mrnededwards

The enclosed King Kong disc plays fine. However, I tried 4 other discs (3 being new Warner Music HD DVD releases and 1 being the HD DVD version of "Pirates") and here are the results:

1. The Warner Music titles get to the main menu, I hear two "click" sounds and then the disc freezes up.
2. The XBOX 360 HD DVD does not recognize the "Pirates" disc (Digital Playground release) as an HD DVD.

Any one experiencing the same problems? Is it the machine or the discs?

GeoffK

The Pirates disc is a WM-HD DVD. Not a true HD DVD... Designed to pay on a computer not a standard HD DVD player.

Centurion

I guarantee you will get more feedback if this thread were in the HD Talk subsection of this forum.

Noonan

The only problem with mine is that EBGames hasn't shipped it yet.

I agree that'd you'll have been luck asking in the HD Forum than here.

warcp

Doesn't sound like the same problem as mine, but mine was definitely broken. It would play any disc for about 5 minutes then it would have trouble reading the disc and would default back to the 360 menu.

Deftones

Yep. It's not broken. Just get discs that are meant for the player.

The Bus

What are the Warner discs?

REL77

Yes, you need real HD-DVD disc, not those PC Windows HD version... Same thing with like T2, they wont play... Buy real HD-DVDs

mrnededwards

The Warner Music discs are REAL HD-DVD :

Cream - Royal Albert Hall London
Eagles - Farewell Tour Live From Melbourne
James Taylor - Music Cares Person Of The Year

Thanks for the info about PC Windows HD.

s}{ammer

That's so lame. I never even heard that there were two different versions of HD-DVD. This is not going to go over well with consumers who buy an HD-DVD and want it to just work. As for MS and the Xbox360 HD-DVD player, there is no reason they can't make them work on the 360.

mrnededwards

Yeah, you would think Microsoft's Windows HD would be compatible with their XBOX 360 HD DVD.

I'm still stumped on the 3 Warner Music titles that do not play.

mrnededwards

Yeah, you would think Microsoft's Windows HD would be compatible with their XBOX 360 HD DVD.

I'm still stumped on the 3 Warner Music titles that do not play.

RichC2

There isn't, the HD-DVD w/ WMV files aren't HD-DVDs, they're just high def files included on standard DVDs, T2 had it as well.

That said, you should be able to play those WMV files on the Media Player on the Xbox 360 console, or can you not play them off a DVD?

Additionally, does the HD-DVD Player not play regular DVDs? I know it's kind of a pointless feature since your regular system has a DVD Player built in, but it'd be good to know.

clappj

It's plays regular DVDs just fine.

Deftones

There aren't. The WMV discs aren't HD-DVDs. They are standard DVDs in the WMV format in HD. They are clearly labeled as such.

s}{ammer

Ah,I see. Well then I am ok with this and MS now had permission to continue selling the HD-DVD drive for the 360.

bahgee

So does the Pirates disc have WMV files that can be played from the 360?

starseed1981

Mine works totally fine. I due have the "clicks" issue though.

Supermallet

If I recall, the Pirates DVD is misleading in its packaging.