Blasphemy!

Prince is a musical genius and should be considered an Idol by anyone's standards.

I am a huge Queen fan, but I can't see any of them impressing anybody with these songs. There are so many better ones.

OK, so it's OK to say that they are singing Queen songs, but not OK to say which songs will be played?

And yes, I agree, Paris' choice is crazy for her. It worked for last year, but it was his style, not hers.

Yep, I was just going to say the exact same thing. I can't imagaine any of these Idol contestants performing the song better than she did (even the choir that was accompanying her was rocking out). Now do I think any of the contestants could do a better job at the song than MiG ...

Plus, the American Idol band pales in comparison to the House Band from RockStar.

wait, is queen (or at least the ones who are still alive actually performing tonight? I am no american idol fan by any means, but I am a big queen fan, so i'll probably tune in for the hell of it.

I can't believe we are actually putting spoiler tags around the songs they are singing. Is someone sitting at home on the edge of their seat for the song choice? Does knowing what Bucky is going to sing, spoil anything at all? For the love of god, stop the spoiler madness. Don't come to threads like this before the show if you are that anal.

:lol:

I agree. It's a singing show, it's not like it's Lost or 24.

..or a Bobcat Goldthwait night!

As far as Bucky's song, there was a recent remake of that song by country artist Kevin Fowler that should suit Bucky just fine. Hope he does well.

Shit! I'd actually like to see that!

Chris-"Hold The Line"
Kellie-"I'll be over you"
Taylor-"Rosanna"
Katherine-"I won't hold you back"
Ace-"Africa"
Elliot-"Georgy Porgy"
Paris-"Waiting for your love"
Bucky-"Make believe"

Hout about a damn night to sing whatever they want so they can get back to what made them all top 10 contestants.

Damnit, please put hypothetical song choices of hypothetical themes of potential future shows in spoilers. :mad:

I still think Mandisa should have been the one to sing that song...Damn the American public!!!!

Dear Ace,

Thank you for ruining a great Queen song.

Signed,
America.

(BTW - it just hit me - Ace is man-pretty.)

Bucky-1

Ace-0

oh my god.... hearing the previews of pickler sounds destructively bad

I like how the members of Queen are somewhat resigned to their opinions.

"Tough song." "Yeah" "She'll do good..." (looks down at floor silently)

Pickler might make a good katie vick

OMG Lita Ford is on American Idol!!! And thanks to Ace, Freddie Mercury is rolling in his grave right now.

Nothing really matterssss.... she sucks

randy is insane...... he is crazy.....

That's exactly what I was going to post :)

these judges are insane.... and this is stupid.... get rid of this moron

Well, I don't think that was nearly as bad as it could've been...and she was better than Ace. Bucky is easily the best so far. Hope Chris makes them all look like amateurs again.

I thought Bucky was really good.

Ace was a travesty.

Kellie managed to not look hot. Good job.

Yeah, that's the one thing I couldn't figure out...Simon was spot on, she looked scary. Half the votes she's getting have to be from guys who think she's hot.

I agree with Simon...So many Queen songs to pick from, he should have rocked One Vision from the Iron Eagle soundtrack.