DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   TV Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk-14/)
-   -   Best Sitcom Finale of all time? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/tv-talk/362913-best-sitcom-finale-all-time.html)

HistoryProf 05-07-04 12:21 PM

Best Sitcom Finale of all time?
 
Just thought i'd post a little poll since this seems to be a water cooler topic today in the wake of ushering in the post-friends era....If you choose Other, tell which one and why....

Groucho 05-07-04 12:27 PM

I voted MASH.

Red Dog 05-07-04 12:29 PM

Newhart, followed by Mary Tyler Moore and MASH.

Did Taxi even have a real finale. Wasn't it abrutly cancelled?

RobCA 05-07-04 12:30 PM

I voted for Newhart. :up: Another finale I liked was Roseanne. It's certainly one of the strangest, but I thought it worked, and it almost made up for the last season.

Almost. ;)

Rob

Deftones 05-07-04 12:31 PM

I didn't watch most of those shows, but of the few I did see, the Cheers one really choked me up the most. I'd say that one.

HistoryProf 05-07-04 12:37 PM


Originally posted by Red Dog
Newhart, followed by Mary Tyler Moore and MASH.

Did Taxi even have a real finale. Wasn't it abrutly cancelled?

To be honest i don't remember....I was just trying to pick out the most popular sitcoms of the last 30 years....I thought I recalled something of a finale, but maybe not....Roseanne would have been a good option too....oh, well.

Canis Firebrand 05-07-04 12:39 PM

Can we have a recap of some of them.

I stopped watching Rosanne about the last season, so I'm not sure exactly what happened.

Spoiler:
I think I recall hearing that Dan actually died of a heart attack and the last season with him in it was more of a dream.


And for the life of me, I cannot recall what the Night Court finale was. I watched that show every week. I guess that shows how memorable the ending was.

Timber 05-07-04 12:43 PM

Have to go with Newhart. Nice idea tying his 2 shows together.

B.A. 05-07-04 12:45 PM


Originally posted by Deftones, Esq
I didn't watch most of those shows, but of the few I did see, the Cheers one really choked me up the most. I'd say that one.
:up:

Jeremy517 05-07-04 12:47 PM


Originally posted by Vryce

And for the life of me, I cannot recall what the Night Court finale was. I watched that show every week. I guess that shows how memorable the <i>last few seasons were</i>.

Fixed.

I can't believe how far Night Court fell in its last few seasons. The whole Phil Foundation, Dan as the Phantom of the Courthouse, Christine being pregnant, Harry adopting the kid...

*shudder*

das Monkey 05-07-04 12:49 PM

<i>Newhart</i>, because the episode itself was hilarious without the twist, and then the twist was absolutely brilliant. I would probably take <i>MTM</i> and <i>M*A*S*H</i> tied for second (hard to compare the kleenex move against the rock message), with <i>Cheers</i> very close behind.

das

Rypro 525 05-07-04 12:52 PM


Originally posted by Vryce
Can we have a recap of some of them.

I stopped watching Rosanne about the last season, so I'm not sure exactly what happened.

Spoiler:
I think I recall hearing that Dan actually died of a heart attack and the last season with him in it was more of a dream.


And for the life of me, I cannot recall what the Night Court finale was. I watched that show every week. I guess that shows how memorable the ending was.

i think everything in the last season of rosanne
Spoiler:
was a dream. it was one of her daughters that kept a journal or something like that.

Jeremy517 05-07-04 12:52 PM

Here's what happened in the Night Court finale. Ugh, how horrible...

Spoiler:
- Harry momentarily accepts a job teaching law school
- Christine decides to move to New Orleans to practice law
- Dan decides to follow her
- Harry decides to not accept the job after all and stays the judge at the night court
- Bull gets beamed up by a couple guys from outer space.

the narrator 05-07-04 12:53 PM

definately Newhart....I didn't really watch either of the newhart shows all that much, but that ending was fantastic

Rogue588 05-07-04 12:55 PM

no love for St. Elsewhere..?

das Monkey 05-07-04 12:55 PM

While it's probably obvious which show you mean, you may want to edit the poll to reflect that it was called <i>Newhart</i> to avoid confusion with <i>The Bob Newhart Show</i>.

das

das Monkey 05-07-04 12:56 PM


• Rogue588 •

no love for St. Elsewhere..?

Hilarious show. Best sitcom ever. :D

das

Chew 05-07-04 12:56 PM

I'd have to go with Newhart as well.

RobCA 05-07-04 12:57 PM


Originally posted by Rypro 525
i think everything in the last season of rosanne
Spoiler:
was a dream. it was one of her daughters that kept a journal or something like that.

Actually,
Spoiler:
it tied in a storyline from a much earlier episode, where Dan fixed up an office for Roseanne where she could write. It turned out Dan died after the heart attack he'd had about a season earlier, and everything since then, with them winning the lottery, etc., was actually stuff she'd written, to try to cope with losing Dan.


Rob

Groucho 05-07-04 12:57 PM

One thing that should be pointed out is that of all the finales, listed MASH was unique in that it played like the finale of a drama, rather than that of a sitcom.

Red Dog 05-07-04 12:59 PM


Originally posted by Groucho
One thing that should be pointed out is that of all the finales, listed MASH was unique in that it played like the finale of a drama, rather than that of a sitcom.

True. Of course, MASH walked that fine line throughout its run.

das Monkey 05-07-04 12:59 PM


• Groucho •

One thing that should be pointed out is that of all the finales, listed MASH was unique in that it played like the finale of a drama, rather than that of a sitcom.

Of course, <i>M*A*S*H</i> was never a typical sitcom anyway, frequently straying into drama territory.

das

MJKTool 05-07-04 01:00 PM

Out of the ones I've seen (Seinfeld, Friends, Cheers) I'll say Cheers was the one I liked the best.

Rogue588 05-07-04 01:11 PM


Originally posted by das Monkey
Hilarious show. Best sitcom ever. :D

Originally posted by das Monkey
Of course, <i>M*A*S*H</i> was never a typical sitcom anyway, frequently straying into drama territory.
Yeah....umm.....that's...umm...what I was trying to say about St. Elsewhere....uh huh...."it was a drama that frequently strayed into sitcom territory".....thereby qualifying it for this thread....yeah, that's the ticket...that's my story and i'm sticking to it...

actually, I didn't really process the thread title until it was too late...

morpheus3715 05-07-04 01:12 PM

I vote for mash because what other sitcom had 2 1/2 hours for the finale. BTW did anyone see the Taxi finale? If so how did that end?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:50 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.