Warcraft 3 Impressions
#26
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Outlaw
To those of you who have played this game, how does this game compare to Starcraft? I've heard that starcraft was based on Warcraft, but I was introduced to this type of game with Starcraft and its the only game I've ever played of this kind. I'm not sure if I'll like it. Also how good of a PC do you need to run it?
To those of you who have played this game, how does this game compare to Starcraft? I've heard that starcraft was based on Warcraft, but I was introduced to this type of game with Starcraft and its the only game I've ever played of this kind. I'm not sure if I'll like it. Also how good of a PC do you need to run it?
#27
Cool New Member
Joined: Feb 2001
Posts: 27
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Minneapolis, MN
i ordered the collector's edition through samgoody.com. the msrp is $79.95, they listed it at $74.95. when i added it to my cart, i got another 10% off bringing it down to $67.50. for an extra $8 you get the book, dvd, and such. you get an action figure too...
#28
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 3,876
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Des Moines, WA
Originally posted by Outlaw
To those of you who have played this game, how does this game compare to Starcraft? I've heard that starcraft was based on Warcraft, but I was introduced to this type of game with Starcraft and its the only game I've ever played of this kind. I'm not sure if I'll like it. Also how good of a PC do you need to run it?
To those of you who have played this game, how does this game compare to Starcraft? I've heard that starcraft was based on Warcraft, but I was introduced to this type of game with Starcraft and its the only game I've ever played of this kind. I'm not sure if I'll like it. Also how good of a PC do you need to run it?
-CM
#29
DVD Talk Special Edition
Just to add a few things:
Lumber isn't affected by upkeep. And I think they even mention somewhere that you should actively seek out other resources to counteract the effects of upkeep. If you have two gold mines when you hit low upkeep, you are making more money than you would have with 1 mine under no upkeep.
All heroes are 5 food, and there is a special building dedicated to summoning and reviving those. If you played a bit of Starcraft, you shouldn't have trouble using any of the races, as their buildings and units mix and match different characteristics form the units in Starcraft. For example, the Undead are like the Zerg, in that they need to build their buildings on special ground; but they're also like the Protoss, in that you and summon a building, then forget about it - the builder can go on and do other things. The night elves have buildings that can move, like the Terrans, and shield generator-like buildings that restore your units' health.
-
About the single-player skirmish; yeah, I got trounced too. I'd chalk it up to my turtle-style of play (I'm afraid to attack until I have at least 50% of my tech researched and 25 defense buildings guarding my base), but the enemy's hero units are always a bit unnerving. They're always 5 or 6 levels above mine, and I read that you're only allowed to do the ultimate spell once a day; well I saw a Priestess of Moon do her Starfall attack 4 times in the span of 10 minutes. It was insane...
I'm going to play a skirmish with an allied AI next time, and see how they work.
Lumber isn't affected by upkeep. And I think they even mention somewhere that you should actively seek out other resources to counteract the effects of upkeep. If you have two gold mines when you hit low upkeep, you are making more money than you would have with 1 mine under no upkeep.
All heroes are 5 food, and there is a special building dedicated to summoning and reviving those. If you played a bit of Starcraft, you shouldn't have trouble using any of the races, as their buildings and units mix and match different characteristics form the units in Starcraft. For example, the Undead are like the Zerg, in that they need to build their buildings on special ground; but they're also like the Protoss, in that you and summon a building, then forget about it - the builder can go on and do other things. The night elves have buildings that can move, like the Terrans, and shield generator-like buildings that restore your units' health.
-
About the single-player skirmish; yeah, I got trounced too. I'd chalk it up to my turtle-style of play (I'm afraid to attack until I have at least 50% of my tech researched and 25 defense buildings guarding my base), but the enemy's hero units are always a bit unnerving. They're always 5 or 6 levels above mine, and I read that you're only allowed to do the ultimate spell once a day; well I saw a Priestess of Moon do her Starfall attack 4 times in the span of 10 minutes. It was insane...
I'm going to play a skirmish with an allied AI next time, and see how they work.
#30
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 3,876
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Des Moines, WA
The 'cooldown' time on the ultimate attacks is 120 seconds. This site: http://www.battle.net/war3/ has descriptions for all the units, and a little bit of strategy for them as well. I really learned a lot from checking it out. Still didn't help me on my single-player skirmish games though. Actually I lasted an hour yesterday, rather than the 10 minutes that it usually took.
-Chad
-Chad
#32
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2001
Posts: 995
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: San Diego to Los Angeles
I tried playing a Multiplayer game against the computer and they are alot smarter and faster than with Starcraft. With Starcraft I can easily take out 2 computer. With WC3 it took me a few times just to beat 1 computer.
#33
DVD Talk Special Edition
That's true - I STILL haven't been able to beat any of the computers in a fair match. There is a bug though - the computers can't figure out they need to cut trees in order to make paths. There is one map divided into four quadrants, each blocked by trees. I was able to take out three computers,one by one, because the trees blocked their way. However, I feel that such a bug also shut off the AI, because the computer kept all their units in the back of the base - I was able to slash my way through half of the base before they even responded.
#34
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 1,388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: LA
Originally posted by RolloTomasi
That's true - I STILL haven't been able to beat any of the computers in a fair match. There is a bug though - the computers can't figure out they need to cut trees in order to make paths. There is one map divided into four quadrants, each blocked by trees. I was able to take out three computers,one by one, because the trees blocked their way. However, I feel that such a bug also shut off the AI, because the computer kept all their units in the back of the base - I was able to slash my way through half of the base before they even responded.
That's true - I STILL haven't been able to beat any of the computers in a fair match. There is a bug though - the computers can't figure out they need to cut trees in order to make paths. There is one map divided into four quadrants, each blocked by trees. I was able to take out three computers,one by one, because the trees blocked their way. However, I feel that such a bug also shut off the AI, because the computer kept all their units in the back of the base - I was able to slash my way through half of the base before they even responded.
As for deals on the game, I'm going to wait for the Sunday ads after the game comes out to figure out who has it on sale. Between Compusa, Best Buy and Circuit City, one of them should have it for a decent price.
#35
Cool New Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 46
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Nashville, TN
Share the Love: Warcraft Deluxe Edition
I'll be ordering this from Amazon.com tonight 6-28), if anyone wants some love for this email me at: [email protected]
#38
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 1,732
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York, N.Y.
Originally posted by enthused
This game has no sea battles? There are no boats? I'm not seeing anything about boats... wtf
This game has no sea battles? There are no boats? I'm not seeing anything about boats... wtf
There is one scenario where at the end, you get into a boat. Not sure if you can actually fight in a boat though. I'm only up to the 3rd human scenario.
#40
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Crizzar
nope, no boat fighting.....you won't miss it at all.
nope, no boat fighting.....you won't miss it at all.

I liked the pretty boats
I wondered why I never saw any at E3, now I know.
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 1,732
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York, N.Y.
Originally posted by Crizzar
nope, no boat fighting.....you won't miss it at all.
nope, no boat fighting.....you won't miss it at all.
#42
Uber Member
Originally posted by enthused
This game has no sea battles? There are no boats? I'm not seeing anything about boats... wtf
This game has no sea battles? There are no boats? I'm not seeing anything about boats... wtf
-David
#43
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 3,876
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Des Moines, WA
The more elements you have, the more complex the game is. True, the boats in WCII were ok, but with all of the stuff in this game, it would be difficult to keep up if you had to deal with boats too. Just look at Star Wars: Galactic Battlegrounds. There are something like 4 or 5 resources to deal with... food, multiple crystal types, etc... I think that they get all carried away with the many types of buildings and don't focus on the units enough. In SWGB all of the unit types from race to race are pretty much the same. The only thing that makes the game fun is the ability to have Vader or Darth Maul, or Luke. Once I built a custom game with only 2 units, Yoda and Vader. Yoda didn't even have a saber, just his cane, and he defeated Vader! It was pretty cool. But you throw in all of those resources and buildings... especially the fact that you have to keep replenishing your farms, and you have to have a unit at each farm to collect the food. Also they give you 3 different methods of getting food... killing a beast and having your units run back and forth getting the meat, building a corral and getting the food from the animals without killing them, and building and cultivating farms. Anyway, WCIII is plenty of fun without boats. Has anyone tried the Sheep game? How about the Hero game?
-CM-
-CM-
#44
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Dec 1999
Posts: 2,708
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I know that I can find the minimum requirements for WCIII online, but as we all know these stats are *bare* minimum. What kind of requirements will I *really* need to play this game (with smooth gameplay)? Thanks
#45
Suspended Pending Valid Email
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 147
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Philly
Originally posted by Lampei
I know that I can find the minimum requirements for WCIII online, but as we all know these stats are *bare* minimum. What kind of requirements will I *really* need to play this game (with smooth gameplay)? Thanks
I know that I can find the minimum requirements for WCIII online, but as we all know these stats are *bare* minimum. What kind of requirements will I *really* need to play this game (with smooth gameplay)? Thanks
#47
DVD Talk Legend
ok I have played thru the orc and human campaigns and am now on the undead one.
I like the game
The main question is what comes after the undead campaign?
do you just play them on a harder setting?
I tried out the online play and won my first match- after looking at the replay my opponent(Shadow of Death
) just made a few orcs and sent them at me right away. I guess he was hoping for a quick win.
I beat the 4 of them and he gave up and quit the game
I finished playing out the map so that I could see everything on it anyway
I like the game

The main question is what comes after the undead campaign?
do you just play them on a harder setting?
I tried out the online play and won my first match- after looking at the replay my opponent(Shadow of Death
) just made a few orcs and sent them at me right away. I guess he was hoping for a quick win.I beat the 4 of them and he gave up and quit the game

I finished playing out the map so that I could see everything on it anyway
#48
Uber Member
Isn't the Dark Elf campaign next?
I started playing the campaigns on Hard, so I'm still stuck on Human 5 (caravan).
I haven't tried playing multiplayer yet.
So far, I'm undecided. I remember WC II and Starcraft being much more fun than this. Maybe after I finish this damn mission!
It also seems like they cribbed a bunch of stuff from Diablo 2.
-David
I started playing the campaigns on Hard, so I'm still stuck on Human 5 (caravan).
I haven't tried playing multiplayer yet.
So far, I'm undecided. I remember WC II and Starcraft being much more fun than this. Maybe after I finish this damn mission!

It also seems like they cribbed a bunch of stuff from Diablo 2.
-David
#50
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 8,953
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: PDX Metro
I am now on the last Nightelf mission. I started on normal difficulty and am really looking forward to some battle-net games.
This game is a serious amount of fun. playing against the computer is going to take a lot of strategy, they are so fast.
I also love that you can get other peoples saved games and watch their strategy.
This game is a serious amount of fun. playing against the computer is going to take a lot of strategy, they are so fast.
I also love that you can get other peoples saved games and watch their strategy.



