Smallville -- "Fragile" -- 04/13/06
#27
I'm curious regarding the "freak of the week" hatred. Do/Did people who don't like the FOTW eps read comic books?
I'm sure people don't moan when a new super viilain shows up in every issue of the Superman comic. The whole "meteor freak" thing is clearly a television move to rationalize to non-comic reading tv viewers why Clark's foes have super powers. Personally I think the show should have embraced its roots and just had super powered baddies from the get go. Forget metor exposure, serum, gas, etc. Some people just have powers. Simple as that. Now have at it.
I'm sure people don't moan when a new super viilain shows up in every issue of the Superman comic. The whole "meteor freak" thing is clearly a television move to rationalize to non-comic reading tv viewers why Clark's foes have super powers. Personally I think the show should have embraced its roots and just had super powered baddies from the get go. Forget metor exposure, serum, gas, etc. Some people just have powers. Simple as that. Now have at it.
#28
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,155
Received 897 Likes
on
741 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
I don't necessarily mind FOTW. But Glassman got superpowers because the meteor hit when he was in a stained-glass shop? Give me a break.
So if someone was working in a brewery when the meteor hit, they would have telekinetic power over beer?
So if someone was working in a brewery when the meteor hit, they would have telekinetic power over beer?
#29
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 15,094
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: WAS looking for My Own Private Stuckeyville, but stuck in Liberty City (while missing Vice City)
Originally Posted by ytrez
I'm curious regarding the "freak of the week" hatred. Do/Did people who don't like the FOTW eps read comic books?
I'm sure people don't moan when a new super viilain shows up in every issue of the Superman comic. The whole "meteor freak" thing is clearly a television move to rationalize to non-comic reading tv viewers why Clark's foes have super powers. Personally I think the show should have embraced its roots and just had super powered baddies from the get go. Forget metor exposure, serum, gas, etc. Some people just have powers. Simple as that. Now have at it.
I'm sure people don't moan when a new super viilain shows up in every issue of the Superman comic. The whole "meteor freak" thing is clearly a television move to rationalize to non-comic reading tv viewers why Clark's foes have super powers. Personally I think the show should have embraced its roots and just had super powered baddies from the get go. Forget metor exposure, serum, gas, etc. Some people just have powers. Simple as that. Now have at it.
#30
I think FotW doesn't translate from comic books as well. There is a lot more dialog and it is a weekly series. Especially in todays TV, viewers have come to expect a lot more depth than just a bad guy who gets captured and then someone presses the reset button.
I grew up watching George Reeves play superman and I was an avid Superman comic book fan. I still PVR the shows when they are on. When I look back on it, I realize how simplistic everything was and it frankly cannot hold my attention.
Smallville is not targetted toward young. My guess is (at least this season) they are shooting squarely for the 18-49 demo. The evidence of that would be some of the more provactive scenes that would never ever appear in the comic books or traditional series (ie lois a stripper).
Spend some time with the covers of the comic books at http://www.superdickery.com/dick/1.html and realize how absolutely sophmoric it is. That doesn't mean it isn't great classic fun. I know this will piss off a lot of superman fans, but I am one of them .... At least I am not trashing Buffy
If Smallville was ever that bad it would have been cancelled already. I expect more from this show. I know it is capable of more. It just hasn't delivered much this season.
I grew up watching George Reeves play superman and I was an avid Superman comic book fan. I still PVR the shows when they are on. When I look back on it, I realize how simplistic everything was and it frankly cannot hold my attention.
Smallville is not targetted toward young. My guess is (at least this season) they are shooting squarely for the 18-49 demo. The evidence of that would be some of the more provactive scenes that would never ever appear in the comic books or traditional series (ie lois a stripper).
Spend some time with the covers of the comic books at http://www.superdickery.com/dick/1.html and realize how absolutely sophmoric it is. That doesn't mean it isn't great classic fun. I know this will piss off a lot of superman fans, but I am one of them .... At least I am not trashing Buffy

If Smallville was ever that bad it would have been cancelled already. I expect more from this show. I know it is capable of more. It just hasn't delivered much this season.
#31
DVD Talk Hero
The highlight for me was the nice close-up on Lois and her tasty ass as she rolled over after the car explosion.
I thought this episode was okay - total filler but moved a few plot points along. I'm not too thrilled about Lana and Lex, but I guess I have to resign myself to the fact that having Clark and Lana in a healthy relationship (and her knowing about his powers) is too hard for the writers to handle.
I thought this episode was okay - total filler but moved a few plot points along. I'm not too thrilled about Lana and Lex, but I guess I have to resign myself to the fact that having Clark and Lana in a healthy relationship (and her knowing about his powers) is too hard for the writers to handle.
#32
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Ayre
Smallville is not targetted toward young. My guess is (at least this season) they are shooting squarely for the 18-49 demo.
#34
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Legend
I wasn't impressed with this episode. Actually I haven't been impressed with all of the episodes that have aired after the 100th episode.
I hope things improved before the season finale.
I hope things improved before the season finale.
#36
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,923
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: In the Universe.
I'm pretty much done with this series. This is the first episode I've watched in about 6 weeks and I don't think I'm going to watch another one until the season finale.
What I don't understand is why wouldn't they want to hype the show up so that the movie can piggyback on it's popularity. I mean if the show sucks it's gonna put off some people to see Superman Returns.
What I don't understand is why wouldn't they want to hype the show up so that the movie can piggyback on it's popularity. I mean if the show sucks it's gonna put off some people to see Superman Returns.
#37
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Texas
Originally Posted by Brack
My question is this: how are they going to make the characters not know Clark is Superman once he makes that transition? Lois might be conceited enough not to notice, but I'm pretty sure Lex will recognize him, as well as everyone else who's seen him in the last 5 years.
Well, I haven't seen Superman in a while, but if my memory serves me correct, he was just a young lad when he took of the the Fortress to learn all of his buisness. It took him like 10 years or so to get it all down pat I guess. With Smallville, Clark already knows how to use his powers and he already has the Fortress, maybe he will just go there to learn to master what he has, develop his super breath, sleep for a few years 'cause he spent all of his teen years saving people, and then take off to Metropolis where he will look completely different and turn into Superman. I don't think Smallville will ever get this far, but how else could it go down??
#38
DVD Talk Hero
Well, Clark probably does drop off the map during his years after college (to do his other post-graduate work Kryptonian-style), perhaps 4-5 years, and upon his return to Metropolis, wearing glasses, looking like a mild-mannered reporter, there is a different group of people around him that weren't in his circle of friends back from Smallville. Now, Lois will most likely finally piece it together after a few Superman appearances, but I suspect she would be the only one who knows (besides Pete), as I expect Chloe to bite it before Clark returns to Metropolis.
As to how Lex wouldn't put 2 and 2 together w/r/t Clark/Superman in Metropolis, I guess that's an exercise for the writers to come up with something plausible.
As to how Lex wouldn't put 2 and 2 together w/r/t Clark/Superman in Metropolis, I guess that's an exercise for the writers to come up with something plausible.
#41
DVD Talk God
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 133,155
Received 897 Likes
on
741 Posts
From: Directionally Challenged (for DirecTV)
What's funny is that Michael Rosenbaum has been the highlight of this series. I assume he shaves his head in real life. I really wish they had done the classic story of his baldness in this rendition.
#43
Originally Posted by SuprVgeta
Ewwww... Lana and Lex is gross.
#44
Banned
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 2,249
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Sand Point
Originally Posted by danegger
Well, I haven't seen Superman in a while, but if my memory serves me correct, he was just a young lad when he took of the the Fortress to learn all of his buisness. It took him like 10 years or so to get it all down pat I guess. With Smallville, Clark already knows how to use his powers and he already has the Fortress, maybe he will just go there to learn to master what he has, develop his super breath, sleep for a few years 'cause he spent all of his teen years saving people, and then take off to Metropolis where he will look completely different and turn into Superman. I don't think Smallville will ever get this far, but how else could it go down??

As for what to do about Lex, it's simple: "Clark! You've been hypnotized! That's why you look so much like Superman!"
#45
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I imagine the series ending with Perry returning the favor he 'owes' Clark by giving him a job and Lois bitching because he hasn't earned it 
I can't see any other way to spin it, but I'm sure the writers will come through with something that is pure genius

I can't see any other way to spin it, but I'm sure the writers will come through with something that is pure genius
#46
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by Patman
True, Clark may have to give Lex a nice kiss of forgetfulness to kick in some major amnesia (of their entire history in Smallville).
#47
DVD Talk Hero
"Fragile"
Fra-gee-lay. That must be Italian.
Fra-gee-lay. That must be Italian.
#48
Senior Member
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Texas
Geez, I love Smallville and watch it every week, but this has kind of got me wondering. I kind of wish they would just speed this series up and get to the end so we can all see how it ends up!!!




