DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Music Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk-28/)
-   -   MusicTalk Draft Game – Draft Thread (All are welcome to play!) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/music-talk/442618-musictalk-draft-game-%96-draft-thread-all-welcome-play.html)

Giles 11-03-05 12:34 PM


Originally Posted by maxfisher

2) The matchups. IMHO, nobody has a 'bad' list and there are more than a few I'd say are great. Depending on who's facing off each round, there are a decent number of lists I could see making it to the final round.

not mine ;) cause my tenth album is going to be just come completely out of left field and quite frankly ruin me from winning - I'm doing this list just to have some fun and really reflect my taste in music. The game's premise is to one up each other's list in music and cull from a pool of already well established artists - I am not condoning people's choice in music, but for the most part it's a laundry list of MOR artists that critics and fans have been praising for years. Sure I'm guilty of it as well, but if we were to do another ten album round I think it would be very interesting to see what lists would be made if we couldn't relist or repeat the artists from this first Top Ten List.

auto 11-03-05 12:35 PM


Originally Posted by cdollaz
How does voting work? I am assuming it will be polls, so that votes can be anonymous.

Nope. There is no way to set up a poll with this many options. Check out the TVTalk Draft threads if you want to see how the voting will work.

The Bus 11-03-05 12:35 PM

Sony's boxset Soundtrack for a Century is still available.

500 artists, a hundred years of music. 26 CDs.

Sure, it's a cop-out. But it's a well-packaged cop-out.

The Bus 11-03-05 12:36 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
not mine ;) cause my tenth album is going to be just come completely out of left field and quite frankly ruin me from winning - I'm doing this list just to have some fun and really reflect my taste in music. The game's premise is to one up each other's list in music and cull from a pool of already well established artists - I am not condoning people's choice in music, but for the most part it's a laundry list of MOR artists that critics and fans have been praising for years. Sure I'm guilty of it as well, but if we were to do another ten album round I think it would be very interesting to see what lists would be made if we couldn't relist or repeat the artists from this first Top Ten List.

I think that's an awesome idea, actually.

auto 11-03-05 12:38 PM


Originally Posted by The Bus
I think that's an awesome idea, actually.

I was actually thinking the same thing. I wasn't sure how many people would be interested since you couldn't pick all the normal favorites (i.e. Beatles, Stones, Clash, Zeppelin, etc.).

Fandango 11-03-05 12:38 PM

Round 9: Cannibal Ox - The Cold Vein

cdollaz 11-03-05 12:40 PM


Originally Posted by auto
Nope. There is no way to set up a poll with this many options. Check out the TVTalk Draft threads if you want to see how the voting will work.

OK. I didn't pay much attention to the TV one so I don't know how it works. I hope it didn't get into a bunch of "you didn't vote for me, so I'm not voting for you" crap.

Giles 11-03-05 12:40 PM


Originally Posted by auto
I was actually thinking the same thing. I wasn't sure how many people would be interested since you couldn't pick all the normal favorites (i.e. Beatles, Stones, Clash, Zeppelin, etc.).

now that would be a challenge :eyebrow:

illennium 11-03-05 12:42 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
...if we were to do another ten album round I think it would be very interesting to see what lists would be made if we couldn't relist or repeat the artists from this first Top Ten List.

I'm in. :up:

maxfisher 11-03-05 12:44 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
not mine ;) cause my tenth album is going to be just come completely out of left field and quite frankly ruin me from winning - I'm doing this list just to have some fun and really reflect my taste in music. The game's premise is to one up each other's list in music and cull from a pool of already well established artists - I am not condoning people's choice in music, but for the most part it's a laundry list of MOR artists that critics and fans have been praising for years. Sure I'm guilty of it as well, but if we were to do another ten album round I think it would be very interesting to see what lists would be made if we couldn't relist or repeat the artists from this first Top Ten List.

Who knows though? You might pick a guilty pleasure that a bunch of us love but just don't have the balls to put on our lists.... :D

As for the follow up game with this game's picks ruled out, I think it's a great idea, but I'd say we take a couple weeks off between them. At some point, there could also be drafts specific to a certain decade or of songs instead of albums...

auto 11-03-05 12:45 PM


Originally Posted by cdollaz
OK. I didn't pay much attention to the TV one so I don't know how it works. I hope it didn't get into a bunch of "you didn't vote for me, so I'm not voting for you" crap.

Everybody was pretty cool about the whole game.

From what I can gather from an internet forum :rolleyes:, everybody playing in this draft seems pretty laid back and cool. I don't think we'll have a problem.

auto 11-03-05 12:47 PM


Originally Posted by maxfisher
Who knows though? You might pick a guilty pleasure that a bunch of us love but just don't have the balls to put on our lists.... :D

As for the follow up game with this game's picks ruled out, I think it's a great idea, but I'd say we take a couple weeks off between them. At some point, there could also be drafts specific to a certain decade or of songs instead of albums...

I agree that we should take a little break after this draft.

I had already begun to think about a draft of individual songs. The Ultimate Mixtape Draft Game?

cleaver 11-03-05 12:48 PM


Originally Posted by The Bus
It's probably a bit too early to make predictions, but I think cleaver's collection is the most well-rounded and most well-known. I can easily see him go all the way or get made fun of for having two greatest hits albums. :)


Originally Posted by Mordred
Yeah, screw cleaver and his cheap-ass tactic! ;)

Depends on what he's up against, because I like almost all of his list. Might have to vote for him inspite of the GHs albums.

What's my other greatest hits album besides Hot Rocks, which I drafted before I realized no one was drafting greatest hits albums.


Originally Posted by The Bus
I don't know if I have a personal preference yet. If you were to have this as a poll on USA Today, I think cleaver would win. Not to put down cleaver or anything. :)


Originally Posted by Giles
USA Today or Rolling Stone magazine for that matter.

Strangely enough auto is ahead in the BCS.


Originally Posted by The Bus
The fact that is went through eight rounds before being picked is a travesty. I didn't think it would last this long, but I pick:

Genius/GZA - Liquid Swords

(IMO one of the best albums, period).

When I have a kid I'm going to put a football and a tutu in front of him, and say "choose the football and you will join me. Choose the tutu and you will join ryuryu2949 at a WNBA game."

Giles 11-03-05 12:49 PM


Originally Posted by maxfisher
Who knows though? You might pick a guilty pleasure that a bunch of us love but just don't have the balls to put on our lists.... :D

As for the follow up game with this game's picks ruled out, I think it's a great idea, but I'd say we take a couple weeks off between them. At some point, there could also be drafts specific to a certain decade or of songs instead of albums...

let's just say it's a genre - no one's mentioned. I'll give you a hint - it's a soundtrack.

A "song" list would be cool.

cdollaz 11-03-05 12:50 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
now that would be a challenge :eyebrow:

Yeah, that would be fun. Looking over my list for this draft, I still have 22 artists on my list that have not had an album drafted yet.

auto 11-03-05 12:51 PM


Originally Posted by cleaver
Strangely enough auto is ahead in the BCS.


When I have a kid I'm going to put a football and a tutu in front of him, and say "choose the football and you will join me. Choose the tutu and you will join ryuryu2949 at a WNBA game."

I give up. I have no idea what either of those two statements mean. :shrug:

Damfino 11-03-05 12:53 PM


Originally Posted by auto
Nope. All picks must be official releases.

OK, for the record it wasn't the Basement Tapes, but I was thinking of using The Gray Album as my no. 10.

Giles 11-03-05 12:53 PM


Originally Posted by auto
I give up. I have no idea what either of those two statements mean. :shrug:


same here - BCS ???

cleaver 11-03-05 12:55 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
same here - BCS ???

USA Today has a college football poll that is a factor in determining the Bowl Championship Series standings by computer which is used to determine who plays for the National Championship.

The other thing is paraphrased from Liquid Swords.

Hiro11 11-03-05 12:56 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
I am not condoning people's choice in music, but for the most part it's a laundry list of MOR artists that critics and fans have been praising for years. Sure I'm guilty of it as well...

...or maybe people just really love the music on their list. I get your point, but just because an album is critically or commercially successful doesn't preclude it from being a personal favorite.


...but if we were to do another ten album round I think it would be very interesting to see what lists would be made if we couldn't relist or repeat the artists from this first Top Ten List.
Now that's an idea I like. Like my johnson, my depth chart is long and distinguished.

auto 11-03-05 12:56 PM


Originally Posted by Damfino
OK, for the record it wasn't the Basement Tapes, but I was thinking of using The Gray Album as my no. 10.

I like your thinking but I think allowing bootlegs would cause too many questions.

These days, what constitutes a bootleg?

illennium 11-03-05 12:57 PM

Voting will be challenging because there are quite a few albums on the list that I haven't heard--Soul Coughing, X, Yaz, Kate Bush, Tift Merritt, and at least 10 others. With the DVD draft, I had either seen all the movies or at least had a very good sense whether or not I would like them. But with some of these albums, I have nothing to go on. I could love them or hate them.

cleaver 11-03-05 12:57 PM


Originally Posted by Hiro11
Like my johnson, my depth chart is long and distinguished.

Also like my DVD collection.

Damfino 11-03-05 12:58 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
same here - BCS ???

BCS = Bowl Championship Series. It's the convoluted formula for screwing up College football's National Championship

auto 11-03-05 12:58 PM


Originally Posted by cleaver
USA Today has a college football poll that is a factor in determining the Bowl Championship Series standings by computer which is used to determine who plays for the National Championship.

In that case, :up:!

:beer:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:53 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.