Black Mirror (Netflix) -- Season 4 Thread
#51
DVD Talk Legend
#52
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 65,293
Received 2,699 Likes
on
1,600 Posts
From: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
#53
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
So this is going back to last season's "Nosedive" but this is a somewhat fascinating, somewhat frightening article about Social Credit in China. It's a long read but worth it.
https://www.wired.com/story/age-of-social-credit/
https://www.wired.com/story/age-of-social-credit/
#54
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Just finished it up, I enjoyed this season more than last season... finally got a so called "feel good" ep... worth the wait!
just finished a good podcast with the creator charlie brooker, was a fun listen
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09kx840
Here's my rankings:
Hang the DJ
USS Callister
Arkangel
Metalhead
Black Museum
Crocodile
just finished a good podcast with the creator charlie brooker, was a fun listen
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09kx840
Here's my rankings:
Hang the DJ
USS Callister
Arkangel
Metalhead
Black Museum
Crocodile
#55
Moderator
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
They went all in with the "uploaded consciousness" tech this season, possibly because of the acclaim San Junipero got last season.
My rankings:
1. "Hang the DJ" -- enjoyable story, well paced and executed, with a fun explanation
2. "USS Callister" -- good for Star Trek fans, although it does seem to drag a bit after the "reveal"
3. "Black Museum" -- not bad, but the performance of the main guy was a huge turnoff to me, I found him very grating.
4. "Arkangel" -- pretty meh, this could have been told almost the same way with current tech. I did like the exploration of what happens with tech after a company goes belly-up (remember Divx?), but it took a back seat to the main plot.
5. "Crocodile" -- pretty much a conventional thriller, again it could have been told almost the exact same way without the tech elements.
6. "Metalhead" -- just an episode of "The Walking Dead" with robots instead of zombies.
My rankings:
1. "Hang the DJ" -- enjoyable story, well paced and executed, with a fun explanation
2. "USS Callister" -- good for Star Trek fans, although it does seem to drag a bit after the "reveal"
3. "Black Museum" -- not bad, but the performance of the main guy was a huge turnoff to me, I found him very grating.
4. "Arkangel" -- pretty meh, this could have been told almost the same way with current tech. I did like the exploration of what happens with tech after a company goes belly-up (remember Divx?), but it took a back seat to the main plot.
5. "Crocodile" -- pretty much a conventional thriller, again it could have been told almost the exact same way without the tech elements.
6. "Metalhead" -- just an episode of "The Walking Dead" with robots instead of zombies.
#56
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
So having said that, I wish there was something in the episode that confirmed that they had written down the wrong inventory number -- meaning that even if they had succeeded in their mission, they would've opened a box containing the wrong item.
I'm not sure, exactly. It's just that the best Black Mirror episodes have both interesting set-ups AND interesting payoffs. With "Black Museum," all three had interesting set-ups that the payoffs didn't really meet or surpass. I just found myself mentally shrugging with each conclusion. The idea of a consciousness being trapped in a stuffed monkey and only capable of two responses SHOULD be horrifying... but the episode just didn't really convey that horror adequately, at least not for me.
Also, you used the phrase "preachy tone". I'm always wary when that word is used, even when i use it myself , because it's often used in a context of "those aren't my thoughts on that matter so let me downplay this by calling it preachy". I mean tell me, what part was so "preachy"?
Bottom line: "Black Museum" just didn't deliver for me, and "Metalhead" ruined its potential with the final reveal. For me, "USS Callister" and "Hang the DJ" were the standout episodes.
#57
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 34,257
Received 2,052 Likes
on
1,394 Posts
From: Not necessarily Formerly known as Solid Snake
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Well ... you could say that in about the loosest sense you could have; but I don't agree. The concept of Black Mirror is an exploration of the complexity of humanity and the ways in which technology alters the human state.
... It is just a 'monster' story, not an exploration of how tech impacts humanity.
... It is just a 'monster' story, not an exploration of how tech impacts humanity.
People are mad that the mission was "just for a teddy bear for dying child"....Well my gawd...you can't get much more HUMAN that that. These people died trying to make a dying child feel better. A risky Fool's Mission? Yes. But a HUMAN MISSION nonetheless. The Dogs fucked all that up. Seems to me this ep once again has hit the right tone of the Black Mirror series and it didn't even occur to me how much it did until I read the negative comments here.
Well ... you could say that in about the loosest sense you could have; but I don't agree. The concept of Black Mirror is an exploration of the complexity of humanity and the ways in which technology alters the human state.
Metalhead was just ... Terminator-dog. If the 'dogs' were created as a security or home assistance device which went rogue and destroyed humanity, then I suppose I could get behind that. But with no back story like that, I just don't think it fits. It is just a 'monster' story, not an exploration of how tech impacts humanity.
I'll agree 100% with you on enjoying each episode though. Even Metalhead, which was gorgeous with a plot that doesn't hold up well.
Metalhead was just ... Terminator-dog. If the 'dogs' were created as a security or home assistance device which went rogue and destroyed humanity, then I suppose I could get behind that. But with no back story like that, I just don't think it fits. It is just a 'monster' story, not an exploration of how tech impacts humanity.
I'll agree 100% with you on enjoying each episode though. Even Metalhead, which was gorgeous with a plot that doesn't hold up well.
Last edited by Abob Teff; 01-10-18 at 09:48 PM.
#58
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,774
Received 1,730 Likes
on
1,390 Posts
From: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
#59
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Easily my least favorite season. Two standout episodes (Hang the DJ & USS Callister), 1 good one (Arkangel), 2 mediocre ones (Crocodile & Metalhead) and one awful one (Black Museum).
#60
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Terribly underwhelming. Not a single episode stood out to me. USS Callister was good but dragged on too long, plus, maybe I have Trek (or Trek like) fatigue from Discovery and The Orville. Worst season so far.
#61
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
We all love Black Mirror, but who has the time for a full episode.
Introducing Mini Black Mirror. All the twists in only two minutes:
Introducing Mini Black Mirror. All the twists in only two minutes:
#62
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 34,257
Received 2,052 Likes
on
1,394 Posts
From: Not necessarily Formerly known as Solid Snake
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Not sure what you meant there ... all the twists?
#64
DVD Talk Godfather
#65
Thread Starter
Moderator
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
'Black Mirror' Renewed for Season 5 at Netflix
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/li...etflix-1090957
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/li...etflix-1090957
#66
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix

Even middle of the road episodes keep me more interested than a lot of movies these days.
#68
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
I wonder if the new season will get into the issue of consciousness/technology interfacing.
#69
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Bit behind the times but started the series last weekend and finished it today. Superb all around, each season getting better with the 4th being the best in the bunch. Reading around a bit on the rankings in this thread and other articles it's clear each episode touches different nerves in people based on their life experiences. My 5 favorite are Be Right Back, White Christmas, Hated in the Nation, USS Callister, and Hang the DJ.
The only episodes I thought were weak were San Junipero (the ending made little sense considering the story before it and felt like a tacked on happy ending) and Men Against Fire (weakest story as it's something that has been done hundreds of times and having been in and around the military most of my life I find it hard to believe you would find enough people to volunteer willingly for something like that to make a force big enough to field an Army).
The only episodes I thought were weak were San Junipero (the ending made little sense considering the story before it and felt like a tacked on happy ending) and Men Against Fire (weakest story as it's something that has been done hundreds of times and having been in and around the military most of my life I find it hard to believe you would find enough people to volunteer willingly for something like that to make a force big enough to field an Army).
#70
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
You're in an EXTREME minority if you didn't like San Junipero, as it's widely considered the best episode of the entire series.
#71
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Yes, San Junipero is amazing. IMHO this is the best episode of BM, and one of the single best episodes of a TV series I've ever seen.
#72
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
San Junipero is a near-great episode, but I think it's somewhat overpraised. There are better episodes of BM in my opinion.
#73
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
I think it get a lot of praise because it was the first with a happy ending. After 10 episodes with dour or bittersweet endings, it was refreshing to have one that was just a happy ending.
#74
Thread Starter
Moderator
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
The Entire History of You is my favorite. But San Junipero is great stuff.
Last edited by dex14; 04-10-18 at 07:55 PM.
#75
Re: Black Mirror -- British anthology series -- Channel 4 / Netflix
Like I said, the episode is great until the end when it just turns to fan service. Truth be told even if Kelly didn't end up staying with Yorkie you still had a happy ending. Yorkie finally made her decision to stay in SJ because she got to experience the life that was taken from her. Kelly would have made the decision not to stay based off her marriage. Kelly's speech about why it was selfish and wrong for Yorkie to say those things about her decision were 100% correct. In no way would I believe that Kelly have made that choice in the end after spending, what, a month or so with Kelly compared to 48 years with her husband and child, both who aren't in SJ. The proper and logical ending would have been both going their separate ways. The ending we got completely ruined the episode. Hang the DJ does a much better job justifying the happy ending.



