Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
#51
Banned by request
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
I'm through episode six right now and I am loving this show. Really well crafted, and they do a great job of differentiating the clones. Tatiana Maslany is incredibly talented. Not only does she make each clone feel distinct, but you can tell when she's acting as one clone pretending to be another clone. That takes skill.
#52
DVD Talk Hero
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
God dammit! I did not see that coming with Kira. I literally jumped with shock!
I can't believe there's only two episodes left. All the pieces and players are being utilized masterfully. Nothing seems extraneous yet.
Tatiana definitely deserves an Emmy nomination at the very least for her work. It's incredible.
I can't believe there's only two episodes left. All the pieces and players are being utilized masterfully. Nothing seems extraneous yet.
Tatiana definitely deserves an Emmy nomination at the very least for her work. It's incredible.
#53
DVD Talk God
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Caught up with the last 3 episodes. Such a good new show.
Shocked at the end when Sarah's daughter got hit by the car.
Okay what is up with the dude who had the tail? What is he supposed to be? Obviously he knows a little too much about the conspiracy that's why the Asian guy poisoned him.
I don't think Tatiana could win an Emmy since this is a Canadian production. I agree her work has been amazing. The Allison character cracks me up.
Shocked at the end when Sarah's daughter got hit by the car.
Okay what is up with the dude who had the tail? What is he supposed to be? Obviously he knows a little too much about the conspiracy that's why the Asian guy poisoned him.
I don't think Tatiana could win an Emmy since this is a Canadian production. I agree her work has been amazing. The Allison character cracks me up.
#54
DVD Talk God
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Alright this bugged the shit out of me.
When Cosima made out and had sex with that blonde grad student who is a spy.
I know a lot of shows do it, but who the hell lies in bed fully clothed in their underwear or lingerie after having sex?
That kiss was pretty hot though.
When Cosima made out and had sex with that blonde grad student who is a spy.
I know a lot of shows do it, but who the hell lies in bed fully clothed in their underwear or lingerie after having sex?
That kiss was pretty hot though.
#55
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 304
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Orphan Black is a BBC America/Space co-production, so it should be eligible for the Emmys. The actual company doing the producing is Temple Street, which is Canadian, but BBC America is putting up half the money to make the series.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
http://www.emmys.tv/sites/emmys.tv/f...roced_rev6.pdf
Foreign television production is ineligible unless it is the result of a co-production (both financially and creatively) between U.S. and foreign partners, which precedes the start of production, and has a commitment to be shown on U.S. television prior to the start of production.
#57
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 1,158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Anyway, this is definitely one of my favorite shows..it's outstanding. Really came out of nowhere for me.. I'd never heard of it until after a few episodes had aired.
#58
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Terrific episode last night! A lot of things came to a head--it could have been the season ender, but we've got one more week to go. Tatiana Maslany continues to shine.
Alison and Felix make a fun pair. She's so uptight and he's so not.
So the jig is up on "Beth." It'll be interesting to see how that shakes out for Sarah.
Are we buying that Delphine has really fallen for and wants to help Cosima? Or is it just more manipulation?
The mysterious woman on the phone (with Leekie? I forget)... [just speculation in the spoiler]
Can't wait for next week!
Alison and Felix make a fun pair. She's so uptight and he's so not.
So the jig is up on "Beth." It'll be interesting to see how that shakes out for Sarah.
Are we buying that Delphine has really fallen for and wants to help Cosima? Or is it just more manipulation?
The mysterious woman on the phone (with Leekie? I forget)... [just speculation in the spoiler]
Spoiler:
Can't wait for next week!
#59
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Terrific episode last night! A lot of things came to a head--it could have been the season ender, but we've got one more week to go. Tatiana Maslany continues to shine.
Alison and Felix make a fun pair. She's so uptight and he's so not.
So the jig is up on "Beth." It'll be interesting to see how that shakes out for Sarah.
Are we buying that Delphine has really fallen for and wants to help Cosima? Or is it just more manipulation?
The mysterious woman on the phone (with Leekie? I forget)... [just speculation in the spoiler]
Can't wait for next week!
Alison and Felix make a fun pair. She's so uptight and he's so not.
So the jig is up on "Beth." It'll be interesting to see how that shakes out for Sarah.
Are we buying that Delphine has really fallen for and wants to help Cosima? Or is it just more manipulation?
The mysterious woman on the phone (with Leekie? I forget)... [just speculation in the spoiler]
Spoiler:
Can't wait for next week!
i wonder if Helena can have kids, or Sarah really is an anomaly. Who would volunteer to find out? Perhaps lull her into docile-ness by giving her some jello or a muffin, and then plowing away.
god i wish the season were longer.
#61
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Anywhere I can stream this? My cable system doesn't have BBC America and I have no desire to watch it hunkered over a PC. I've heard hulu has it but can't find it.
#62
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00D0K0UPW/
Hulu may have it in certain markets, but not in the US.
I doubt you'll see it on Netflix or Amazon Prime anytime soon. For one, BBC America will want to rerun it. They'll also want to sell the season set on DVD/Blu-ray, coming out July 16:
http://www.amazon.com/Orphan-Black-S...dp/B00BVMXBVG/
The BBCA show Copper just showed up recently on Netflix, likely due to the new season starting up soon. I expect Orphan Black to follow something similar, so it'll show up on the unlimited streaming services a month or so before the new season starts on BBCA.
#63
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
I thought the odd thing on the ultrasound was that Kira was (mostly) unharmed. There doesn't seem to be any indication at this point that the ER doctor knew anything else. It's not like the conspiracy could've planned for an ER doctor to be there when Kira comes in, since they didn't know she'd be hit by a car, and they don't know about Kira yet anyway.
#64
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
Posts: 795
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#65
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Wow. I've been behind and had to play 3 episode catch up.
So many elements from the season are coming to a head. I can't believe there is only 1 epIsolde left.
I also saw something rectangular on the ER image with regard to Kira. The nurse was even shocked. Maybe an enchancement of some sort? I guess if it was anything more complex they would have kept her. I was expecting the cops to show up.
I think the French lady does actually have feelings for Cosima. You could see how hesitant she was in the limo scene with the doctor. Plus, from the viewers standpoint she didn't tell him anything about Kira.
Would really like to know who Alison's monitor is. I'd say Donnie, but perhaps somebody less obvious.
Didn't Felix have he druggie boyfriend come down to ID "Sarah" at he morgue. I wonder why hey went to Felix.
Maybe the clones are clones of a clone? If the mystery lady is the original though, shouldn't we expect her to be at least 20 years older?
I don't think the Helena / Sarah "reveal" is a huge deal unless only 1 egg was implanted.
Do we think the doctor knew about the twins? On he one hand he referred to Helana as his while whale. However, he also seemed to imply that he knew who Sarah was; yet she didn't have a monitor.
So many elements from the season are coming to a head. I can't believe there is only 1 epIsolde left.
I also saw something rectangular on the ER image with regard to Kira. The nurse was even shocked. Maybe an enchancement of some sort? I guess if it was anything more complex they would have kept her. I was expecting the cops to show up.
I think the French lady does actually have feelings for Cosima. You could see how hesitant she was in the limo scene with the doctor. Plus, from the viewers standpoint she didn't tell him anything about Kira.
Would really like to know who Alison's monitor is. I'd say Donnie, but perhaps somebody less obvious.
Didn't Felix have he druggie boyfriend come down to ID "Sarah" at he morgue. I wonder why hey went to Felix.
Maybe the clones are clones of a clone? If the mystery lady is the original though, shouldn't we expect her to be at least 20 years older?
I don't think the Helena / Sarah "reveal" is a huge deal unless only 1 egg was implanted.
Do we think the doctor knew about the twins? On he one hand he referred to Helana as his while whale. However, he also seemed to imply that he knew who Sarah was; yet she didn't have a monitor.
#66
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Something brought up by the appearance of Sarah's birth mother was that she said that the couple she was carrying Sarah for weren't a real couple. A previous episode mentioned that all the other known clones were the children of parents that used in vitro fertilization (IVF). At the time I figured the clone group had swapped out the clone embryos with unsuspecting couples, but now it seems possible that some of the clones parents may have been "in" on the plot. We haven't seen Beth, Cosima, or Alison's parents yet.
I don't think the Helena / Sarah "reveal" is a huge deal unless only 1 egg was implanted.
Do we think the doctor knew about the twins? On he one hand he referred to Helana as his while whale. However, he also seemed to imply that he knew who Sarah was; yet she didn't have a monitor.
Do we think the doctor knew about the twins? On he one hand he referred to Helana as his while whale. However, he also seemed to imply that he knew who Sarah was; yet she didn't have a monitor.
Depending on when Sarah's mother fled, it's possible the group didn't know she was carrying twins. When they learned about Helena, it's possible they thought they knew about all the clones. So the fact that they're twins could explain how Sarah managed to be off their radar for so long.
Also, Helena has said before that she felt a special connection to Sarah, which is why she didn't kill Sarah on sight. Being twins possibly explains this connection, due to developing in the same womb.
What's interesting is that IVF has a higher percentage of twins than conception by normal methods, around 20-40% of pregnancies.
Last edited by Jay G.; 05-28-13 at 10:32 AM.
#67
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
FYI- they are doing an all out marathon on BBCA this Saturday, which it turns out my service does have. Set to DVR all and looking forward to them.
#68
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
It might have been the last episode, but did anybody else catch allusions to others orphaned "in the black"? Ms S made it sound like those were under the radar adoptions and others beyond Sarah were involved. I took that to mean there are possibly other clone lines out there.
Also mentioned by somebody about the "situation" gettin worse in Europe.
Also mentioned by somebody about the "situation" gettin worse in Europe.
#69
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2003
Posts: 795
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
This show has a big hole in it, in my opinion. Who taught Helena to be a sniper? Not the priest, certainly. Everything about her screams street fighter, not trained killer. So how was she supposed to have made that ~300 yard shot across the river?
#70
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
It might have been the last episode, but did anybody else catch allusions to others orphaned "in the black"? Ms S made it sound like those were under the radar adoptions and others beyond Sarah were involved. I took that to mean there are possibly other clone lines out there.
I thought that meant that the European clones were getting assassinated.
This show has a big hole in it, in my opinion. Who taught Helena to be a sniper? Not the priest, certainly. Everything about her screams street fighter, not trained killer. So how was she supposed to have made that ~300 yard shot across the river?
This show has a big hole in it, in my opinion. Who taught Helena to be a sniper? Not the priest, certainly. Everything about her screams street fighter, not trained killer. So how was she supposed to have made that ~300 yard shot across the river?
#71
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Well I meant other type clones not in the Sarah/Beth/Alison/etc line. Like another line that is also undergoing observation. However, I see your broader point about regular non-clone orphans as well.
Still, between the two comments I infered there is more clone story out there. I mean if hey went to all this trouble of creating the experiment, you think they'd have others for redundancy.
Re: Thomas - we know he's part of an organization. Maggie who Beth killed was part of it as well. I think they have religious origins, but doesn't mean they are same as the cogent she was dropped off at. How would they unravel the mystery anyway?
Still, between the two comments I infered there is more clone story out there. I mean if hey went to all this trouble of creating the experiment, you think they'd have others for redundancy.
Re: Thomas - we know he's part of an organization. Maggie who Beth killed was part of it as well. I think they have religious origins, but doesn't mean they are same as the cogent she was dropped off at. How would they unravel the mystery anyway?
#72
DVD Talk Hero
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
I thought that meant that the European clones were getting assassinated.
This show has a big hole in it, in my opinion. Who taught Helena to be a sniper? Not the priest, certainly. Everything about her screams street fighter, not trained killer. So how was she supposed to have made that ~300 yard shot across the river?
This show has a big hole in it, in my opinion. Who taught Helena to be a sniper? Not the priest, certainly. Everything about her screams street fighter, not trained killer. So how was she supposed to have made that ~300 yard shot across the river?
Helena does seem to be a little too flaky to be a proficient sniper, though. That's a discipline that requires a lot of practice and training, and Helena doesn't seem like she's capable of making a pot of coffee.
#73
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
Well I meant other type clones not in the Sarah/Beth/Alison/etc line. Like another line that is also undergoing observation. However, I see your broader point about regular non-clone orphans as well.
Still, between the two comments I [inferred] there is more clone story out there. I mean if hey went to all this trouble of creating the experiment, you think they'd have others for redundancy.
Still, between the two comments I [inferred] there is more clone story out there. I mean if hey went to all this trouble of creating the experiment, you think they'd have others for redundancy.
To be fair, we haven't seen Helena at the top of her game. As soon as we found out her identity, she'd been stabbed by Sarah, so was recuperating from that. Also, the special link she felt with Sarah has apparently destabilized her worldview. That said, Leekie has described her as "feral," so she may have always been a bit unstable.
#74
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Thread Starter
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
I think we are in agreement about Thomas' organization.
However, I'm still open to the idea there could be other clone lines out there.
However, I'm still open to the idea there could be other clone lines out there.
#75
DVD Talk Legend
re: Orphan Black -- Season 1 Thread -- BBC America
It's possible, but I don't think the dialogue so far was implying it. From a narrative standpoint, revealing additional clone lines would just muddy the waters, so I hope they don't go there.