RB, but that doesn't mean they aren't worth playing. I play these games bacuase I am a music fan. I like singing and playing along to old favorites and just having fun with friends and family. Some of you are taking these games WAY too seriously.
I picked up GH:WT at the Best Buy midnight launch and have been having a blast playing since. RB2 is my favorite video game ever and I've never had more fun playing a game since it came out. It will probably remain my favorite game until RB3 comes out, but I haven't put it in my Xbox since GH:WT came out.
You RB fanboys can enjoy playing the same old tracks you've been playing the last few months along with the sub-par DLC you got this week and next. I'm gonna go have more fun playing great songs like Trapped Under Ice, Death Magnetic album, Band on the Run, Hotel California, Pull me Under, Beat It, Mr. Crowley, Crazy Train, No Rain, Are You Gonna go my Way, Anything, Stranglehold, Nugent/Wylde Guitar Battles, The Joker, Assassin, Hot for Teacher, Satch Boogie, Purple Haze, Rebel Yell, Hollywood Nights, Hot Blooded, Jessie's Girl, Do it Again & many many more.
Sure, they aren't quite as polished as they would be if they were in RB, but that doesn't mean they aren't worth playing. I play these games bacuase I am a music fan. I like singing and playing along to old favorites and just having fun with friends and family. Some of you are taking these games WAY too seriously.
I'm going to be so torn if GH gets Opeth DLC first. It was on that same list of most-wanted artists from dev's and anything they put in is fine with me. I might go halves on AC/DC and 250/250 + export it but I'm not sure just yet. PUSA pack will be a pick up, as will the 20 song pack. It can't be any worse than singing Spanish gibberish in GH like Dave Chappelle
#503
DVD Talk Godfather
I like the way you think. I'm not familiar with SG or W.A.S.P. though. I'd still love to see the Who's Tommy, Ayreon's Human Equation or Universal Migrator 1, Pain of Salvation's Be or Scarsick and of course Coheed & Cambria's Good Apollo IV pt.1 or 2.
Concept albums seem to be the only full albums that really fit this 'album' DLC format. It's a perfect fit but we have yet to actually get one. Ayreon would be great since he has such a varied group of singers on every album.
#504
Senior Member
Based on your tastes above, I have no idea how you are not familiar with Shadow Gallery. I suggest you go order Tyranny as soon as humanly possible. Your ears will thank me later.
#505
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,860
Received 1,685 Likes
on
1,200 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
The way I see it, if GHWT ever drops in price just for the game only. I may consider picking it up.
I just can't bring myself to purchase, at full price, a game in which I only want to play 17 songs as opposed to the 40 RB2 songs which I want to play.
I just can't bring myself to purchase, at full price, a game in which I only want to play 17 songs as opposed to the 40 RB2 songs which I want to play.
#506
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#507
DVD Talk Godfather
Are you familiar with Frameshift's Absence of Empathy? I would have added that one but thought it would be way obscure for discussion. Hands down Sebastian Bach's best vocal work of his career. Prog + Concept album + Bach = Win.
#508
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I don't understand the Live hate/indifference. They never quite got their due. IMO. They would have some great RB translated songs.
#509
DVD Talk Gold Edition
On Tour: Decades? I don't care if it's a handheld system, it's still a brand-new game and not a port. I'm sure there are others coming. Didn't ActiBlizz say they were going to do 4 titles a year, and up it to 6 a little bit down the road? That's over-saturation if you ask me.
Personally, I would've been happy with Rock Band just being Rock Band 1 forever, but the additions in RB2 are awesome. If GH can be forward-thinking and make all of their DLC from this point on compatible, it will help them out in the long run. We'll see though.
Personally, I would've been happy with Rock Band just being Rock Band 1 forever, but the additions in RB2 are awesome. If GH can be forward-thinking and make all of their DLC from this point on compatible, it will help them out in the long run. We'll see though.
I think they are...not sure what else that code for is on the manual. I think RB set the precedent that they will have to from now on.
#510
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I noticed that Half.com already has product pages in place for the AC/DC disc: http://product.half.ebay.com/AC-DC-L...oQQprZ70783636
I think I should easily be able to clear $25, worst case scenario. So all that AC/DC goodness for $20 is awesome for me.
#511
DVD Talk Legend
I tend to think Carved In Stone and Tyranny are equal, but CIS is not a concept record. Not as crazy about the later SG stuff.
How about some Symphony X?
Now, my main artist requests would be:
Fear Factory
Rammstein
Porcupine Tree
Opeth
Seal
Last edited by bunkaroo; 10-30-08 at 03:28 PM.
#512
DVD Talk Godfather
Symphony X is solid. Outside Divine Wings though nothing has truly blown me away. V and Paradise Lost were good, but it's hard to top DWoT.
#513
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 556
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#514
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#516
Senior Member
How about some Symphony X?
Last edited by clintilona; 10-30-08 at 02:04 PM.
#517
I know we have moved past this discussion and many folks aren't a fan of playing the song in-game but Bob Dylan is a big name to have in RB. He may not draw the younger gaming crowd but he (like The Eagles, Paul Simon, etc.) draw large crowds at concerts where the tickets are super expensive.
Speaking of.... i want some Simon and Garfunkle in RB.
Speaking of.... i want some Simon and Garfunkle in RB.
#518
DVD Talk Legend
This might be the case and how it differs from Rock Band. I don't know how they can add additional mics, unless they're not tied to a controller slot (wireless and synced to the guitar, perhaps)? Then they could give the option to export to Rock Band, but you lose that stuff.
#519
I'm catching up on posts now...
I agree with the clamoring for Live. Personally i would rather have their first album Mental Jewelry but i would settle for Throwing Copper.
As for the Beatles project. I am very stoked for the Beatles. I hope the tracks are exportable into RB (since i assume it will be a complete standalone game that i will happily buy).
I am also really taken with the idea of making the Beatles game essentially be RB3 and have the ability to bring all the RB1 and RB2 tracks into that version. It would be a genius way to hype that title and upgrade the engine.
I agree with the clamoring for Live. Personally i would rather have their first album Mental Jewelry but i would settle for Throwing Copper.
As for the Beatles project. I am very stoked for the Beatles. I hope the tracks are exportable into RB (since i assume it will be a complete standalone game that i will happily buy).
I am also really taken with the idea of making the Beatles game essentially be RB3 and have the ability to bring all the RB1 and RB2 tracks into that version. It would be a genius way to hype that title and upgrade the engine.
#521
#522
I'm wondering why there isn't more (or SOME) from the likes of Elvis, The Beach Boys, Van Morrison, and any combination of Crosby, Stills, Nash, & Young? Could the availability of quality masters be an issue for some of those older groups?
I'd love Suite Judy Blue Eyes, even if it might be boring on guitar.
I'd love Suite Judy Blue Eyes, even if it might be boring on guitar.
#523
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,860
Received 1,685 Likes
on
1,200 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
#524
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,860
Received 1,685 Likes
on
1,200 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
I hope you understand...
That I.. don't like the Beatles...
I'm really not a fan....
#525
DVD Talk Godfather
Spoiler:




Four more to go.