DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Does Fox Still Seem Second Rate to you? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/424218-does-fox-still-seem-second-rate-you.html)

das Monkey 05-26-05 09:53 AM

They don't "seem" second rate; they <i>are</i> second rate. Frankly, though, I think they want it that way. They want to be on the fringe, airing (and quickly cancelling) quirky genre shows and sinking to the absolute lowest of lows in terms of classless programming. That's their niche, and they're great at it. We don't need another ABC/CBS/NBC. Fox fills a void and does it well, but they're still second rate. Until they open up a third primetime hour, it's not even close.

das

twikoff 05-26-05 09:56 AM

and fox allows all their shows to make fun of their network and owners :up:

superdeluxe 05-26-05 11:07 AM


Originally Posted by Jadow
It does to me. Not that there aren't good shows, but it doesn't have the feel of a major network for two reaons in my opinion:

No 5:30 (central) national newscast

In central time, all their shows only go until 9:00 central, then from 9:00 to 10:00 they have no national presense so it's just old syndicated eps of Seinfeld where I live. Is that the same elsewhere?


Nope. and it was proven by Fox winning the coveted demo 18-49

I watch more shows on Fox (5), than I do total for all the other networks (3)

superdeluxe 05-26-05 11:10 AM


Originally Posted by Draven
Fox will always be a second-rate network to me. Despite the renewal of "Arrested Development," a network that promotes garbage like "American Idol" and "The Simple Life" on top of every other stupid "reality" and animal-attack show they've aired make them one big joke to me.

AD, That 70s Show and occassional reruns is all the network is good for.

That Garbage, is the one of the highest rated shows in the country.

and you want garbage? You see the crap that NBC is throwing out there? What about all those idiotic reality shows..I mean how many takes of the bachelor can you have?

superdeluxe 05-26-05 11:11 AM


Originally Posted by Draven
To me, Fox has never been a network that aired quality programming.

.

House > .

/thread.

sundog 05-26-05 11:14 AM

I think it's the other way:

Fox didn't become first-rate, the other three networks have dropped to second-rate (maybe even third-rate).

twikoff 05-26-05 11:16 AM

2nd rate feel.. but still the best lineup of shows :up:

Red Dog 05-26-05 11:21 AM


Originally Posted by twikoff
2nd rate feel.. but still the best lineup of shows :up:


ABC had the best lineup of shows this past season of broadcast networks.

twikoff 05-26-05 11:27 AM


Originally Posted by Red Dog
ABC had the best lineup of shows this past season of broadcast networks.

:hscratch:
Im trying to think of anything i watch on abc

wait a minute.. hold on.. im sure there is one.....

cbs had the best overall ratings of the networks..
fox, nbc, abc all pretty much tied for 2nd

but as mentioned above.. fox won the 18-49 demo.. which is most important

Draven 05-26-05 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by superdeluxe
That Garbage, is the one of the highest rated shows in the country.

Which means what? That lots of people like watching shitty shows on television? Who didn't already know that?

twikoff 05-26-05 11:55 AM


Originally Posted by Draven
Which means what? That lots of people like watching shitty shows on television? Who didn't already know that?

or means that your opinion is not the same as the majority
but i assume your opinion is still the correct one?

twikoff 05-26-05 11:55 AM

Ive been to burnsville.. drove by there this past weekend
did you see me??

boredsilly 05-26-05 12:11 PM

I actually see The WB as a step up from Fox. I know that isn't technically true, but they have a slicker presentation/higher production value IMHO that makes them seem more real deal. But yeah, Fox still is a second stringer, but if that means they don't run 14 cop shows during the week I'm cool with it.

Bill Needle 05-26-05 12:24 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
Ive been to burnsville.. drove by there this past weekend
did you see me??

I've got you beat, I live within sight of Burnsville. Can see it now off in the distance over the treetops.

DRG 05-26-05 01:04 PM

I really wish they would've opened up that third hour years ago. It would've meant an extra 7 hours to fill across the week. It *might* have saved some of the infamous cancellations if Fox had that much time to fill. "Well Wonderfalls/Firefly/Tru Calling/etc. is doing crappy in the ratings, but we might as well stick with it because we need to put SOMETHING on."

Or, they might have just filled it with even more crap... we'll never know.

superdeluxe 05-26-05 01:06 PM


Originally Posted by Draven
Which means what? That lots of people like watching shitty shows on television? Who didn't already know that?

Which means that Fox is among the big boys..and not a 2nd rate network.

Who cares they dont have national news? Not everyone watches the national news (notice ratings going down across the board). I'd rather have my syndicated sitcoms.

Who cares they have 3 hours of programming. That extra hour of programming sure hasnt helped NBC. It makes what Fox is doing even more special..since they are working with one less hour.

Red Dog 05-26-05 01:08 PM

A network basically hanging its hat on one program, particularly a reality one (that could very well be a fad), isn't a recipe for continued success IMO.

Josh H 05-26-05 01:30 PM

I don't watch anything on Fox currently except the NFL in the fall/winter.

So, yes is 2nd rate IMO.

superdeluxe 05-26-05 01:36 PM


Originally Posted by Red Dog
A network basically hanging its hat on one program, particularly a reality one (that could very well be a fad), isn't a recipe for continued success IMO.

A fad that has gotten better ratings in its 4th season than its 1st? Not bad for a fad.

Oh and also House is a top 10 program. Not bad..Fox has 3 of the top 10 shows in the nielsen's ratings..

superdeluxe 05-26-05 01:37 PM


Originally Posted by Josh Hinkle
I don't watch anything on Fox currently except the NFL in the fall/winter.

So, yes is 2nd rate IMO.


Well if we are talking opinions...CBS must be 2nd rate..as I do not watch anything on CBS. Being consistant and all.

twikoff 05-26-05 01:38 PM


Originally Posted by Bill Needle
I've got you beat, I live within sight of Burnsville. Can see it now off in the distance over the treetops.


I drove through the twin cities this weekend
did you see me?
I was in a dollar rental car taurus

;)

Red Dog 05-26-05 01:42 PM


Originally Posted by superdeluxe
A fad that has gotten better ratings in its 4th season than its 1st? Not bad for a fad.

Oh and also House is a top 10 program. Not bad..Fox has 3 of the top 10 shows in the nielsen's ratings..


House wouldn't be a top-10 program w/o the lead-in of AI. FOX's success is driven by one show, which makes for a potentially bad situation. No other network is so dependent on one show.

twikoff 05-26-05 01:44 PM

hold on.. Im still trying to think of ANYTHING i watch on ABC.. Im sure there is something.. :hscratch:

although I could quickly come up with 5-7 programs I watch regularly on fox

twikoff 05-26-05 01:45 PM


Originally Posted by Red Dog
House wouldn't be a top-10 program w/o the lead-in of AI. FOX's success is driven by one show, which makes for a potentially bad situation. No other network is so dependent on one show.

have you seen house?
it may very well be the best show on television right now

and AI is just one piece of fox's current success.. of course, its the overall most dominating rating show on the air, but still.. ;)

Red Dog 05-26-05 01:47 PM


Originally Posted by twikoff
have you seen house?
it may very well be the best show on television right now

and AI is just one piece of fox's current success.. of course, its the overall most dominating rating show on the air, but still.. ;)


I have. Can't stand it. I have little doubt what ratings it would draw without the AI lead-in.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:33 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.