The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
#51
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,324
Received 1,824 Likes
on
1,134 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Daryl really killed Zombie-Merle in the harshest, hardest way possible. Hands-on killing is always more difficult, but when the zombie is in the physical form of your own brother, how can you have the nerve to stab it repeatedly in the face? Very hard. An arrow to the head from a distance would have been easier, but Daryl, of course, didn't have the range or the time to do that, so this is going to haunt him for a long, long time.
him that way.
Earlier in the episode, when Daryl said to Merle, "I'm waiting to have my brother back," I don't think Daryl ever had a "nice" Merle as a brother. He always had a drug-addicted asshole brother, so what kind of brother was he waiting to get back, exactly?
The brother who killed off top Governor guys and sacrificed his life for the Prison Group is not Daryl's brother returned. So far as I was able to ascertain, a complete stranger did it in the guise of Merle Dixon.
#52
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Great episode, one thing that always gets me about the prison is that they let the zombies just hang out by the fence. No way I would let those zombies accumulate, get them over to the fence and poke a sharp stick through the eye. Then when the gov does attack they only need to worry about he ones that gov brings and not the rest that are just hanging around the jail.
#53
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
One question about actor Michael Rooker - he was the only established movie star (aside from Scott Wilson) in the whole cast. When I first saw him in Season One, I figured he cut his salary demands in half or something, as he's the only really famous person on this show.
And speaking of poor Scott Wilson, what the hell does it take to get your name in the opening credits of the show?!
And speaking of poor Scott Wilson, what the hell does it take to get your name in the opening credits of the show?!
#54
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 3,107
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Great episode, one thing that always gets me about the prison is that they let the zombies just hang out by the fence. No way I would let those zombies accumulate, get them over to the fence and poke a sharp stick through the eye. Then when the gov does attack they only need to worry about he ones that gov brings and not the rest that are just hanging around the jail.
#55
Banned
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 3,503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Great episode, one thing that always gets me about the prison is that they let the zombies just hang out by the fence. No way I would let those zombies accumulate, get them over to the fence and poke a sharp stick through the eye. Then when the gov does attack they only need to worry about he ones that gov brings and not the rest that are just hanging around the jail.
They clearly don't just "let them hang out" by the fence, or there would be thousands of fucking zombies there by now.
Last edited by Dragon Tattoo; 03-25-13 at 10:52 AM.
#56
Senior Member
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
What? No comment about Merle taking Rick's telephone? It is so OBVIOUS that the ghost of Lori has used it to drive Rick crazy, and she did the same to Merle making him essentially go on a suicide mission.
Thos.
Thos.
#57
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 2,134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Also, great episode. The bits with Michonne and Merle were so good; Merle's chance at redemption was nice, and the governor is a full bore nut job biting off his fingers like that.
I think Daryl was going to kill Merle anyway since he'd taken Michonne and he knew what Merle had done to Maggie and Glenn. The way it was done, though, was so much more dramatic. As someone mentioned, it makes more sense that he'd stab him since most "crimes of passion" are done in close proximity to the victim.
#58
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: May 2002
Posts: 2,669
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Rick should have consulted with Merle. Merle took down a bunch of Governor's group all by himself, imagine if he could plan and coordinate his attacks.
#60
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,297
Received 373 Likes
on
267 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
One question about actor Michael Rooker - he was the only established movie star (aside from Scott Wilson) in the whole cast. When I first saw him in Season One, I figured he cut his salary demands in half or something, as he's the only really famous person on this show.
But no one was going to see that, Mississippi Burning, JFK or Days of Thunder because it was "The New Michael Rooker flick."
He's a fine actor, but not a movie star (not many actors are). My guess is one of the co-stars of "Super Capers" wasn't too far out of The Walking Dead's price range.
I wonder if Daryl collected his arrows after killing Merle?
#61
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
"Established movie star" might be stretching things. There was "Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer," but it's not like that was a big hit or was embraced by general audiences. Look at the last decade of his career: There was Slither and Jumper (in which he was like 7th billed) then a lot of direct-to-DVD stuff like The Marine 2. Tombstone in 1993 was probably his last real box office success.
But no one was going to see that, Mississippi Burning, JFK or Days of Thunder because it was "The New Michael Rooker flick."
He's a fine actor, but not a movie star (not many actors are). My guess is one of the co-stars of "Super Capers" wasn't too far out of The Walking Dead's price range.
I wonder if Daryl collected his arrows after killing Merle?
But no one was going to see that, Mississippi Burning, JFK or Days of Thunder because it was "The New Michael Rooker flick."
He's a fine actor, but not a movie star (not many actors are). My guess is one of the co-stars of "Super Capers" wasn't too far out of The Walking Dead's price range.
I wonder if Daryl collected his arrows after killing Merle?
No, because Daryl used a knife on his zombie-brother.
#63
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#64
Admin
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
"Established movie star" might be stretching things. There was "Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer," but it's not like that was a big hit or was embraced by general audiences. Look at the last decade of his career: There was Slither and Jumper (in which he was like 7th billed) then a lot of direct-to-DVD stuff like The Marine 2. Tombstone in 1993 was probably his last real box office success.
But no one was going to see that, Mississippi Burning, JFK or Days of Thunder because it was "The New Michael Rooker flick."
He's a fine actor, but not a movie star (not many actors are). My guess is one of the co-stars of "Super Capers" wasn't too far out of The Walking Dead's price range.
I wonder if Daryl collected his arrows after killing Merle?
But no one was going to see that, Mississippi Burning, JFK or Days of Thunder because it was "The New Michael Rooker flick."
He's a fine actor, but not a movie star (not many actors are). My guess is one of the co-stars of "Super Capers" wasn't too far out of The Walking Dead's price range.
I wonder if Daryl collected his arrows after killing Merle?
#65
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
While I thought it was an improvement over the last couple weeks which were terrible, I thought they really squandered an opportunity to really surprise the audience. I thought it would have been a far better episode if Merle able to kill the Governor but that led to an immediate attack on the prison. I guess the writers really want us to see the inevitable Glenn vs Governor one on one <---specualation
Last edited by johnnysd; 03-26-13 at 12:47 AM.
#66
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
#67
Admin
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
It's a First Person Shooter video game reference. People who sit behind cover and pick off people who try to move around are "campers" That combined with the fact the Rooker was a prominent character in the last two Call of Duty video games made it funny...to me at least.
#69
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Sorry, the fact that he even entertained the idea is enough. So he balked today, what stops him tomorrow? A quaint little rallying speech? What if he decides to just hand over someone else "for the sake of the group?" No, he's just as fucked up as Merle, which he alluded to. Do you think Rick would let anyone even entertain the thought of someone turning over Carl "for the sake of the group?" Fuck no, they'd be out of that prison/or dead before the end credits roll. So Rick gets a pass because of some cheesy speech.
#71
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Sorry, the fact that he even entertained the idea is enough. So he balked today, what stops him tomorrow? A quaint little rallying speech? What if he decides to just hand over someone else "for the sake of the group?" No, he's just as fucked up as Merle, which he alluded to. Do you think Rick would let anyone even entertain the thought of someone turning over Carl "for the sake of the group?" Fuck no, they'd be out of that prison/or dead before the end credits roll. So Rick gets a pass because of some cheesy speech.
If I showed up at your house, and the Governor came to you and said, "hand over Buttmunker, or else I wipe out your whole family?" You gonna stand and fight for me? I don't think so!
#72
Admin
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
I had a hunch they would have Merle go out a hero. I'm glad that they did. Talking Dead was fun last night with The Governor and Merle on at the same time. Rooker went into character a couple of times during the interview which was funny.
#73
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as Groucho AND Bandoman/Death Moans, Iowa
Posts: 18,297
Received 373 Likes
on
267 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
Ease up. Michonne is no Carl. Rick was going to throw her out eventually anyway, and she was never a part of the group. It was an "easy sacrifice," in light of the people Rick cared about, vs Michonne, who was a newcomer, and not worth the fight.
If I showed up at your house, and the Governor came to you and said, "hand over Buttmunker, or else I wipe out your whole family?" You gonna stand and fight for me? I don't think so!
If I showed up at your house, and the Governor came to you and said, "hand over Buttmunker, or else I wipe out your whole family?" You gonna stand and fight for me? I don't think so!
#74
Banned
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 3,503
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Walking Dead -- "This Sorrowful Life" -- 3/24/13
The very fact that he gave up his solo-leader power for a more democratic way of governing? Did you miss parts of this episode?
The fact that you even attempt to equate Michonne to Carl is mind-boggling. No one else in that group (including Michonne) would do that. She was a stranger who has only been with them for a month at most.
The fact that you even attempt to equate Michonne to Carl is mind-boggling. No one else in that group (including Michonne) would do that. She was a stranger who has only been with them for a month at most.
#75
DVD Talk Legend