DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   South Park - "Trapped in the Closet" - 11/16 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/445415-south-park-trapped-closet-11-16-a.html)

Mattrk 11-17-05 11:58 AM

They did forget that Xenu not only dropped these poor frozen aliens off into volcanoes, but that he dropped nuclear bombs on them as well. Still, they did a great job on the DC-8s, and the end credits.

SMB-IL 11-17-05 12:15 PM

Funniest episode of SP I've seen in a few years, IMO. rotfl

Big Boy Laroux 11-17-05 12:36 PM

man, i caught this because of the new TiVo overlap feature! sweet!

i liked the episode. Not stellar, but it was funny to see the actual beliefs of scientologists.

slop101 11-17-05 03:49 PM

Hey, isnt' Isaac Hayes (aka Chef) into Scientology?

GameGenie 11-17-05 07:13 PM

I thought this episode was pretty good but it wasnt that funny. I thought it was realy funny though when Tom Cruise asked stan what his fav movie of his was. Also the R. Kelly jokes were good.

RoyalTea 11-17-05 09:14 PM

is there a background for the r. kelly jokes?

i don't listen to hip-hop.

Charlie Goose 11-17-05 11:03 PM

Feh. Making fun of Scientology and Tom Cruise is way too easy.

Gizmo 11-17-05 11:25 PM


Originally Posted by slop101
Hey, isnt' Isaac Hayes (aka Chef) into Scientology?

Chef still alive? I havn't seen him in like years.

DRG 11-18-05 12:05 AM


Originally Posted by RoyalTea
is there a background for the r. kelly jokes?

i don't listen to hip-hop.

He did a series of videos, basically one REALLY long song divided into 12 parts, with a really long video to go with it. The whole thing is basically a bad soap opera that he sings. It's brutally bad but hilarious at the same time. Part one is here in Quicktime. Enjoy. :)
http://www.video-c.co.uk/microshow.a...eType=ADSLprog

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trapped_In_The_Closet

Also on DVD apparently: :lol:
http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0...ZZZ_SS260_.jpg

grunter 11-18-05 09:57 AM

Third episode in a row to not bring "the funny."

South Park's slipping.

Red Dog 11-18-05 10:00 AM

Loved the "This is what Scientologists actually believe" graphic. They should have done the same thing during the Mormon episode.

PixyJunket 11-18-05 10:30 AM


Originally Posted by Charlie Goose
Making fun of Scientology and Tom Cruise is way too easy.

That's what I was thinking. Tom Cruise is gay? Wow, nobody has made that joke before.

lamphorn 11-18-05 09:33 PM

Actually, I thought it was phenomenal that they made fun of Scientology. Just publicly mentioning that Xenu story has been enough to get people sued, stalked, threatened (and I mean physically, like death threats), etc.. The media usually glosses over it (never seen Saturday Night Live tackle it ((though I haven't watched lately))). Those Smiths in the credits weren't just for laughs.
They hammered the "in the closet" thing a little too much I think, but I'm really thrilled that they took on that despicable cult head-on.

Merkin Muffley 11-18-05 09:50 PM


Originally Posted by RoyalTea
i don't listen to hip-hop.

rotfl

RichardW 11-19-05 08:27 AM

I thought it was pretty good. The "go ahead and sue me" statement followed by the John and Jane Smith credits was priceless.

atlantamoi 11-19-05 09:20 AM

Have people associated with Scientology sued successfully? I can't imagine how it would be possible to get hammered by telling the truth about their beliefs. Sure, piss 'em off, but sued?

DGibFen 11-19-05 09:47 AM


Originally Posted by atlantamoi
Have people associated with Scientology sued successfully? I can't imagine how it would be possible to get hammered by telling the truth about their beliefs. Sure, piss 'em off, but sued?

I think (I'm not certain, however) it's been argued before in a court case that Scientology is copyrighted, and therefore anyone talking about it without written permission is breaking that copyright.

caligulathegod 11-19-05 12:14 PM

They don't even care if they win. They just sue and sue until the victim is bankrupted by lawyer fees.

boogieman03 11-19-05 12:27 PM

Man, I was rotfl throughout this episode. Not groundbreaking, but I was laughing. Nice touch on bringing R Kelly in. "I'm gonna cap this bitch!"
I liked Travolta's impression as well.

HistoryProf 11-19-05 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by DRG
He did a series of videos, basically one REALLY long song divided into 12 parts, with a really long video to go with it. The whole thing is basically a bad soap opera that he sings. It's brutally bad but hilarious at the same time. Part one is here in Quicktime. Enjoy. :)
http://www.video-c.co.uk/microshow.a...eType=ADSLprog

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trapped_In_The_Closet

Also on DVD apparently: :lol:
http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0...ZZZ_SS260_.jpg

Holy cow. That is awful.

Goldberg74 11-19-05 07:16 PM

VH1 showed the entire video in a special over the summer. Very interesting story/video.

Saw the South Parks story on CNN and watched the video they had there of the segment. Had to laugh, especially with R. Kelly (who I figured it was but they never made reference... 'cept for the closet reference) holding a gun to the door and going in the closet.

MOSHUN 11-19-05 08:01 PM

that shit is the funniest thing I think Ive seen this year. Im laughing to it hurts

invisiblegt 11-19-05 08:03 PM

In my opinion...

One of the least funny episodes in a while. The whole "in the closet" thing was horrible.

mikewendt 11-20-05 03:32 PM

I thought this episode was good... I had a few laugh-out-loud moments and a number of chuckles...

Highlights for me...
Travolta: "Is this where he is, is this wher L. Ron Hubbard lives? OhmyGAUD!!!"
Belief Disclaimer
"You not as good as the guy in Napoleon Dynamite."
R. Kelly's gun moments
& End Credits

I'd say that's a solid ammout of laughs for 22 minutes of TV...

Damfino 01-23-06 05:13 PM

Looks like this episode has been banned in Britain...

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2006/01...uth_park_axed/

It will be interesting to see if it airs uncut here again.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:21 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.