Kee-ripes!! The ending just knocked me on my ass! Great episode, great show, great writing.

great episode

One word - Wow

Yep one of the best ever.

I till think that the episode with Michael J. Fox was better. The one where they focused on his OCD but this was awful close.

I was dissapointed in the Fox storylines. I thought that one was just amazing though.

Agreed! I lost interest during the last 2 with Fox.

Chris

AH. I once again forgot Scrubs is now on Tuesday nights. That's like 3 or 4 times I've forgotten. I set up and alarm on my computer but alas I was watching a movie and not at the computer so it didn't grab my attention. Oh well, atleast I'll have a "new to you" episode to look forward to come Summer ;)

TiVo is my friend :D I would have no idea it was on otherwise :)

I've just started watching this show this season and wow. This show is fantabulous. I'm not one of those people who LOL when watching tv by myself, but this ep never fails to make me bust a gut. Then they go and rip my heart out with the dramatic shiznit. This show should be required viewing for everyone.

I'm with the above poster in thinking that the Fox OCD ep was better, but this ep was still stellar.

Man, I finally had the time to check this out last night on the ReplayTV, so I've been avoiding this thread like the plague till now. But man oh man, what a great episode. I try not to think when watching a TV show since it's my brain-dead time, so I didn't see that coming at all.

Great acting by all of them, I was esp surprised by Brenden Fraser! He was funny as hell!

As for comparing the episodes, it is quite obvious MJF is a superior actor. While this episode might have been better that is because of the writers. I think they could have filled BF part with almost any actor.

I just hope they don't turn this into Will & Grace, "guest star of the week" syndrome. They are coming close though with Tara Reid, MJF, and Brendan Frazier.

Also was not a fan of the MJF storyline, I liked him in Spin City, but not in scrubs.

I love Jordan though. :)

one word also: W O W!! this was such a great episode, with a great ending.

so many good clues :) i jus loved it, prlly one of my fave eps!

G x

I know it has been a while since this episoda was on but I just rewatched it again (because it was such a damn good episode) and was wondering if anyone happened to know the song that was playing towards the end I think it was a song by Elliot Smith

Maybe... Josh Radin - Winter

"My Screw Up" is on right now before Last Comic Standing comes on at 9/8 central.

Yep. I watched it again too. A very different perspective knowing the outcome.

I still think the OCD episode with MJF was my favorite although this one is considered the best Scrubs episode ever.

I think knowing the outcome of this ep just made me appreciate a few other spots in the ep more than I did before, but it is still one of my favorite episodes - if not my favorite.

I think its my favorite ep also.

I just got done watching ep 1x22 - my occurence, where ben was first introduced. Anyways I can't believe I forgot they did the same thing in that episode, except it was through JDs perspective. I think its great they were able to pull it off again. <3 scrubs.