How will this decade be remembered music wise?
#77
DVD Talk Legend
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I'll remember it for the death of sound quality. The loudness war has really hurt the quality of many modern recordings, and throughout the last decade, it has extended its reach to many catalog titles that have been remastered. Even jazz albums have been affected.
Then you have the public's acceptance of low-bitrate MP3/AAC and online streaming, and stock earbuds to listen to them on. Music became exclusively a background activity for many people. Record companies are catering to this lowest common denominator, and damaging the music for those who actually take the time to listen at home on decent equipment. Higher resolution formats like SACD and DVD-Audio failed to catch on outside of a niche market.
There are some good signs, though. Vinyl has had a resurgence, even though part of the reason it can sound better is because they aren't mastering the CDs properly. (Of course, vinyl vs. CD quality is very debatable.
) Some sites are now offering lossless downloads, and hopefully all online sellers will follow suit as bandwidth and storage increase.
Then you have the public's acceptance of low-bitrate MP3/AAC and online streaming, and stock earbuds to listen to them on. Music became exclusively a background activity for many people. Record companies are catering to this lowest common denominator, and damaging the music for those who actually take the time to listen at home on decent equipment. Higher resolution formats like SACD and DVD-Audio failed to catch on outside of a niche market.
There are some good signs, though. Vinyl has had a resurgence, even though part of the reason it can sound better is because they aren't mastering the CDs properly. (Of course, vinyl vs. CD quality is very debatable.
) Some sites are now offering lossless downloads, and hopefully all online sellers will follow suit as bandwidth and storage increase.
#78
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
Remastering has also ruined recording after recording, a good example being the Led Zeppelin remasters.
Last edited by Hiro11; 12-06-09 at 08:38 AM.
#79
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I don't know if it's the fault of the record companies. I don't think the record companies are really dictating anything. From what I hear, the record companies are basically in limbo and are just going with the flow.
It's the people who are choosing ease and convenience over quality.
#80
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
The real bottom line is that this was a decade without a universal identity, at least in the world of Rock music. I look at people's list of the "Best Albums of the Decade" and I have to laugh. I haven't even heard of half these artists and I subscribe to three music magazines. Not that the music isn't good, but there no longer seems to be a communal aspect to rock and popular music. Remember how everyone was so shocked about Michael Jackson's death? Part of that was because he was from an era where music was far more universal; everyone either had his album or at least knew it really well. Those days seem to be gone.
When I say "50's Music?" to you, you say "Elvis. Buddy Holly. Chuck Berry"
60s? -- Beatles, Stones, Dylan, The Who
70s? -- Led Zep, Pink Floyd, Eagles, Bowie, Fleetwood Mac, Elton John
80s? -- Michael Jackson, Police, Prince, Madonna, Early U2, REM
90s? -- Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Smashing Pumpkins, Beck, Green Day
What about this decade? Coldplay? Radiohead? I don't know. Nothing really springs to mind as being decade-defining music. And I don't think that's just a lack of perspective; it's really a change in the Rock music scene.
When I say "50's Music?" to you, you say "Elvis. Buddy Holly. Chuck Berry"
60s? -- Beatles, Stones, Dylan, The Who
70s? -- Led Zep, Pink Floyd, Eagles, Bowie, Fleetwood Mac, Elton John
80s? -- Michael Jackson, Police, Prince, Madonna, Early U2, REM
90s? -- Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Smashing Pumpkins, Beck, Green Day
What about this decade? Coldplay? Radiohead? I don't know. Nothing really springs to mind as being decade-defining music. And I don't think that's just a lack of perspective; it's really a change in the Rock music scene.
#81
Banned by request
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I kind of see them in the way I see The Flaming Lips. I've been listening to both since 1995, but both feel like 00's bands to me. Perhaps it feels more like the made the decade theirs, as opposed to when the albums were released. I would never say the 90's belonged to The Flaming Lips or Radiohead.
#82
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
It's probably not quite as bad as it's made out to be, but it still lacks a big identity, and is the worst decade for mainstream music.
#83
DVD Talk Legend
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
My comment about the stigma of the '80's has to do with the majority of people thinking that the music during that time was awful, because most people associate the '80's with the retro/pop music that was all over the place. The '80's most certainly had fantastic albums, as evidenced by the posts after mine, but those albums aren't generally what people think of when you talk about '80's music.
I was just wondering if this decade would get that kind of association, despite the fantastic albums that have come out over the past 10 years.
It's difficult to sum up a decade's worth of music, encompassing all genres, into a simple sentence.
I was just wondering if this decade would get that kind of association, despite the fantastic albums that have come out over the past 10 years.
It's difficult to sum up a decade's worth of music, encompassing all genres, into a simple sentence.
#84
Banned by request
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I think the stigma surrounding the 80's lifted this decade, as you can find an appreciation of 80's music this decade, along with 80's retro coming back in style. Same as how the 70's became big again in the late 90's.
#85
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#86
DVD Talk Godfather
#87
DVD Talk Hero
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
My comment about the stigma of the '80's has to do with the majority of people thinking that the music during that time was awful, because most people associate the '80's with the retro/pop music that was all over the place. The '80's most certainly had fantastic albums, as evidenced by the posts after mine, but those albums aren't generally what people think of when you talk about '80's music.
I've said here many times, that the '80s has the best and worst music of the century. The first few years of the '80s (really 1978 - 1983, aka the "New Wave" era) was the best music of the century. The synth had just been made available to musicians and began a musical revolution, much the way the electric guitar had years earlier. Coming off the coat-tails of punk and alongside goth, the music was very minor key, dark and foreboding (Numan, early Ultravox, OMD & Human League, etc.)
But unfortunately, that meant that every Tom, Dick & Harry band or artist jumped on the synth bandwagon and started making music. And with the less talented came the shittier music. And synth music changed from dark and forbidding to bright and cheesy (with even bands such as OMD & The Human League selling out to that style). THAT is the music we all mock when we say "'80s music".
Unfortunately, the early '80s stuff is lost to most except those that were there, or real music fans who seek it out (and don't just accept whatever is handed to them on a mainstream compilation CD).
#88
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
But unfortunately, that meant that every Tom, Dick & Harry band or artist jumped on the synth bandwagon and started making music. And with the less talented came the shittier music. And synth music changed from dark and forbidding to bright and cheesy (with even bands such as OMD & The Human League selling out to that style). THAT is the music we all mock when we say "'80s music".

<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/zDrJKmrOo2s&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/zDrJKmrOo2s&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>
I don't think the stereotypical 80s cheese new wave is all so bad though. Human League I think actually IMPROVED over their early stuff with Dare. I've listened to the original band and don't like it at all.
I've tried listening to a lot of "early new wave" and none really do much for me besides Japan. Are there any others close to them? I know duran duran is an obvious choice but they were poppier and just lifted things from them.
Last edited by statcat; 12-06-09 at 10:15 PM.
#89
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
Anyway, to me, whatever decade the band got their start and made their mark in fame wise first - which again in this case with Radiohead is still the 90's - is the one they ultimately belong to.
Oasis put out more albums this decade than the last, yet that doesn't make than an '00 band. R.E.M. released almost as many albums in the 90's as they did the 80's - but do you see them being referred to as a 90's band. Do you consider Aerosmith a 70's, 80's or 90's band? Even though they certainly had just as many hits in the 80's/90's (and were perhaps, even more popular) than they did in the 70's, to me I'll always associate them with the 70's, first.
Doesn't mean that a band can't move beyond just one decade for popularity, but still, the association will always be with their debut one.
Last edited by Rocketdog2000; 12-06-09 at 10:39 PM.
#91
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
It takes either actually living through a particular decade or at least doing your own digging in the past to break through the common stigmas.
#92
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I think decades tend to be stigmatized by their cultural excesses, and usually the worst excesses. For example, a lot of people think the '70s were nothing but disco music, bad hairdos, and garish fashions; and a lot of people think the '80s were nothing but bad perms, synthesizer-based pop music and cheesy hair metal bands.
It takes either actually living through a particular decade or at least doing your own digging in the past to break through the common stigmas.
It takes either actually living through a particular decade or at least doing your own digging in the past to break through the common stigmas.
#93
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
Released more albums? Ok one more album than the prior decade, so technically, yes. More popular? I'd say just as, not more so. Output better, though? There I'm going to have to differ, as that's completely debatable. With the exception of In Rainbows, there's no album they've released this decade, on the whole, that is better than The Bends or OK Computer in my book. I only like about half of Kid A, about the same of Amnesiacand even less of Hail To The Thief. Even then, though, it still doesn't give enough justification to label them more of an '00 band than a 90's one.
/old fart contrarian.
#95
Banned by request
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I agree that The Bends is the best Radiohead album, but I really liked Kid A and remember it being a huge deal when it came out. I actually prefer that album to OK Computer. Amnesiac and Hail to the Thief did nothing for me, but I enjoyed In Rainbows.
#96
DVD Talk Hero
#97
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
Yes, but you could say that's also because they've had more records to sell, too. Still doesn't change anything. With his passing, Michael Jackson has sold more records this year than in the past ten years. By your logic, does that justify him now being an '00 artist, as well? Don't think so.
Last edited by Rocketdog2000; 12-08-09 at 12:40 AM.
#98
DVD Talk Legend
#99
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: How will this decade be remembered music wise?
I'd guess that this decade will be looked at as a sort of Dark Ages, when compared with decades in the past, and hopefully decades in the future.



