The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
#51
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
The thing is the writers/producers/show runners of the Flash and Arrow want it both ways. I have no problem if they want to create original characters for the shows but they want to use existing characters from an established universal (although one in continual flux) and make dramatic changes. At minimum it's lazy and at worst it's disingenuous. It's cheap lip service to fans. It's like they are saying "look, look we are using this character from the DC universe aren't we smart....of course he doesn't really fit so were and changing him... a lot." Having Linda Park in this show as a love interest for Barry is the best example. I actually like Roth and Malese Jow and would happily accept them as an original character.
#52
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
The thing is the writers/producers/show runners of the Flash and Arrow want it both ways. I have no problem if they want to create original characters for the shows but they want to use existing characters from an established universal (although one in continual flux) and make dramatic changes. At minimum it's lazy and at worst it's disingenuous. It's cheap lip service to fans. It's like they are saying "look, look we are using this character from the DC universe aren't we smart....of course he doesn't really fit so were and changing him... a lot." Having Linda Park in this show as a love interest for Barry is the best example. I actually like Roth and Malese Jow and would happily accept them as an original character.
#53
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
I don't care about the comic talk, I just think it's silly to hold television Barry who has been the Flash for mere months to the standards of his comic book counterpart who has been the Flash for decades.
#54
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
And please kill Iris (for drama or whatever) and bring Felicity on this show. I love her character.
Oh, and Barry secret identity is getting as bad as the Spider-Man movies. Why wear a mask anymore? Soon everyone will know his secret identity. Guess they are going to lock the bee villain away so she can't tell anyone now either. It's starting to feel like all of his enemies and friends (and acquaintances) know that The Flash is Barry...except Iris. (At least they acknowledged this with a funny line in this episode.)
Minor criticisms but my family and I are loving this show. Other than Face-Off, this is my kid's favorite show on TV and also probably my wife's second favorite which is really saying something. I feel they are doing the story build-up on the Wells confrontation really well.
#55
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
I think there's room for both what's on screen and what has been either taken from the comics or modified towards a television medium.
It's not like they're specifically following some story arc, so it's simply comparing the two formats and how they have transitioned the characters to the screen. Should book talk be kept separate from a film translation of said book?
It's not like they're specifically following some story arc, so it's simply comparing the two formats and how they have transitioned the characters to the screen. Should book talk be kept separate from a film translation of said book?
#56
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
I don't watch Green Arrow so all this Atom stuff is new to me. Was it said on Green Arrow why he decided to call himself The Atom? It makes sense in the comics since he shrinks but didn't really make any sense here. I did love that Cisco asked him if he was tied to that name.
And please kill Iris (for drama or whatever) and bring Felicity on this show. I love her character.
Oh, and Barry secret identity is getting as bad as the Spider-Man movies. Why wear a mask anymore? Soon everyone will know his secret identity. Guess they are going to lock the bee villain away so she can't tell anyone now either. It's starting to feel like all of his enemies and friends (and acquaintances) know that The Flash is Barry...except Iris. (At least they acknowledged this with a funny line in this episode.)
Minor criticisms but my family and I are loving this show. Other than Face-Off, this is my kid's favorite show on TV and also probably my wife's second favorite which is really saying something. I feel they are doing the story build-up on the Wells confrontation really well.
And please kill Iris (for drama or whatever) and bring Felicity on this show. I love her character.
Oh, and Barry secret identity is getting as bad as the Spider-Man movies. Why wear a mask anymore? Soon everyone will know his secret identity. Guess they are going to lock the bee villain away so she can't tell anyone now either. It's starting to feel like all of his enemies and friends (and acquaintances) know that The Flash is Barry...except Iris. (At least they acknowledged this with a funny line in this episode.)
Minor criticisms but my family and I are loving this show. Other than Face-Off, this is my kid's favorite show on TV and also probably my wife's second favorite which is really saying something. I feel they are doing the story build-up on the Wells confrontation really well.
#57
Banned
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
I don't watch Green Arrow so all this Atom stuff is new to me. Was it said on Green Arrow why he decided to call himself The Atom? It makes sense in the comics since he shrinks but didn't really make any sense here. I did love that Cisco asked him if he was tied to that name.
#58
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
With how fast they are advancing the story, I tend to agree. She'll find out in the finale. An alternate flashback sounds like the perfect way to do it too.
#59
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Bartertown due to it having a better economy than where I really live.
Posts: 29,834
Received 18 Likes
on
12 Posts
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
the opening with them catching a whole ton of regular criminals was pretty good fun, as was the "it's a bird it's a plane" thing
#60
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
Did everyone who's complaining about Atom not shrinking miss the gigantic anvil of foreshadowing that crashed down when he held up the bee at the end? It's totally coming. Give the man a second to work out the tech. The suit barely works as it is.
#61
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Flash (S1E18) -- "All-Star Team-Up" -- 4/14/15
My complaint with the Atom is that he's proven he's an incompetent fighter at best. Both shows have let Oliver and Barry almost immediately accept any yahoo that shows up wanting to fight crime.