HGTV Design Star Discussion Thread
#26
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Goldberg74
This show lost the HOT and the SPARKLE all in the same episode... how sad. 


These double elimination shows are real downers. I cannot believe that we are already down to the Final Four.
#27
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by Goldberg74
This show lost the HOT and the SPARKLE all in the same episode... how sad. 

#28
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
I am so glad that Robb got his show cancelled. He could not have been a bigger prick if he had tried. I was really hoping for his carpenter to tell him that he's an asshole. I would have to say that it's Todd's competiton to lose. He has actually started to grow on me.
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Agree completely. It is todd's to lose. I wouldn't mind seeing Will against Todd for the final, but I'm sure it'll be boy v girl..
I am glad Robb got booted as he was a clear jackass.
And again the tiling didn't get done properly, but the Kitchen was a way harder space, having said that they didn't really do anything drastic with it that other people couldn't figure out
New counter tops, new appliances, a table and chairs! magic.
I am glad Robb got booted as he was a clear jackass.
And again the tiling didn't get done properly, but the Kitchen was a way harder space, having said that they didn't really do anything drastic with it that other people couldn't figure out
New counter tops, new appliances, a table and chairs! magic.
#30
Moderator
Bye Robb. 
The judges didn't make a mistake.
Go Todd!
Design High Five!... uh, wrong show.

The judges didn't make a mistake.
Go Todd!
Design High Five!... uh, wrong show.
#31
Moderator
Will's gone... but he was very gracious about it. He knows that he's good at design, but sucks as a host.
It's down to Kim and the "Design" Todd.
I'm cool with either of them winning.
Until next week America!
It's down to Kim and the "Design" Todd.
I'm cool with either of them winning.
Until next week America!
#33
DVD Talk Legend
Agree, I'd be happy with either winning, Kim was a natural in front of the camera.
The coal miners wife was hot in that middle of nowhere hot chick way.
I think I liked Will's room the best, then Todd's then Kims.
but that's just personal taste. Kim did really well in giving them what they wanted and not pushing her taste on the folsk.
The coal miners wife was hot in that middle of nowhere hot chick way.
I think I liked Will's room the best, then Todd's then Kims.
but that's just personal taste. Kim did really well in giving them what they wanted and not pushing her taste on the folsk.
#34
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
doesnt anyone else begin wretching violently whenever todd starts talking? whatever talent he has (and i do admit the guy has talent and a creative streak with refreshing "newness" that HGTV probably needs) is abolished by his annoying surfer dude attitude. it makes me wish he were in a soap opera so he could age 15 years in one season. each time he talks, i feel like i am stuck in a bill and ted's excellent adventure marathon and cant escape. sigh... bastard is probably going to win, too
#35
DVD Talk Legend
I thought so till this week. but the public might go Kim
#36
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
i dont know. kim is very likeable and professional, but i think a lot of people will find todd's style and originality uplifting enough to vote. and, although i find him positively revolting, i am sure that a lot of female viewers find him attractive. hopefully their vaginas dont learn how to vote
#38
DVD Talk Legend
Ha. his shtick is getting a little old okay. But he's from SF, so I have to root for him.
I really enjoy this show a lot.
I really enjoy this show a lot.
#39
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
My vote goes to Kim. I thought her room was far better than Todd's this week and her mic skills were also better. I also thought that Vern did a nice job in his first show(Deserving Design). And Cynthia is a little too old to be wearing such hot pants!
#40
DVD Talk Legend
Also liked Kim's room overall. Good show, i prefered the empty box finale from last year though.
#41
DVD Talk Legend
Todd had it in the bag, until I created that really lame final room...
#42
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
And so ends another reality based competition. Congrats to Kim. I'm glad that you were able to beat out Todd, but I won't make a point to watch your upcoming show.
Todd blew it with that terrible final room, but he does get a Mercury SUV, so he made out just fine.
Todd blew it with that terrible final room, but he does get a Mercury SUV, so he made out just fine.
#43
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I enjoyed this season because they had a really talented bunch. My only complaint is the show didn't last long because they did a double-elimination too many times.




