the Practice 05.19.2002
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 15,094
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: WAS looking for My Own Private Stuckeyville, but stuck in Liberty City (while missing Vice City)
the Practice 05.19.2002
Yawn.
Actually, i turned ABC on at 10p [after the X-Files] and was surprised to see the credits. I thought ABC had started it at 8 instead of 9.
Too bad they hadn't. It would've spared me from this bore of an episode. Did they save all the good stuff for the first hour?
Actually, i turned ABC on at 10p [after the X-Files] and was surprised to see the credits. I thought ABC had started it at 8 instead of 9.
Too bad they hadn't. It would've spared me from this bore of an episode. Did they save all the good stuff for the first hour?
#3
I just watched it (I taped it, among a couple other shows).
I thought it was pretty solid. The other plot line involving Rebecca's client went totally nowhere though. The performance by the actress who plays Lindsey made the show good. But, two hours is a little long for a "been there, done that" type of storyline (Bobby was, afterall, on trial for conspiracy murder this time last year).
Interesting verdict, though.
I thought it was pretty solid. The other plot line involving Rebecca's client went totally nowhere though. The performance by the actress who plays Lindsey made the show good. But, two hours is a little long for a "been there, done that" type of storyline (Bobby was, afterall, on trial for conspiracy murder this time last year).
Interesting verdict, though.
#5
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 1,849
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It was a two hour season finale. And boy oh boy was it ever predictable.
Now keep in mind that I am a master at suspending disbelief and I'm willing to swallow most of what passes for the practice of law on tv, but The Practice has reached an extremely low point. And I doubt I'll be back for next season, even though I have never missed an episode - I watched from day one.
But I knew the outcome was one of two very predictable paths, and for that matter I pretty much guessed every "twist" without even trying to guess them. In fact I actively surpress my analytical skills while watching my shows because it takes the surprise away and I truly love the feeling of discovery as a show unfolds. But even I was unable to avoid the forgone conclusion that
Spoiler:
Now keep in mind that I am a master at suspending disbelief and I'm willing to swallow most of what passes for the practice of law on tv, but The Practice has reached an extremely low point. And I doubt I'll be back for next season, even though I have never missed an episode - I watched from day one.
But I knew the outcome was one of two very predictable paths, and for that matter I pretty much guessed every "twist" without even trying to guess them. In fact I actively surpress my analytical skills while watching my shows because it takes the surprise away and I truly love the feeling of discovery as a show unfolds. But even I was unable to avoid the forgone conclusion that
Spoiler:
Last edited by WarriorPrincess; 05-20-02 at 07:32 AM.
#6
Originally posted by WarriorPrincess
It was a two hour season finale. And boy oh boy was it ever predictable.
It was a two hour season finale. And boy oh boy was it ever predictable.
das
#7
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 666
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Death Star
Meh.. I kind of knew it would be
I thought the verdict would be renedered and she would go crazy and get killed by the police or something. I just figured a twist was coming, but I guess the twist was a peaceful ending without someone dying.
Spoiler:
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 1,945
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Los Angeles
geez guys...does anyone on this board like this show. I still consider the best show on now if not the best show ever made. yes, it definitely has flaws here and there and it is unrealistic when everything is taken together, but I still think the individual storylines are extremely well written and done that way to try and cover as many possible ethical and other dilemmas as possible. I was pretty offended when TV guide totally ignored it when they ranked the top 50 shows of all time. Please don't get me wrong, this show has flaws, but i think every show does (even the West Wing..which has won how many Emmys). I hope this series never ends.
#10
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,193
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just got done watching it on tape and I thought it was pretty good. What the Practice does best is presents the characters and viewers with very hard moral and ethical questions. The moment when Rebecca had to decide whether or not to give Helen her client's friend's name is a great "The Practice" moment. As for that sub-plot not going anywhere, it seemed clear to me that this "two hour" season finale was written to be two seperate episodes, the first ending with everyone prepared for Linsey's trial and the 'resolution' of Rebecca's case.
As for the final verdict, they clearly revealed (at least to me) that it was going to be guilty with the ominous music they had playing while everyone was sitting waiting for the verdict to be read. I saw no "twist" like every one is talking about here. (though, to be honest, when I saw Laroquette's name in the list of guest stars thought the twist would be he'd show up at the end and imply he was "the other man". I'm very glad that sort of twist didn't happen.)
As for the final verdict, they clearly revealed (at least to me) that it was going to be guilty with the ominous music they had playing while everyone was sitting waiting for the verdict to be read. I saw no "twist" like every one is talking about here. (though, to be honest, when I saw Laroquette's name in the list of guest stars thought the twist would be he'd show up at the end and imply he was "the other man". I'm very glad that sort of twist didn't happen.)
#11
DVD Talk Legend
I had a long response to type up... but it basically repeats all of the points that WarriorPrincess makes.
As with most of the season, the writing on the finale was weak and the story was predictable. This show was interesting and fun when it started, but (like most David Kelley shows) after a few years it is now spiraling out of control. The performances are strong, but the scripts are just phoned in. Waste of time.
I think I'll probably be dropping this show (and possibly Enterprise) for next season.
As with most of the season, the writing on the finale was weak and the story was predictable. This show was interesting and fun when it started, but (like most David Kelley shows) after a few years it is now spiraling out of control. The performances are strong, but the scripts are just phoned in. Waste of time.
I think I'll probably be dropping this show (and possibly Enterprise) for next season.
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 1,180
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NYC Metro
I love The Practice, but agree the scripts have been pretty weak lately. David E. Kelley might want to focus on one show instead of juggling three. I would also type alot, but...just read WarriorPrincess' reply. Guess I'm just phoning it in now too...




