I think I agree with Simon about Chris' song - the vocals were not bad, but the song was.

Kellie Pickler should not have been praised like she was....


I hate her.

And Ace..if you just cut your hair...you would be EXTREMELY hot....but sadly you still have nasty carrot-top style hair....gross

Chris....sing some songs people actually know the words to....Innuendo was good and has a great message, but messages are lost on the general American public...as you can see, people are still voting for Kellie, and haven't picked up on the message that she's about as real as Pam Anderson's rack

I can not BELIEVE they didn't eviscerate Pickler - she fucking destroyed that song....simply awful and nauseating. The fix is in.

Am I the only person that doesn't care for McPhee? Her voice isn't bad (she needs to learn how to control that top range better), but her overall attitude reminds me of Brenna. She's hiding a big ego somewhere, and it's starting to show.

no she's not...and regardless, this isn't a hot contest...it's a singing contest. she fucking sucks and destroyed that song.

I think Chris only chose that song because it had the word "Creed" in the lyrics.

Pinkler= post-bad girl makeover Olivia Newton John in Grease

i have the Mcfever...:drool:

but yeah i sense the attitude.....

no, i definitely agree. she irks me. I don't believe half of these contestants are really being themselves, unlike past seasons, especially last season where everyone seemed to really be true and genuine on tv.

Chris, Paris, and Elliot all seem very real, and seems as though that's how they really are in real life.

Taylor could also be real...but I could care less...ha

Simon: "You look amazing"

McMe: "I know, I do"

Yikes. That failed mic kick was a bit uncomfortable.

O.M.G. taylor...Lame...just...lame...

Taylor goes for the mike stand... and muffs it! rotfl

I don't know why they like Taylor

how about we give him....a nice big punch to the face.


THANK YOU SIMON.

SIMON = saving grace.

taylor was definitely better then Kellie and Ace combined...

Simon only said that shit about Taylor to guarantee him votes so he'll move on.

Well, Ace has my vote tonight... to go home.

Ack! Why is Paris dressed like Lil Kim??

I really liked Paris!

I thought she looked more like Black Cat-era Janet Jackson. Booty and all.

Yeah, but I think I echo Simon's sentiment - it was a little weird. It's an interesting side to her personality we haven't seen yet!

I feel the same way - and after watching her dance during the rehearsal, I was hoping she'd sing her original song. :drool:

OK I don't care for her either but...

Simon: "You owe a big kiss to the director and the lighting director because they made you look amazing!"

McPhee: "I know! I do! Thank you guys!"

I think her "I do" was to her owing the directors a big kiss not that she knows she looks good. :-) I still don't care for her though.

Paris and Elliot and Chris ruled tonight even though I could barely understand a word Chris said.

Well before i go to the magical DialIdol for my official office pool picks, I will say Paris, Elliott, and Ace in the bottom 3 with Ace going home. It was a tough choice between him and Paris though.

Top 3:

Taylor
Chris
Paris

Bottom 3:
Elliot
Ace




Pickler :yack: