Make a Bold Statement About Music
#151
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
You want a bold statement, here's one. This whole idea that you have to go out and look for good music is straight up bullshit. Music was a hell of a lot better when it was a shared experience. It's a lot more exciting to be part of something larger than life than to have this treasured secret that only a select few will ever enjoy.
#152
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Pink Floyd is boring as fuck if your not on any drugs. Zeppelin are a bunch of plagerists,and listening to a lot of pre 1960s Blues and then trying to relisten to artists like Zeppelin,The Stones and Cream is weird. They are pretty much the Iggy Azalea's of their time.
#154
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music

But as a five-album run, I'd still put it behind Rubber Soul, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper, MMT, and the White Album. But not that far behind.
#155
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Prince - Dirty Mind - Controversy - 1999 - Purple Rain
#157
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
#158
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
My take on Beatles vs. Kinks on those 5-album runs (and I love both):
Rubber Soul vs. Something Else? Rubber Soul. It's an extraordinary album, a game-changer not just for The Beatles but for the concept of album rock as a whole. Something Else is a fantastic album too, the moment where The Kinks really came into their own as a unique band more at home in the world of British folk, pub, and dance-hall than "simple" Invasion blues rock (although "Face To Face" would be just as welcome in this album run).
Revolver vs. VGPS? Son of a bitch... tough one. Revolver, for me, by a hair. You really can't go wrong with either. Both are magnificent.
Sgt. Pepper vs. Arthur? Arthur. Pepper has higher highs but also lower lows. Arthur is much more consistent and overall a stronger album.
MMT vs. Lola v Powerman? Side 2 of MMT alone beats ALL of Lola v. Powerman.
White Album vs. Muswell? White Album for its eccentric, chaotic genius but Muswell is far from
any slouch. It's a classic album in its own right, and the last time The Kinks were every totally brilliant from start to finish.
All in my opinion, of course.
Rubber Soul vs. Something Else? Rubber Soul. It's an extraordinary album, a game-changer not just for The Beatles but for the concept of album rock as a whole. Something Else is a fantastic album too, the moment where The Kinks really came into their own as a unique band more at home in the world of British folk, pub, and dance-hall than "simple" Invasion blues rock (although "Face To Face" would be just as welcome in this album run).
Revolver vs. VGPS? Son of a bitch... tough one. Revolver, for me, by a hair. You really can't go wrong with either. Both are magnificent.
Sgt. Pepper vs. Arthur? Arthur. Pepper has higher highs but also lower lows. Arthur is much more consistent and overall a stronger album.
MMT vs. Lola v Powerman? Side 2 of MMT alone beats ALL of Lola v. Powerman.
White Album vs. Muswell? White Album for its eccentric, chaotic genius but Muswell is far from
any slouch. It's a classic album in its own right, and the last time The Kinks were every totally brilliant from start to finish.
All in my opinion, of course.
#159
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
That's just it, because Piper kind of stands apart from the rest of their catalogue, there are actually plenty of people who have no interest in post-Syd Floyd that love it. Along with Sgt. Pepper, Piper is considered by many to be the absolute pinnacle of 60's psychedelic pop. I'd argue that depending on one's personal tastes, Dark Side, The Wall, and Piper are the three most "accepted" answers for best Floyd album.
#160
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Those three are definately better than the Kinks run.
Zeppelin seems to be getting trashed a lot in here, but I'll take LZ I through House of the Holy over the Kinks any day.
Zeppelin seems to be getting trashed a lot in here, but I'll take LZ I through House of the Holy over the Kinks any day.
Last edited by hdnmickey; 10-23-14 at 04:29 PM.
#161
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Hell, you could include Face to Face ('66) and call it a 6-album run. I think it goes neck and neck with the Beatles (Rubber Soul to Abbey Road).
#163
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Five album runs?
The Grand Wazoo
Over-Nite Sensation
Apostrophe (')
Roxy & Elsewhere
One Size Fits All

Lola is hands down a better LP than Muswell.
The Grand Wazoo
Over-Nite Sensation
Apostrophe (')
Roxy & Elsewhere
One Size Fits All

Lola v Powerman is a really good album, but it's easily the weakest link in an otherwise near-flawless run. Plus you're ignoring Percy... not that I blame you 
But as a five-album run, I'd still put it behind Rubber Soul, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper, MMT, and the White Album. But not that far behind.

But as a five-album run, I'd still put it behind Rubber Soul, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper, MMT, and the White Album. But not that far behind.
#164
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
I also think Lola vs is one of their stronger ones.Love them both too, and I've been familiar with all 10 albums since the mid-'80s, or so, and I just haven't gotten tired of the Kinks albums like I have the Beatles albums, for some reason.
Also, I didn't mean to compare them 1 for 1, but all 5 as a whole. And honestly, while those 5 Beatles albums reach higher heights, they also have far lower lows than the Kinks stuff.
Though I'd still put the Stones ahead of the Beatles, and say that they have the best four consecutive album run*.
*Beggars Banquet, Let it Bleed, Sticky Fingers, Exile on Main St.
Also, I didn't mean to compare them 1 for 1, but all 5 as a whole. And honestly, while those 5 Beatles albums reach higher heights, they also have far lower lows than the Kinks stuff.
Though I'd still put the Stones ahead of the Beatles, and say that they have the best four consecutive album run*.
*Beggars Banquet, Let it Bleed, Sticky Fingers, Exile on Main St.
#166
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
#168
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Bringing it all Back Home
Highway 61 Revisited
Blonde on Blonde
John Wesley Harding
#169
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Oh ye gods, this is a great one. Tumbleweed, Madman, and Honky Chateau are pretty peerless, and Yellow Brick Road is just one of those great self-indulgent double albums in the Exile, Key Of Life, White Album, Something/Anything vein. Don't Shoot Me... though, is a bit wonky.
#170
DVD Talk Reviewer & TOAT Winner
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Speaking of that:
The White Album is a mess. Its official title "The Beatles" is ironic as most of the songs were NOT done by the Beatles as a group, more as individual members doing their own tracks and throwing them together on a 2-record set. It was a sure sign that the Beatles would soon be coming to an end.
The White Album is a mess. Its official title "The Beatles" is ironic as most of the songs were NOT done by the Beatles as a group, more as individual members doing their own tracks and throwing them together on a 2-record set. It was a sure sign that the Beatles would soon be coming to an end.
#172
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
Greatest five album run:
Roxy Music
For Your Pleasure
Stranded
Country Life
Siren
Unbelievable consistancy of vision and quality.
Roxy Music
For Your Pleasure
Stranded
Country Life
Siren
Unbelievable consistancy of vision and quality.
#173
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
I prefer the slightly less-harsh Killing Joke--I could never get into Revelations. My favorite run of theirs would be Fire Dances, Night Time, and Brighter Than a Thousand Suns. Really amazing stuff.
#174
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Make a Bold Statement About Music
I'll see your five album streaks, and raise ya one...
Queen
Queen II
Sheer Heart Attack
A Night at the Opera
A Day at the Races
News of the World
Hell, even Jazz was a pretty darn good album.
Queen
Queen II
Sheer Heart Attack
A Night at the Opera
A Day at the Races
News of the World
Hell, even Jazz was a pretty darn good album.




) Raw power from piano, bass, and drums.