#26
The time travel explanation was just like that one episode where they tried to explain how destroying one of the bombs destroyed them all. I love the show, but man, it'd be so much more with some better writers.
#27
will travel , 01-28-16 02:10 AM
DVD Talk Special Edition
will travel
DVD Talk Special Edition
close
- Join DateFeb 2004
- LocationIowa
- Posts:1,594
Received 184 Likes
on
106 Posts
Time Travel. My Mantra is "Don't over think it, just go with the flow".
Thus I was able to enjoy this episode with the Reverse-Flash.
Also nice to see Tina McGee again. Glad they haven't forgotten about her.
Sad to see Patty go. She and Barry had some vibes together.
Thus I was able to enjoy this episode with the Reverse-Flash.
Also nice to see Tina McGee again. Glad they haven't forgotten about her.
Sad to see Patty go. She and Barry had some vibes together.
#29
Quote:
Same here. Even a "I watched the Flash fail to save my mom so I am evil" origin is stronger and those usually suck.Originally Posted by randian
Thawne's motivations seemed a little thin to me, and the whole "I had to be your opposite" speech was just dumb.
#30
Here we go with the insistent "TIME TRAVEL DOESN'T WORK THAT WAY" posts 

#31
PhantomStranger , 01-28-16 01:04 PM
DVD Talk Hero
PhantomStranger
DVD Talk Hero
close
- Join DateFeb 2007
- LocationThe Phantom Zone
- Posts:29,284
Received 1,204 Likes
on
1,007 Posts
The comics have been pretty firm in depicting the Speed Force existing independently outside our space and time, which solves many problems involving time travel.
#32
Quote:
Well that's pretty much taken straight from the comics.Originally Posted by randian
Thawne's motivations seemed a little thin to me, and the whole "I had to be your opposite" speech was just dumb.
#33
Quote:
Yes! We are experts on the subject! Originally Posted by Hokeyboy
Here we go with the insistent "TIME TRAVEL DOESN'T WORK THAT WAY" posts

#34
Superman07 , 01-28-16 09:31 PM
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Superman07
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
close
- Join DateJul 2003
- LocationSnogBox
- Posts:8,732
Received 153 Likes
on
115 Posts
Patty! 
At least Barry manned up in costume to her, even though he didn't give her a good explanation.
I thought Well's explanation was good until he drew on the board. Then his scribbles didn't line up with what he just explained. I thought he was going to show that a version of Thawne must have been in the Speedforce slipstream when the murder/assassination occurred. Except that's not what he scribbled.

At least Barry manned up in costume to her, even though he didn't give her a good explanation.
I thought Well's explanation was good until he drew on the board. Then his scribbles didn't line up with what he just explained. I thought he was going to show that a version of Thawne must have been in the Speedforce slipstream when the murder/assassination occurred. Except that's not what he scribbled.
#35
Michael Corvin , 01-29-16 06:21 PM
DVD Talk Godfather
Michael Corvin
DVD Talk Godfather
close
- Join DateMay 1999
- LocationLouisville, KY
- Posts:63,453
Received 1,377 Likes
on
943 Posts
This show, man. Awesome! I wish post 5 didn't ruin the Zoom reveal for some of us.
Patty, you will be missed. Bloated cast or not, she was always good to have around.
So that explanation basically means you aren't erased from existence. You still live your life from point A to point Z and regardless of where you are in the timeline, you still die at Z. Good. I like it, kind of a different take on paradoxes. Right?
HOW the fuck EVER... Cisco was being erased from existence, a direct contradiction to what Harry was describing.
Unless I'm interpreting all that wrong.
Patty, you will be missed. Bloated cast or not, she was always good to have around.
Quote:
Yeah, I'm pretty sure I followed what he was saying just fine but the drawing didn't match up with what he was saying at all. At any rate, I like the explanation.Originally Posted by Superman07
I thought Well's explanation was good until he drew on the board. Then his scribbles didn't line up with what he just explained. I thought he was going to show that a version of Thawne must have been in the Speedforce slipstream when the murder/assassination occurred. Except that's not what he scribbled.
So that explanation basically means you aren't erased from existence. You still live your life from point A to point Z and regardless of where you are in the timeline, you still die at Z. Good. I like it, kind of a different take on paradoxes. Right?
HOW the fuck EVER... Cisco was being erased from existence, a direct contradiction to what Harry was describing.
Unless I'm interpreting all that wrong.
#36
Hunter Zolomon showing up could mean that Barry (and maybe Wally) are going to visit Gorilla City sometime in the near future. (At least I hope that's the case)
#37
I don't know about Gorilla City in the near future, but this is coming in a few weeks.
http://www.hitfix.com/harpy/diggle-f...k-on-the-flash
http://www.hitfix.com/harpy/diggle-f...k-on-the-flash
#38
I didn't mind the time travel explanation in this one, and liked the idea that we were seeing the Reverse Flash's origin story. My only wish was that they had dumped some of the Legends of Tomorrow setup and had a few more episodes fleshing this out instead.
Only thing that gets me is when someone says something like, "Barry, all you need to do is race up to the point of time travel and then throw him through." As though there's any sort of baseline for what that means.
And Barry just says, "OK, sure." 
Only thing that gets me is when someone says something like, "Barry, all you need to do is race up to the point of time travel and then throw him through." As though there's any sort of baseline for what that means.
And Barry just says, "OK, sure." 
#39
Giantrobo , 02-01-16 01:16 PM
DVD Talk Godfather
Giantrobo
DVD Talk Godfather
close
- Join DateApr 1999
- LocationGateway Cities/Harbor Region
- Posts:65,281
Received 2,697 Likes
on
1,598 Posts
Sooo...in this TV version of these characters why aren't the Reverse Flash and Zoom villains focused on each other? They seem to both want to be "the fastest or most powerful speedster".
If I were Barry talking to the Reverse Flash I would be like..."Dude, there's this thing called Zoom who is faster than both of us and he called your mother a whore..."
If I were Barry talking to the Reverse Flash I would be like..."Dude, there's this thing called Zoom who is faster than both of us and he called your mother a whore..."
#40
Deftones , 02-01-16 01:34 PM
DVD Talk God
Deftones
DVD Talk God
close
- Join DateOct 1999
- LocationArizona
- Posts:83,592
Received 2,057 Likes
on
1,386 Posts
Quote:
http://www.hitfix.com/harpy/diggle-f...k-on-the-flash
I will give the producers a bunch of credit. They recognize what fans love and give them more of it on this show. Originally Posted by mwbmis
I don't know about Gorilla City in the near future, but this is coming in a few weeks. http://www.hitfix.com/harpy/diggle-f...k-on-the-flash

#41
Michael Corvin , 02-01-16 01:41 PM
DVD Talk Godfather
Michael Corvin
DVD Talk Godfather
close
- Join DateMay 1999
- LocationLouisville, KY
- Posts:63,453
Received 1,377 Likes
on
943 Posts
Quote:
Well one is from Earth 2, so why would Reverse Flash have knowledge of him? And from Zoom's perspective, RF is from the future, how would he know about him?Originally Posted by Giantrobo
Sooo...in this TV version of these characters why aren't the Reverse Flash and Zoom villains focused on each other? They seem to both want to be "the fastest or most powerful speedster".
Quote:
Originally Posted by Giantrobo
If I were Barry talking to the Reverse Flash I would be like..."Dude, there's this thing called Zoom who is faster than both of us and he called your mother a whore..."
Well, that might work.
#42
Quote:
If I were Barry talking to the Reverse Flash I would be like..."Dude, there's this thing called Zoom who is faster than both of us and he called your mother a whore..."
I think Thawn is more focused on punishing Barry than power.Originally Posted by Giantrobo
Sooo...in this TV version of these characters why aren't the Reverse Flash and Zoom villains focused on each other? They seem to both want to be "the fastest or most powerful speedster". If I were Barry talking to the Reverse Flash I would be like..."Dude, there's this thing called Zoom who is faster than both of us and he called your mother a whore..."
#43
I thought that the Reverse Flash's origin speech was a bit wanting...
Was I the only one who had to hit the 'net to figure out what was going on in this episode?
Spoiler:
Was I the only one who had to hit the 'net to figure out what was going on in this episode?
