DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Watching X-Files for the first time... Anyone else? Discuss! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/510988-watching-x-files-first-time-anyone-else-discuss.html)

GenPion 01-23-08 03:47 PM

I purchased Season One and Two recently. I'd never seen the show before. Well, I watched the entire first season... and I thought it was just okay. Honestly, there were some stand-out episodes, but a lot of them were pretty weak IMHO. I'm already about eight episodes into season two though and I'd say it's picking up and starting to get more interesting. Hopefully the series is as good as everyone says it is Seasons 3 to 5 (or 6... depending on who you ask). That will make watching these earlier seasons worthwhile.

7Keys 01-23-08 06:59 PM


Originally Posted by GenPion
I purchased Season One and Two recently. I'd never seen the show before. Well, I watched the entire first season... and I thought it was just okay. Honestly, there were some stand-out episodes, but a lot of them were pretty weak IMHO. I'm already about eight episodes into season two though and I'd say it's picking up and starting to get more interesting. Hopefully the series is as good as everyone says it is Seasons 3 to 5 (or 6... depending on who you ask). That will make watching these earlier seasons worthwhile.

I think they're were a lot of great episodes from 1 & 2, but it did get better starting with Season 3. And I think Season 6 has really good stand alone episodes.

Bluelitespecial 01-24-08 01:48 PM


Originally Posted by Ravenous
Well Im ressurecting this cause I just started season 4 and I just saw the episode 'HOME'

That was one FUCKED up episode. But awesome!

The only episode to ever have a TV-MA rating, and then never aired in syndication I believe.

tommyp007 01-24-08 02:22 PM

As a firm fan of this show, I will agree that seasons 1-6 were the best, but there are great shows all the way to the end. Watch it all.

cardaway 01-24-08 02:25 PM


Originally Posted by Bluelitespecial
The only episode to ever have a TV-MA rating, and then never aired in syndication I believe.

Does FX count as sydication? I'm sure I saw it again on TV in the last couple years and it might have been on FX.

Great episode and I always wondered what the big deal was as far as not showing it again. There were far worse scares and subjects during other one off episodes, but Home gets all the attention. In fact, there are things shown during many episodes of CSI that are far worse than the gore and subject matter of Home.

rfduncan 01-24-08 04:02 PM


Originally Posted by cardaway

Originally Posted by Bluelitespecial
The only episode to ever have a TV-MA rating, and then never aired in syndication I believe.

Does FX count as sydication? I'm sure I saw it again on TV in the last couple years and it might have been on FX.

Great episode and I always wondered what the big deal was as far as not showing it again. There were far worse scares and subjects during other one off episodes, but Home gets all the attention. In fact, there are things shown during many episodes of CSI that are far worse than the gore and subject matter of Home.

You're both sorta correct:

Originally Posted by Wikipedia
After its original airing, Fox Network chose not to air the episode again due to the disturbing theme. It was re-aired only once, on October 31, 1999 as a special Halloween showing. On its re-airing, it featured a TV-MA rating, the only X-Files episode to be rated as such.

FOX started rating their live action programming in 1997 much after the original 10/11/96 broadcast.

cardaway 01-24-08 04:27 PM


Originally Posted by rfduncan
You're both sorta correct:

FOX started rating their live action programming in 1997 much after the original 10/11/96 broadcast.

Another case of Wiki being wrong. It's been on TV again in the last few years (2004 +). As I posted earlier, probably as part of a viewers choice X-Files marathon on FX.

dhmac 01-24-08 04:59 PM


Originally Posted by tommyp007
As a firm fan of this show, I will agree that seasons 1-6 were the best, but there are great shows all the way to the end. Watch it all.

In Seasons 7 and 8, I agree that there were some great episode. But Season 9... no, not at all. IMO, there was not a single great episode in that entire season (but there were quite a few bad ones).

Can anyone honestly name a single great episode (not just good or merely ok, but GREAT!) in Season 9?

Sweet Baby James 01-24-08 05:03 PM


Originally Posted by 7Keys
Rat or not, Krychek was probably my favorite character on the show.

Only second to the CSM(cigarette smoking man).:)

xmiyux 01-24-08 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by Sweet Baby James
Only second to the CSM(cigarette smoking man).:)

Agreed. Musings of the CSM was the best X-Files episode.

Michael Corvin 01-24-08 06:09 PM


Originally Posted by cardaway
Another case of Wiki being wrong. It's been on TV again in the last few years (2004 +). As I posted earlier, probably as part of a viewers choice X-Files marathon on FX.

No, it's correct. FOX NETWORK has only aired it twice, the original broadcast and the Halloween special. FX can air it to it's hearts content, and usually do during those "fan favorite" days. They're owned by the same company but there are in fact different channels. ;)

cardaway 01-24-08 06:19 PM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
No, it's correct. FOX NETWORK has only aired it twice, the original broadcast and the Halloween special.

I didn't read it as pertaining to only the original Fox network, but rather it saying it hasn't aired on TV since. I see the connection now.

Ravenous 01-25-08 01:18 PM


Originally Posted by xmiyux
Agreed. Musings of the CSM was the best X-Files episode.

Saw that one a few nights ago and it was awesome! I think what I LOVE about the show is I remember Smoking Man being a big character. When I got the sets and saw the pilot, he was already there. So he wasnt like added in for suspense, he was always there. Cool detail I thought.

Thanks to everyone keeping everything in Spoilers. Im only on season 4 so Id hate to read somehting I havent seen yet!

cardaway 01-25-08 01:38 PM


Originally Posted by Ravenous
Saw that one a few nights ago and it was awesome! I think what I LOVE about the show is I remember Smoking Man being a big character. When I got the sets and saw the pilot, he was already there. So he wasnt like added in for suspense, he was always there. Cool detail I thought.

Prepare then to be blown away on how much his character fits in before it's all said and done. Defiantely one of the high points fo the show overall.

rfduncan 01-25-08 01:43 PM

Favorite part of S6:


Originally Posted by Agent Scully
Oh... oh my God. They're back!

I thought "4-D" in S9 was pretty cool as was "Audrey Pauley" and "Sunshine Days". I think a lot of people were just so damned blinded by the essential replacement of Mulder and Scully that they let that cloud the quality of those final episodes. Once Reyes and Doggett hit their stride, they are more than ample replacements (inverse since Doggett is the skeptic). The writers just took too long getting there trying to work all three into the storylines when they should have been bonding a duo.

I didn't realize the next X-Files was already filming!

Michael Corvin 01-25-08 02:39 PM


Originally Posted by rfduncan
Favorite part of S6:



I thought "4-D" in S9 was pretty cool as was "Audrey Pauley" and "Sunshine Days". I think a lot of people were just so damned blinded by the essential replacement of Mulder and Scully that they let that cloud the quality of those final episodes. Once Reyes and Doggett hit their stride, they are more than ample replacements (inverse since Doggett is the skeptic). The writers just took too long getting there trying to work all three into the storylines when they should have been bonding a duo.

I didn't realize the next X-Files was already filming!

I think Carter has gone on record saying he tried to convince Fox to turn the X-files into a spin-off once Duchovney left but they wouldn't have any part of it. Hand off the reigns to Dogget and Reyes and you have a new series isntead of dragging down the parent show. This was before all the CSI, Buffy, and L&O spin-offs. I bet they wouldn't hesitate if the show was on today.

Nick Danger 01-25-08 10:09 PM

We're watching the series sets. I've seen them all before, but Mrs Danger had only seen a couple of episodes. I only bought 1-6, and I only got season 6 because I think it had a few glowing embers of a once-great program. But it's pretty clear that the writing staff, the producers, the directors, and the stars are getting tired.

Robert Patrick really tried hard, and I liked his work, but he didn't have enough help.

Anyway, we just watched the first episode of Season 5. Mrs Danger is still enjoying it! Woo hoo!

Tommy Ceez 01-25-08 10:35 PM

I dont want to start a seperate thread...

Is anyone here excited about JJ Abrams X-Files rip-off FRINGE?

Mercury&Solace 01-26-08 03:11 AM

I just finished S3 and in the middle of S4.
Loved it for the most part, though some of the episodes I really didn't care for.
But the great ones make up for it.

dhmac 01-26-08 09:41 AM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
I think Carter has gone on record saying he tried to convince Fox to turn the X-files into a spin-off once Duchovny left but they wouldn't have any part of it. Hand off the reigns to Doggett and Reyes and you have a new series instead of dragging down the parent show. This was before all the CSI, Buffy, and L&O spin-offs. I bet they wouldn't hesitate if the show was on today.

My nickname for Season 9 is The X-Files: R.F.D. because it is more like a spin-off instead of like the earlier seasons of the show (in which "one man's crusade" was a very central theme).




(P.S. if you don't get the reference, it's to Mayberry R.F.D., the spinoff continuation of the Andy Griffith Show)

JesseCuster 01-28-08 01:05 AM

The show through season 6, IMHO, is top flight. I've never been a huge fan of season 1. Everyone was still finding their rythyms and Gillian Anderson was not only radically different looking than she would look through the rest of the series, I got the sense she was struggling a little as an actress to find her characters voice and place in the show. Not sure if I've ever seen an actor improve as dramatically over the course of a series as her. She went from feh! in the first season to stunningly good by the end. Her work since X-Files has been pretty freaking impressive though I think she still struggles to find roles due to typecasting.

rfduncan 01-29-08 07:55 AM


Originally Posted by JesseCuster
Gillian Anderson was not only radically different looking than she would look through the rest of the series, I got the sense she was struggling a little as an actress to find her characters voice and place in the show. Not sure if I've ever seen an actor improve as dramatically over the course of a series as her. She went from feh! in the first season to stunningly good by the end.

In truth, she was a very green actress when the show first filmed (she was 24). I have to agree that she'd never have been able to pull off The House of Mirth without the substantial acting development she culled from working on X-Files.

superdeluxe 01-29-08 09:59 AM

Anyone ever go to those X-Files conventions? Or was I the only geek in here heh.

xfilefanfreak 01-29-08 10:12 AM

I whent had a great time .i still have x-files stuff lotts of it

Michael Corvin 01-29-08 10:34 AM


Originally Posted by superdeluxe
Anyone ever go to those X-Files conventions? Or was I the only geek in here heh.

They always seem to be the same weekend as the Fresh Prince ones. Sorry but the Prince wins out.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:29 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.