NEW 8 Simple Rules 11/4/03
#26
Guest
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 847
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well, cheers to ABC for nixing the laugh track after the opening scene. Now, if only we could get all shows to do that.
James Garner was the best part of the show...too bad they're only keeping him around for four episodes.
While the jokes at the wake weren't particularly funny, that's exactly the kind of stuff that happens...people say stupid things that they wouldn't say anywhere else.
The only part I DIDN'T care for was the last column they found...it seems like an awful coincidence that his last column would remind the family how much he loved them. It was a nice touch...but a little unrealistic.
The only thing I made up my mind about after last night's show...which I would give a B- to overall...was that this program NEEDS a strong male lead. Garner provided it last night, but unless he sticks around or they find someone equally as strong, I think the ratings will slip and the show will be cancelled.
James Garner was the best part of the show...too bad they're only keeping him around for four episodes.
While the jokes at the wake weren't particularly funny, that's exactly the kind of stuff that happens...people say stupid things that they wouldn't say anywhere else.
The only part I DIDN'T care for was the last column they found...it seems like an awful coincidence that his last column would remind the family how much he loved them. It was a nice touch...but a little unrealistic.
The only thing I made up my mind about after last night's show...which I would give a B- to overall...was that this program NEEDS a strong male lead. Garner provided it last night, but unless he sticks around or they find someone equally as strong, I think the ratings will slip and the show will be cancelled.
#27
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by WWE Jedi
I have no doubt this episode will require some Kleenex.
I have no doubt this episode will require some Kleenex.
Actually, the episode was sad, but not half as sad as they could have made it. I was sadder watching the episodes WITH him, knowing he was already dead.
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2000
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think they should have went one way or the other with the laugh track. Either they should have left it in for the occasional joke, or left it out and not have had any jokes.
They should have not announced his death until 15 minutes into the story, and should have eliminated the grandparents bikkering, and replaced it with how she explained to the kids.
They should have not announced his death until 15 minutes into the story, and should have eliminated the grandparents bikkering, and replaced it with how she explained to the kids.
#30
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
They SHOULD have cancelled the show. This isn't like a player for a sporting team dying and everyone saying "He would have wanted us to keep playing". They obviously have to resume playing at some point. This was a television show where the star pass away. It is in very bad taste to continue the show just to get ratings. Instead they will milk this for what its worth and the show will fade away slowly. It should have ended with John in memory to him.
#33
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
No offense taken. I really couldn't care less if they continued it or not. I'm just stating my opinion on what they should have done since everyone else was. The show never was very good(BTW, I actually did see a few before he died, unlike half the viewers last night) and was only held together by Ritter. Why continue it?
#34
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Formerly known as "12thmonkey"/Frankfort, IL
Posts: 7,790
Received 35 Likes
on
31 Posts
Well, we (my wife, daughter and I) were big fans of 8 Simple Rules, but somehow none of us could muster the desire to watch the hour-long "lead character dies" episode.
Hell, we saw the commercial for it and we all looked at each other and said "no, can't do it."
In the past, we had watched the show because we liked to laugh. It was a sitcom, it was funny.
Don't get me wrong - we felt really awful when Ritter died. We watched the first three episodes of this season, and for us, that was tough enough to do.
I taped it, but it's unlikely we'll ever watch it. Weird, huh?
Hell, we saw the commercial for it and we all looked at each other and said "no, can't do it."
In the past, we had watched the show because we liked to laugh. It was a sitcom, it was funny.
Don't get me wrong - we felt really awful when Ritter died. We watched the first three episodes of this season, and for us, that was tough enough to do.
I taped it, but it's unlikely we'll ever watch it. Weird, huh?
Last edited by Pointyskull; 11-05-03 at 10:53 AM.
#35
DVD Talk Reviewer
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Formerly known as "12thmonkey"/Frankfort, IL
Posts: 7,790
Received 35 Likes
on
31 Posts
Originally posted by BDLOU
The show never was very good
The show never was very good
Boy, I thought it was consistently pretty darn funny.......
Last edited by Pointyskull; 11-05-03 at 11:17 AM.
#36
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Columbus, OH
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
12th monkey
I guess I shouldn't say it was never very good. It was entertaining I suppose. I would watch it if it were on and I was sitting in front of the TV but it wasn't something I would Tivo. It did for a family what "Everyone Loves Raymond" does for couples with smaller(mostly invisible in Ray's case) children. Although I do think Raymond is a lot better but thats probably because I don't have any teenage children. With that being said, I just don't see how a show could move on from losing its star other than doing so only to make money. And that is what I find offensive.
I guess I shouldn't say it was never very good. It was entertaining I suppose. I would watch it if it were on and I was sitting in front of the TV but it wasn't something I would Tivo. It did for a family what "Everyone Loves Raymond" does for couples with smaller(mostly invisible in Ray's case) children. Although I do think Raymond is a lot better but thats probably because I don't have any teenage children. With that being said, I just don't see how a show could move on from losing its star other than doing so only to make money. And that is what I find offensive.
#37
Guest
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 847
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As someone who thinks Everyone Loves Raymond is completely unfunny, I must say that 8 Simple Rules was occasionally quite funny. I think the problem was it was never consistantly funny. BTW, last night's show wasn't really intended to be funny - I'm expecting the laughs to start slowly returning with next week's show. By the time Garner leaves the series, things should be less somber and move back to sitcom-like storytelling.
#38
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I didn't watch it either, and probably won't for a while until they are past the geiving stage. I imagine I'll probably give it a chance when February sweeps come around. The only show I record on ABC's Tuesday night lineup is Less Than Perfect (not a popular show around here it seems). The rest are good, but I don't really care if I miss them.
#39
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Posts: 34,082
Received 723 Likes
on
528 Posts
The little jokes made it hard for me to get thru this episode. I wasn't quite sure if i should laugh or not and most times.. I think I ended up like the characters.. in a moment of uncomfortable silence. The ending was quite touching and did make me think about the things I say to those I love.
#40
Member
Would anybody be willing to part with their taped copy of last nights episode? My channels were switched and I ended up recording something totally different. I'll gladly pay for shipping/tape/time. Please email if you can help me out. Thanks!
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Manhattan
Posts: 1,176
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Spooky
While the jokes at the wake weren't particularly funny, that's exactly the kind of stuff that happens...people say stupid things that they wouldn't say anywhere else.
While the jokes at the wake weren't particularly funny, that's exactly the kind of stuff that happens...people say stupid things that they wouldn't say anywhere else.
#42
DVD Talk Gold Edition
i watched it, but it felt very akward...the jokes just seemed out of place and like they were seperate from what was going on instead of flowing like they should have...
#44
DVD Talk Special Edition
Now that Dragnet's canceled, maybe they can bring Ed O'Neill off mothballs to be her live-in boyfriend, and have him leering and coming on to the daughters. 8 Simple Rules for Oggling my Teenage Stepdaughter
#45
Suspended; also need updated email
Really just an extension of the John Ritter tribute
The few funny lines didn't fit in with the sadness
i also don't see how the show can move forward
I'd hate to see Kaley Cuoco leave the tv screen, she is so hot. I'd be happy with a 1/2 hour weekly show with Kaley modelling various swimsuits and lingerie
The few funny lines didn't fit in with the sadness
i also don't see how the show can move forward
I'd hate to see Kaley Cuoco leave the tv screen, she is so hot. I'd be happy with a 1/2 hour weekly show with Kaley modelling various swimsuits and lingerie
#46
DVD Talk Legend
I've never watched a single episode of the show... in fact, I never knew the show even existed until the news of John Ritter's death.
While flipping channels I came across the show as it was starting and realized it was the "death" episode - and I decided to watch.
The first 5 minutes with the laugh track (before the news of the death of the father) wasn't funny at all. Not sure if that's indicative of how the show normally was, but I'm not much of a fan of most sitcoms - so I'm thinking the normal shows would not be to my liking.
However, I was very surprised that I was teary-eyed for a good number of parts of this show. It had nothing to do with John Ritter's death (since I don't really lament on the death of celebrities) but had to do with the greiving a family had for losing their father. It was a very sad thing to watch.
I found it very touching, emotional and (in part) realistic. I thought it was very well done - much to my surprise.
That said, I still have no desire to watch any of the previous shows and any of the future ones.
While flipping channels I came across the show as it was starting and realized it was the "death" episode - and I decided to watch.
The first 5 minutes with the laugh track (before the news of the death of the father) wasn't funny at all. Not sure if that's indicative of how the show normally was, but I'm not much of a fan of most sitcoms - so I'm thinking the normal shows would not be to my liking.
However, I was very surprised that I was teary-eyed for a good number of parts of this show. It had nothing to do with John Ritter's death (since I don't really lament on the death of celebrities) but had to do with the greiving a family had for losing their father. It was a very sad thing to watch.
I found it very touching, emotional and (in part) realistic. I thought it was very well done - much to my surprise.
That said, I still have no desire to watch any of the previous shows and any of the future ones.