DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Nip/Tuck: Who is The Carver? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/448117-nip-tuck-who-carver.html)

starseed 12-17-05 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by sebastianv50
I'm guessing that Gina is the Carver, but my girlfriend said that Gina was out in the church waiting for Kimber like everyone else at the time that Kimber was abducted. Does anyone know if this is true? Because if so it would be very difficult for he alone to be the Carver.

Yes, Gina was indeed shown seated in the church at the wedding.

Groucho 12-17-05 02:40 PM


Originally Posted by Green Smurf
I still say that its the detective Kit.

:hscratch:

http://img397.imageshack.us/img397/5535/np237fd.gif

TheNightFlier 12-17-05 03:36 PM

I hope it's not someone that we've only seen for 30 seconds in a 1st season episode.

My guesses are
Spoiler:
Jude or Quentin..the only reason I'm still considering Quentin is that in the preview his arms are tied up, he's not drugged. So it's possible he cut himself. It's a bit of a stretch though.

DVD Josh 12-17-05 03:56 PM


Originally Posted by TheNightFlier
I hope it's not someone that we've only seen for 30 seconds in a 1st season episode.

My guesses are
Spoiler:
Jude or Quentin..the only reason I'm still considering Quentin is that in the preview his arms are tied up, he's not drugged. So it's possible he cut himself. It's a bit of a stretch though.

That person is not visible long enough to make the snap judgment that they are not drugged. Besides, they look more dead than anything else.

TheNightFlier 12-17-05 04:02 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
That person is not visible long enough to make the snap judgment that they are not drugged. Besides, they look more dead than anything else.

Spoiler:
Why tie his arms up if he's drugged?

OldBoy 12-17-05 04:27 PM

so it is a 2-hour finale, Tuesday 12/20 starting at 10pm, right?

DVD Josh 12-17-05 04:35 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
so it is a 2-hour finale, Tuesday 12/20 starting at 10pm, right?

It's only been mentioned several times already in this thread.

OldBoy 12-17-05 05:10 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
It's only been mentioned several times already in this thread.

i just want to be sure. it was only mentioned once i think with several varying opinions. i need some more confirmation. not smart ass remarks.

ChristopherS 12-17-05 10:09 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
yes. Cris and Sean went to Atlanta i believe where he worked prior for a specific case (which i don't remember) or Quentin came to Miami one time for the case.

My theory was that they called for this Quinten guy but instead got the carver posing as Quinten. The reveal would be someone predictable and capable, but with a twist. But that doesn't hold up if they knew the guy previously.

I read elsewhere that Ryan Murphy has said the episode with the woman stuck to the sofa holds a clue. Anyone know if he really said that? That would lean towards a certain somebody who randomly appears in that episode.

DVD Josh 12-17-05 10:11 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
i just want to be sure. it was only mentioned once i think with several varying opinions. i need some more confirmation. not smart ass remarks.

You could read the thread

You could go to FXNETWORKS.com (which would be faster)

You could go to TVguide.com

You could go to zap2it.com

It continues.

The bottom line is that you did nothing that would have EASILY found your answer, in less time than it took you keep posting your already-answered and easily-answered question.

Could I have said yes? Perhaps, but you didn't do any of the above so why should anyone else feel the need. That would give you your "confirmation".

DVD Josh 12-17-05 10:13 PM


Originally Posted by ChristopherS
My theory was that they called for this Quinten guy but instead got the carver posing as Quinten. The reveal would be someone predictable and capable, but with a twist. But that doesn't hold up if they knew the guy previously.

I read elsewhere that Ryan Murphy has said the episode with the woman stuck to the sofa holds a clue. Anyone know if he really said that? That would lean towards a certain somebody who randomly appears in that episode.

All the sudden buzz has started being generated about

Spoiler:
Jude. Which would mean that Julia's pregnancy is further along than she thought


I would be VERY disappointed if s/he was the Carver.

I actually like your idea. Maybe Quetin did not come back from Africa, and the Carver took over his identity, and his connection to M/T was purely coincidental. Very N/T.

Jimmy James 12-17-05 11:32 PM


Originally Posted by TheNightFlier
Spoiler:
Why tie his arms up if he's drugged?

It could be scene-specific symbolism. We don't know what else is going on in the room where that takes place.

treszoks 12-18-05 10:16 AM

Spoiler:
Perhaps the "I Can't Stop" written above Q tied to the bed was done by himself and then he ties himself up because it's the only way to stop himself?


My guess is Kit, the detective. I just have to think that since the carver thinks beauty is a curse, that would rule out a lot of the choices.

DVD Josh 12-18-05 10:41 AM


Originally Posted by treszoks
Spoiler:
Perhaps the "I Can't Stop" written above Q tied to the bed was done by himself and then he ties himself up because it's the only way to stop himself?


Doesn't make any sense. The Carver doesn't want to stop.

Jimmy James 12-18-05 01:03 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Doesn't make any sense. The Carver doesn't want to stop.

Maybe something happens in the episode that changes it. I will point out again that anything we have seen in that preview could be a lie or a part of a dream.

DVD Josh 12-18-05 01:35 PM


Originally Posted by Jimmy James
Maybe something happens in the episode that changes it. I will point out again that anything we have seen in that preview could be a lie or a part of a dream.

I like most of your theories JJ. Not this one though :)

Previews often are distortions though.

Damn I can't wait until Tuesday.

Jimmy James 12-18-05 01:38 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
I like most of your theories JJ. Not this one though :)

Previews often are distortions though.

Damn I can't wait until Tuesday.

My personal theory is that either Sean or Christian have a dream about the Carver that includes that shot of Quentin as a victim. It's the writing in blood on the wall and his arms being tied up that make me suspicious.

DVD Josh 12-18-05 02:22 PM


Originally Posted by Jimmy James
My personal theory is that either Sean or Christian have a dream about the Carver that includes that shot of Quentin as a victim. It's the writing in blood on the wall and his arms being tied up that make me suspicious.

I believe that
Spoiler:
Kit goes to arrest Quetin for being the Carver and they find him like that

sureAV421 12-18-05 03:14 PM

i can't remember, but how exactly did Christian's used condom get in the Carver's first murder victim's room?

Jimmy James 12-18-05 06:26 PM


Originally Posted by sureAV421
i can't remember, but how exactly did Christian's used condom get in the Carver's first murder victim's room?

Search us. Maybe they'll fill us in.

sureAV421 12-18-05 07:28 PM

check out: http://www.myspace.com/niptuck
there's a new preview (a few spoilers though).

Green Smurf 12-18-05 07:31 PM


Originally Posted by Groucho


She slept with Christian and Kimber in the begining of this season. She seemed pretty mad that Kimber would change her life to be Christian's wife. Hence why Kimber is going though what she is going through now, and how she would have gotten Christians condom.

I know I get made fun out of for suggesting it, but I think it's her.

SexualPudding 12-19-05 02:16 AM

Impossible, since it has been said ad nauseum that it is someone who has appeared in the past, not just this season.

DVD Josh 12-19-05 06:45 AM


Originally Posted by Green Smurf
She slept with Christian and Kimber in the begining of this season. She seemed pretty mad that Kimber would change her life to be Christian's wife. Hence why Kimber is going though what she is going through now, and how she would have gotten Christians condom.

I know I get made fun out of for suggesting it, but I think it's her.

Well, it really can't be, since she appeared LONG after the Carver.

DVD Josh 12-19-05 06:47 AM


Originally Posted by SexualPudding
Impossible, since it has been said ad nauseum that it is someone who has appeared in the past, not just this season.

Well not impossible, but I agree, highly unlikely. To clarify, he said "someone we've known awhile". Many people have taken it to mean since season one, but like you said, it's better to say "appeared in the past".

I really can't believe the buzz around
Spoiler:
Jude
.

I'm starting to think that it is him.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:23 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.