Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
#2826
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
The thing is though he’s the one who started it and he must have had an idea that he’d get some backlash from comic fans and the media. He chose to attack a group for mourning the death of someone beloved to their community. There wasn’t really a reason for him to go after that group other than him not being a fan or understanding why adults like comic related media. It’s different than his normal political leanings and having a stance on a politician, event, or whatever. Also I would say if he wants it to stop this retort probably isn’t going to help matters.
#2827
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Bill should have had a medical expert on that panel. He said some things that are just factually wrong (ear infections are not on the increase, they are dramatically decreased since the advent of pneumococcal vaccine, vaccines do not suppress the immune system). And his panel agreed that people should be vaccinated for Measles but kind of came off like you should pick and choose which ones are important. There should have been some doctor or scientist to explain to him that the science is sound. His argument that medical science is much less reliable than earth science is completely wrong. Yes medical treatments have changed over time. But so has earth science. We used to think it was fine to burn trash or dump it in the ocean as long as we didn’t littler. We used to think aerosols were okay until we didn’t. Fertilizer has changed many times over, so have weed killers. The basic tenants of science dictate that you learn from your data, refine and adapt. I am not saying skepticism is a bad thing, but vaccines are technical and important enough that if you want to discuss them at length with a panel, you should have somebody there who knows a lot about them rather than just folks who have opinions and feelings about the subject.
#2828
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
He didn't attack them for mourning Stan Lee. He attacked them for the way they were mourning him. Stan's death got it's 3 minutes at the end of the nightly news as was appropriate. It's not like Stan and comics had a huge impact in forming out culture like Dylan, Beatles or Elvis.
His original blog post makes it clear that he thinks "the comic book thing" is a symptom of a larger problem in America that has led to the Trump presidency. Sort of an Idiocracy thing. Adults are expending too much time and energy on entertainment intended for children, which is keeping them from thinking about the important issues in our society like climate change and weed legalization.
Last edited by Mike86; 01-27-19 at 10:51 AM.
#2829
Banned
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
He didn't attack them for mourning Stan Lee. He attacked them for the way they were mourning him. Stan's death got it's 3 minutes at the end of the nightly news as was appropriate. It's not like Stan and comics had a huge impact in forming out culture like Dylan, Beatles or Elvis.
#2830
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Nevertheless, my reply is a direct answer to the question you asked. Stupid or not, you asked why he did it when his general interest is politics.
#2831
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Yeah, but in my view he took something that's really not political and skewed it that way to fit his narrative. I don't agree with what he's saying in general.
#2832
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
When did the anti-vax episode air??
#2833
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
#2834
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Anyways, something can be of cultural importance without it being something to hold on to as adults. It is a bit fucking odd when grown men and women collect Funko's
Last edited by Gunde; 01-27-19 at 02:33 PM.
#2835
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
You are severely mistaken. Not only did Stan had a great impact in forming our culture, but comics have done so too. Funny that you mention Elvis. Why? Because his attire was inspired by Captain Marvel Jr. The entire movie economy today has been dependent on comic book based movies. Stan's creations have produced billions of dollars to the economy. One of the biggest shows this past decade is the Walking Dead, which came from comic books and inspired the modern zombie craze. I can go and on about the cultural impact of comic books and Stan Lee in our culture, but this would take me months to complete.
"I became a firefighter after seeing Towering Inferno as a kid."
#2836
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
It might not have been the worst thing for him to address it by saying, "It was months ago. If you haven't let it go, you need to, I'm moving on." But I think he really wanted to explain that he was not attacking Stan Lee.
. The flu shot is one of the least effective vaccines - usually less than 50% - and I think is the only one that requires getting a new shot annually. Compare that to pretty much all other vaccines that require just 1 or 2 shots and maybe a booster decades later and are typically from 85% to 100% effective and the flu shot is the runt of the litter, at least until the "Universal Flu Shot" is finally available. (Personally speaking, though, I get a flu shot each year because I think some protection is better than none, but I know a lot of people who aren't anti-vaxxers but never bother getting the flu shot.)
#2837
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Maybe it’s the AZ weather. But I haven’t had a flu shot (maybe once when I was a teen) and never had the flu in 15 or 20 years.
#2838
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Difference obviously being that while Irwin Allen was known for disaster films he never really reached mainstream celebrity status or was a recognizable figure. Stan Lee was a well known figure in comics and pop culture for decades. Also the Marvel characters are much more tied into the lexicon of our society. People are going to continue to recognize the Marvel characters years from now, but most aren’t likely to remember some old disaster films from the seventies (not saying those are bad films but it’s true).
Last edited by Mike86; 01-27-19 at 09:36 PM.
#2839
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
It’s kind of slippery; Maher isn’t a hardcore antivaxxer, but he seems to be really sympathetic to the cause. And when it comes to things like medicine and health, Maher seems to buy into a lot of woo.
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bill_Maher#On_medicine
https://gizmodo.com/neil-degrasse-ty...nce-1780648740
https://vaxopedia.org/2016/10/15/bil...r-on-vaccines/
https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/fiv...-it-yet-again/
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Bill_Maher#On_medicine
https://gizmodo.com/neil-degrasse-ty...nce-1780648740
https://vaxopedia.org/2016/10/15/bil...r-on-vaccines/
https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/fiv...-it-yet-again/
#2840
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Difference obviously being that while Irwin Allen was known for disaster films he never really reached mainstream celebrity status or was a recognizable figure. Stan Lee was a well known figure in comics and pop culture for decades. Also the Marvel characters are much more tied into the lexicon of our society. People are going to continue to recognize the Marvel characters years from now, but most aren’t likely to remember some old disaster films from the seventies (not saying those are bad films but it’s true).
As huge as Game of Thrones is, less than 1% of the population knew the books existed and had ever read one. Those who had been reading them before the tv series were in on something that everybody else was left out on. Comics are like that.
#2841
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
I'd wager that 90% of the population wouldn't know Stan Lee from his name. Show them his picture and, "Oh yeah. That old guy in the superhero movies." Stan was a well known figure in comics, which is a sub culture. Comics are like a secret club and those who read them are in on the secret.
As huge as Game of Thrones is, less than 1% of the population knew the books existed and had ever read one. Those who had been reading them before the tv series were in on something that everybody else was left out on. Comics are like that.
As huge as Game of Thrones is, less than 1% of the population knew the books existed and had ever read one. Those who had been reading them before the tv series were in on something that everybody else was left out on. Comics are like that.
I would say the Game of Thrones comparison is different in that it only was a series of four books when the series started. Not everyone is as apt to reading large fantasy novels, and especially ones where the author takes years and years to write and still isn't even finished with them. A lot different when compared to something like Marvel that's been around a lot longer and was more in the public eye even before gaining popularity with the films with the comics, cartoons, toys/merchandise, etc.
Last edited by Mike86; 01-28-19 at 07:09 AM.
#2842
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Stan had been appearing in the Marvel films for close to the last two decades. People awaited his cameos. He definitely had notoriety and I'm fairly certain a lot of people, including casual viewers started to notice him and caught on to who he was eventually. I also wouldn't necessarily call comics a secret club anymore. The people that read them maybe is still a smaller subset, but a lot more people in general are aware of them or at the least their characters.
.
.
If a single guy had invented Trix, Alpha-Bits, Cocoa Puffs, Captain Crunch, Fruit Loops and Lucky Charms and died today, people would think about it minute and then never think about it again. That's what comics mean to the general population. It is in error to apply Stan's importance to the sub culture to the entire population.
Maher is wrong in not recognizing Stan's importance to the subculture, and right in that most people don't give a shit.
#2843
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Yes the comics and characters are more widely known, but that doesn't mean they are as important to the general public as they are to the sub culture.
If a single guy had invented Trix, Alpha-Bits, Cocoa Puffs, Captain Crunch, Fruit Loops and Lucky Charms and died today, people would think about it minute and then never think about it again. That's what comics mean to the general population. It is in error to apply Stan's importance to the sub culture to the entire population.
Maher is wrong in not recognizing Stan's importance to the subculture, and right in that most people don't give a shit.
If a single guy had invented Trix, Alpha-Bits, Cocoa Puffs, Captain Crunch, Fruit Loops and Lucky Charms and died today, people would think about it minute and then never think about it again. That's what comics mean to the general population. It is in error to apply Stan's importance to the sub culture to the entire population.
Maher is wrong in not recognizing Stan's importance to the subculture, and right in that most people don't give a shit.
Last edited by Mike86; 01-28-19 at 09:12 AM.
#2844
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Maher is gonna Maher. I've always viewed him as a prick who says shit to get attention. I'm 40, married, and I read comics. He is of that generation that looks upon comics as trash. So, fuck him
#2845
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
William Shatner dying is equal to Barbara Eden dying, or Gilligan because they are not Star Trek fans.
#2846
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
That's the point. To most people one cultural icon is no more important than another. They aren't invested in it. Marvel movies are no more important to them than Mission Impossible, Jurassic Park or Alien. Everything's equal reduced to either good movie/bad movie.
William Shatner dying is equal to Barbara Eden dying, or Gilligan because they are not Star Trek fans.
William Shatner dying is equal to Barbara Eden dying, or Gilligan because they are not Star Trek fans.
I don't think your other examples really match Stan or Marvel other than maybe the Mission: Impossible franchise due to Tom Cruise being a big star, but even then that's only one thing (films) versus Marvel's various output. The Jurassic Park/World films while popular money makers aren't really associated with one star necessarily (Pratt is just the current guy), and as much as I love Star Trek its much more niche than Marvel and has never had a big mainstream appeal.
The closest icon that I can think of is maybe George Lucas as Star Wars is a huge brand with the films and has superceded just those with shows, video games, toys, and other merchandise. Even he I wouldn't say was ever as spotlighted as Stan Lee though, and oftentimes when he was it was in a more negative light.
Last edited by Mike86; 01-28-19 at 11:16 AM.
#2847
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Building attractions one theme park at a time.
Posts: 10,800
Received 82 Likes
on
49 Posts
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Neil Gaiman said it best: "More people cared about Stan Lee’s death than care about Bill Maher alive."
#2848
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
I'm with Bill on this! Adults should not be into comic book based movies. They should only be into serious stuff, like this:
#2849
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Real Time with Bill Maher (HBO) - Series Discussion Thread
Or acting like a dumb twenty something who thinks it’s cool to talk about pot and smoke it any chance he gets.
#2850
Banned